Rubin (2002) analysed the consequences of death penalty and asked the question “Will an execution have the effect of deterring other potential murders, or will it merely satisfy some desire for vengeance?” In his article Rubin tries to relate the homicide rates and the death penalty in trying to find out whether having the capital punishment actually deters homicide.
Rubin (2002) argued that comparing the homicide rates may not be a good idea because according to him the rates of homicides are totally dependent on other issues like income gaps, racial compositions and urbanisation. He went ahead and argued that;
A state may have capital punishment precisely because it has a higher murder rate and is trying to control this evil. In such a case, observing capital punishment and a high murder rate says nothing about causality, and the deterrence argument is that rates would be even higher if there were no capital punishment. (Rubin 2002).
If his argument is anything to go by, it is easier to conclude that the homicide rates are not determined by the punishment frameworks in place. But later in his paper Rubin described a research he conducted in which he discovered that indeed...
... middle of paper ...
...lin, Steven. (1978). Deterrence and Social Control Source: American Sociological Review. Vol. 43 (2)
Litwak, Eugene. Three ways in which the law Acts as a Means of Social Control: Punishment, Therapy and Education.
National Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty. Death Penalty Overview: Ten Reasons Why Capital Punishment is Flawed Public Policy. Retrieved from http://www.ncadp.org/index.cfm?content=5
Radelet, Michaell and Lacock, Tracil. Recent Developmentss. Do Executions Lower Homicide Rates?: The Views of Leading Criminologists. Retrieved from http://www.deathpenaltyinfo.org/files/DeterrenceStudy2009.pdf
Rubin, Paul. 2002. The Death Penalty and Deterrence. EBSCO Publishing
Steele, Tracey and Wilcox Norma. 2003. A View From the Inside: The Role of
Redemption, Deterrence, and Masculinity on Inmate Support for the Death Penalty Crime & Deliquecy Vol. 49 (2).
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- ... The death penalty has been proven to be a costly punishment that costs much more than a regular sentence as the author states “Jon Corzine and the state legislature, the 13-member New Jersey Death Penalty Study Commission concluded that life imprisonment in a maximum security facility without the possibility of parole would be less costly than the death penalty”. With this in mind, the article as well states that “The death penalty does deterrent and has a disparate impact on the poor”. This recommends starting a fund for the families of murder victims because through the current justice system and the appeals to arrive can mean that for a convicted felon to be sentenced and a final ve... [tags: Capital punishment, Death row]
1690 words (4.8 pages)
- The question of ethical behavior is an age-old conundrum. The prevailing issue with ethics is that it is extremely difficult to measure. A person’s moral fabric is largely based on their particular personality traits, as well as, their psychological state and environmental influences. Many believe that ethics are tied to a person’s conscience, and that good morals are often facilitated by a strong religious background. Furthermore, a person’s moral development can be linked to their economic situation and cultural differences.... [tags: capital punishment, death penalty]
1277 words (3.6 pages)
- ... All of these facts support von Drehle’s assertment that capital punishment is losing momentum, but von Drehle closes this part of the argument by telling readers that only 72 courts imposed the death penalty in 2014, and all but two of the nation’s forty-nine executions have been carried out by only five states, despite the fact that execution is legal in thirty-one. He continues on to explain why, first asserting that the U.S., as a country, still isn’t improving in regards to methods of execution.... [tags: Capital punishment, Murder, Prison, Death row]
1746 words (5 pages)
- ... The American Civil Liberties Union trusts capital punishment naturally damages the established boycott against unfeeling and strange discipline and the assurances of due procedure of law and of equivalent security under the law. Moreover, we trust that the state should not to give itself the privilege to slaughter individuals – particularly when it murders with deliberation and function, for the law 's sake or for the sake of its kin, and when it does as such in a discretionary and oppressive design.... [tags: Capital punishment, Crime, Prison, Death row]
1047 words (3 pages)
- Capital punishment was the most severe punishment within the Canadian Justice system before it was abolished in the 1970’s. It is still used in many other countries around the world such as the United States, China and India, as it is believed to lower the crime rate within their country. Capital punishment was basically a form of torturing the suspect, but to their death as a consequence of their heinous crime. Many believe that capital punishment should be reinstated into Canada, while others are strongly against the suggestion and I believe the same.... [tags: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty]
1248 words (3.6 pages)
- Death Penalty Historically, death penalty was used as the most severe punishment available if a person disobeyed the laws or committed murder. The death penalty also known as capital punishment is the judicially ordered execution of a prisoner for an extremely serious crime. The rate of violent crimes in the United States is one of the highest, despite the fact that the United States has one of the harsher penal systems in the world. The courts have generally seen their task as fitting the punishment to the crime perpetrated.... [tags: capital punishment]
1343 words (3.8 pages)
- Life and the Death Penalty Does the death penalty support the value of life. The death penalty has been utilized as a form of punishment for serious crimes since there was a division of people on social levels. According to the National Library of Crime in the article “Origins of Capital Punishment”, there are records that indicate its existence as early as 1760 BC. (1) During this time, the methods that carried out the death penalty included hanging, beheading, and being crushed by an elephant.... [tags: serious crimes, punishment, morals]
1559 words (4.5 pages)
- The death penalty is one of the most controversial issues we have in our country today. The people are divided between supporting and opposing the death penalty. The supporters would say that it is a deterrent for future crimes. They would also say that taxpayer dollars are not going to pay for the care of these individuals. The opposition would say that the cost of the death penalty is actually higher than the cost of a life sentence. They also find that the deterrent argument is debatable. (meggiem, 2012) There is evidence that contradicts the supporters’ claims.... [tags: social and economic costs]
612 words (1.7 pages)
- The death penalty or capital punishment is an issue that has sparked controversy and anxiety in today’s society. Capital punishment refers to “a sentence of death by execution”, for the crimes committed. In order to receive the death penalty an individual needs to commit certain types of crimes known as “capital crimes” or “capital offences”. Capital crimes include treason, perjury, kidnapping, rape, terrorism and murder. Today, executions are carried out by either a lethal injection or electrocution.... [tags: Capital Punishment Essays]
1052 words (3 pages)
- Costs and Consequences of the Death Penalty, written by Mark Costanzo, neatly lists reasons for opposition, and abolishment of, the death penalty. Costanzo provides a review of the history of the death penalty, a review of how the death penalty process is working today, questions on whether or not if the death penalty is inhumane and cheaper than life imprisonment. He also questions if the death penalty is fairly applied and the impact, if any, that it has on deterrence. He closely examines the public's support of the death penalty and questions the morality of the death penalty.... [tags: essays research papers]
1189 words (3.4 pages)