Immigration Policy: Challenging Its Myths Essay

Immigration Policy: Challenging Its Myths Essay

Length: 2268 words (6.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Immigration Policy: Challenging Its Myths

America is a nation of immigrants. Yet, Americans have not always been happy with new immigrants. Benjamin Franklin worried that German immigrants would crowd out America’s British culture. In the 1840s, mostly Roman Catholic Irish immigrants provoked the first organized anti-foreign movement. At the turn of the century, new immigrants from Italy and Poland were seen too different to become Americans. These days, Latino and Asian immigrants are inflaming same fears and criticism.
Since Congress began placing restrictions on new immigration, controversies over immigration policy have never ceased for more than a century. Whatever the rhetoric surrounding immigration policy, the public debate comes down to whether new immigrants are eating away our pie or not. Immigration proponents argue that immigration shores up the American economy, while opponents charge new immigrants undermine our economic potential. The conflicting views at both ends of the spectrum are attributable to a myriad of myths on which the immigration policy is based.
As I examine the truth and myths about our immigration policy, I found two major differences between the rival assertions. First, their perspectives on immigration are totally different. Proponents view immigration from global, long-term, and multi-cultural perspective, while opponents focus more on local, short-term, and acculturation viewpoints. Second, most opponents misread the reality. Pro-immigration segments were more receptive to the changing trends, whereas, anti-immigration segments, especially politicians, were politically and emotionally driven. To forge a sound immigration policy, we should not base it on myths, but on a compelling ...


... middle of paper ...


...s and Facts’,

Ghadar, Fariborz. Dec. 11, 2012. ‘Dispel the immigration myths’,


Saxenian, AnnaLee, 1999, ‘Silicon Valley’s New Immigrant Entrepreneurs. San Francisco: Public Policy Institute of California.

Welcome Dayton, 2014 < http://www.welcomedayton.org/about/ >

Welcoming Michigan, 2014 learn-more>

West, Darrel. Aug. 11, 2010. ‘Seven Myths that Cloud Immigration Debate’, USA Today,
http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/opinion/forum/2010-09-01-column01_ST1_N.htm?csp=obinsite

White House, June 20, 2007. ‘Immigration’s Economic Impact’, < http://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/cea/cea_immigration_062007.html>



Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Immigration And The Canadian Immigration Policy Essay

- Immigration has played a large role in Canada’s history, and essentially has crafted the Canadian identity. Each time Canada’s immigration policy changed so did the flow and contextual backdrop of immigrants and thus the uniqueness of Canada (Passaris, 1998). Canadian immigration and essentially immigration policy is a multifaceted composition of an interrelated “set of guidelines, regulations and actions by government agents” (Green & Green, 2004). The economic forces of immigration have played a large role in influencing Canadian immigration policies over Canada’s large and vast immigration history and three major intentions are emphasized....   [tags: Immigration, Immigration to the United States]

Strong Essays
1643 words (4.7 pages)

Immigration Policy Is Illegal Immigration Essay

- The chapter “Immigration” by Richard T. Schaefer discusses the immigration status in the United States. The number of immigrants had dramatically changed due to the government policy. The immigration policy changed a lot in the American history such as Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, Emergency Quota Act of 1921, and Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965.These policies changed the patterns of immigration to the United States. Also, Richard discusses the immigration policy today. The current immigration policies are less restrictive than before, so there are a lot of people can immigrate to the United States....   [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]

Strong Essays
1047 words (3 pages)

The Best Immigration Policy or the Worst? Essay

- The Best Immigration Policy or the Worst The Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (IRCA) is viewed as one of the most important policy implementations in U.S. immigration history. As drafted, IRCA proposed to be a policy to control and deter all illegal immigration into the U.S., but the policy was truly directed at stopping the flow of Mexican immigrants that continues to be the largest immigration flow in the world. Daniel Tichenor writes in Dividing Lines that, “Originally designed as a restrictive enforcement measure, IRCA proved to be surprisingly expansive in both design and effect.” By identifying the unintended consequences of the law, this paper explores why the policy faile...   [tags: Immigration ]

Strong Essays
2370 words (6.8 pages)

Essay on Immigration Reform : The Current Immigration Policy

- Immigration Reform The current immigration policy is badly in need of repairing. Its harsh treatment of immigrates has created mistrust between citizens and law enforcement, is costly in terms of clean environment, resources and human lives. Fixing this policy will vastly improve living situations for both citizens and immigrants. Although illegal immigration is against the federal law, many states believe that the government isn’t doing a very good job enforcing it. Some states, like Arizona, have came up with their own attempt in order to compensate for this issue....   [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]

Strong Essays
1268 words (3.6 pages)

Immigration Policy : A Nation Of Immigrants Essay

- The United States has always been known as a nation of immigrants; however as of late, the policy enacted upon immigrants does not seem to reflect that ideology. In order to understand how to effectively write immigration policy, it is important to acknowledge the history, politics, and philosophy of such legislation. Particularly in the last ten years, congress has worked on a lot of immigration policy like the Dream Act, a piece of legislation that worked to provide citizenship to undocumented immigrants....   [tags: Immigration, Immigration to the United States]

Strong Essays
1285 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on The Immigration Policy Of The United States

- There may not be a more politicized issue in America than illegal immigration. People from all over the world travel to the United States to better their lives for themselves and/or their families, whether that be through education or job opportunities. Unfortunately, legislators from all across the country have tried, and failed, to pass laws reforming the immigration policy of the United States. In recent years, President Obama has issued an Executive Order granting amnesty to millions of illegal immigrants, a bipartisan group of senators crafted an immigration reform package, and President Bush attempted to pass illegal immigration reform....   [tags: Immigration, Immigration to the United States]

Strong Essays
804 words (2.3 pages)

The Development Of Canadian Immigration Policy Essay

- This book is written from an economic perspective by three economics professor emeritus at Queen’s university, all three of them has a PHD from world’s prominent universities such as Harvard and Princeton. The purpose of the book is to inform readers in political science, public policy, governmental agency, and immigration studies of the changes and how to improve in immigration policy notably in skilled workers. It gives a statistic reference to professors and researchers. It is a great source for people that are interested in social studies to read....   [tags: Immigration, Immigration to the United States]

Strong Essays
1030 words (2.9 pages)

The United States Immigration Policy Essay

- The United States immigration policy is in immediate need of a reform in order to maintain the nation’s societal, cultural, and economic needs. Reason being is because the main tasks the federal government is accountable for, acquires to regulate our borders and governs or limits individuals entering the United States. Regrettably, the federal government has continuously failed at solving this problematic situation, leading an estimated 11.5 million illegal immigrants and approximately 40 percent of dishonest immigrants overstaying on their legal visa term (Heritage Foundation Backgrounder No....   [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]

Strong Essays
1305 words (3.7 pages)

U.s. Immigration Policy Policies Essay

- Have you been in recent years in a circus. Well, you probably haven’t, but let me assure you that, yes, you actually have been. Lately, with the United States of America presidential election on the door, “Efforts to overhaul U.S. immigration policy often generate more show than substance” (Malakoff, May 31 2013). So, to obtain more substance than show, the United States of America needs compromised members of Congress to reform the immigration policy according to U.S. actual needs with clear and realistic objectives, and measurable intended outcomes....   [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]

Strong Essays
1249 words (3.6 pages)

The Root of America's Racist Immigration Policy Essay

- The Root of America's Racist Immigration Policy On Tuesday May 16,2006 President George W. Bush started his State of the Union speech with, "We must begin by recognizing the problem with our immigration system". Although the ideologies and issues that America faces today with immigration may seem more complex, there not. The truth is America was founded by immigrants and has flourished with many new types of immigrants to this very day. As romantic as that sounds, immigrants have been met with racist policies that have been institutionalized....   [tags: US Immigration Policy]

Free Essays
1074 words (3.1 pages)