Identity Theory Vs. Dualism : The Nature Of The Mind Essay

Identity Theory Vs. Dualism : The Nature Of The Mind Essay

Length: 1117 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Identity Theory vs. Dualism: The Nature of the Mind
In this paper, I will argue that the materialistic approach of the identity theory to the mind/body problem gives a better account of the nature of the mind than René Descartes’ theory of dualism. These two theories take opposite stands when trying to explain the nature of the mind: dualism holds that the mind and the body are different entities; the body/brain being of physical nature, whereas the mind being non-physical. In contrast, the identity theory says that the mind and the brain are the same, and that the terminology that we use to describe them refer to the same thing (Sober, 204). In this essay, I will outline Descartes’ argument of indivisibility and indubitable existence, and how they rely on the use of Leibniz’s law to show that the mind is different from the body. I then propose that the inherent limitations of human beings, and the ignorance of science, make the identity theory stronger than dualism when trying to determine the nature of the mind.
Identity theory
The identity theory takes a materialistic perspective in trying to explain the nature of the mind. This theory considers the properties of the mind to be the same as those of physical things, which means that the terminology used for physical and mental states describe the same items in the world (Sober, 204). For example, to say that we are in the mental state of pain, refers to the activation of pain receptors in the brain and our subsequent perceptual experience of it.
I propose that we should favor the simplicity of the identity theory, since we can test our understanding of what it means for mental states to be the same as physical. Although we might not fully understand the linear relationship b...


... middle of paper ...


...oday might be proven to be wrong in the future.
We can also consider the ever-developing body of knowledge in science, which is constantly changing to accommodate new understandings of the world and to sometimes show the mistakes of previous conceptions that we held. Our current understanding of the world is bound to change. If we take these arguments into consideration when trying to determine which of the two theories is better at determining the nature of the mind, the identity theory is better suited since it does not attempt to understand the mind as a separate entity, but as being the same as the body, which allows for it to be tested. We cannot reach any conclusive knowledge if the theory is not falsifiable, which is the case for the properties of the mind in dualism, due to our inherent limitations and ignorance about the totality of knowledge of the world.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Dualism On The Concept Of Self Essay

- Dualism on the Concept of Self A commonly discussed issue in philosophy is the problem of self. The concept of the self suggest that the self is a single unit, disconnected from other selves, and unique to each individual in terms of hopes, desires, beliefs, and so on (Rounder, 76). Searle introduces questions of the self through a series of examples, laying out a general question of how we may still identify with the same essence of self despite physical changes taking place within our bodies....   [tags: Philosophy of mind, Mind, Dualism, Brain]

Better Essays
1148 words (3.3 pages)

Analyzing Individuation and Identity In Descartes´ Philosophical View of the Mind-Body Dualism

- Every since Plato introduced the idea of dualism thousands of years ago meta-physicians have been faced with the mind-body problem. Even so Plato idea of dualism did not become a major issue of debate in the philosophical world until the seventeenth century when French philosopher Rene Descartes publicized his ideas concerning the mental and physical world. During this paper, I will analyze the issue of individuation and identity in Descartes’ philosophical view of the mind-body dualism. I will first start by explaining the structure of Cartesian dualism....   [tags: Rene Descartes, Plato, Cartesian dualism]

Better Essays
1098 words (3.1 pages)

The Theory Of Mind Body Dualism Essay

- The Theory of Mind-Body Dualism is the view that there are two different kinds of things or substances that make up human beings: a physical body and a non-physical mind or soul. “Many dualist believe that a materialistic account of the mind is insufficient to explain everything we want to about the nature of mind and that the mind can be ‘embodied’ or ‘disembodied’” (Mind Body Dualism 1 Notes). Two famous arguments that breaks down dualism a little is The Argument from Conceivability says that the mind can exist without a body like a “disembodied mind” and the body cannot exist without a mind....   [tags: Mind, Philosophy of mind, Soul, Free will]

Better Essays
898 words (2.6 pages)

Dualism : The Mind And Body Essay

- Dualism, A philosophical concept is ultimately the relationship between the mind and the body. The mind-body dualism cannot be perceived with our senses, we cannot feel, see, or touch mind-body dualism. Moreover, there is no legitimate way for one’s thoughts to be traced or known. Additionally, you cannot study the mind, one can only study the brain. This concept was adopted by major philosophers including, Plato, Aristotle, and Descartes. Furthermore, the soul can be interchangeable with real identity from the human body and the senses....   [tags: Mind, Soul, Philosophy of mind, Perception]

Better Essays
1193 words (3.4 pages)

The Mind And The Body Essay

- The topic of this essay is to discuss whether the mind and the brain are identical, for the purpose of this paper I will refer to the brain as the body. The position that I am taking on this topic is that of dualism and the argument that the mind and the body are indeed separate. I will support this by discussing Rene Descartes thoughts on substance dualism, and Leibniz 's Law and the indivisible nature of the mind as an additional supporting argument for mind and body dualism. I will counter this by discussing monism and the argument that the mind and the body is made up of only the physical, I will do this by discussing Daniel Dennett and discussing how science supports this....   [tags: Mind, Philosophy of mind, René Descartes, Brain]

Better Essays
1291 words (3.7 pages)

Descartes 's Theory Of Substance Dualism Essay

- According to René Descartes, substance dualism is a dual particular kind of matter that has two kinds of properties. In this case, the two kinds of properties are mental properties and physical properties of human beings. The mental properties are the thoughts of an individual and the physical properties are the extension in space. Descartes explains that a person is not identical to a body; a person can exist without a body because it is not a body. Henceforth, Descartes claims that substance dualism is true....   [tags: Mind, Ontology, Argument, Fertilisation]

Better Essays
1347 words (3.8 pages)

Descartes And The Mind And Body Essay

- Descartes states that the mind and body are two separate substances. I will argue against this claim for there are three reasons to not believe Descartes. The first reason is that we generally come to know things through our senses. Second, there is no empirical evidence to support other minds. Third, there is a close connection between the mind and the body. Descartes theory of substance dualism states that there is a difference between the mind and the body; your mental state is not affected by your physical state....   [tags: Mind, Philosophy of mind, René Descartes]

Better Essays
1288 words (3.7 pages)

Dualism: Concerns and Issues Essay

- Dualism is a broad term that can encompass many areas within philosophy itself. In aspect to metaphysics, it classifies the types of entities in the world into two subcategories, physical and non physical substance. While this may appear to be a very wide and ambiguous opinion, it becomes very specific in regards to our own existence. Paul Churchland puts it very explicitly in his book Matter and Consciousness, and defines dualism as the idea that, “the essential nature of conscious intelligence resides in something nonphysical” (Churchland 1)....   [tags: Philosophy]

Better Essays
2096 words (6 pages)

Cognitive Science And The Mind Body Problem Essay

- Background Cognitive science and the mind-body problem: from philosophy to psychology to artificial intelligence to imaging of the brain was written by Morton Wagman. The author is a professor Emeritus of psychology at the university of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and he is also Diplomate in Counseling Psychology, American Board of Professional psychology. This book was published in the United States of America by Praeger publishers in 1998. The main content of the book is to analyze the variation of the mind-body problem within and across the disciplines of philosophy, psychology, artificial intelligence, and neural science....   [tags: Psychology, Mind, Cognitive science, Brain]

Better Essays
1444 words (4.1 pages)

Essay on Responses to the Doctrine of Mind-Brain Identity

- Responses to the Doctrine of Mind-Brain Identity To be in pain is, for example, is to have one's c-fibres, or more likely a-fibres, firing in the central nervous system; to believe that broccoli will kill you is to have one's B(bk)-fibres firing, and so on. The Blackwell Companion to Philosophy:Chapter 5 'Philosophy of Mind' by William G. Lycan The theory or doctrine of mind-brain identity, as its name implies, denies the claim of dualists that mind and brain (or consciousness and matter) are distinct substances....   [tags: Philosophy Philosophical Papers]

Better Essays
2365 words (6.8 pages)