I Read Your Article With Great Interest As Someone Who Teaches Business Ethics Courses

I Read Your Article With Great Interest As Someone Who Teaches Business Ethics Courses

Length: 839 words (2.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

I read your article with great interest as someone who teaches business ethics courses and utilizes serious games in my classroom. Based on my understanding this conceptual article seeks to offer new insights for ethical leadership development using moral intuitionism, moral pluralism, and serious gaming methods. There are 6 areas in the manuscript that need further development.
1. Introduction:
a. I would like to see a succinct and strong case for why ethical leadership development is so urgently needed today before getting to definitions.

2. Literature Review:
a. Given that this is largely a conceptual piece, I feel that there are some critical gaps in the literature you cite so far. First, you should be examining research within more business ethics journals, such as the “Journal of Business Ethics,” which has a well-established teaching and learning section. I’ll note that some of the suggestions have come out very recently and might not have been available during your initial literature reviews.
b. Likewise, there are other potential articles in pedagogy journals like the “Journal of Business Ethics Education” which would support or situate your argument (See Adkins, 2011, Stumpf, 2011, & Jagger, Siala, & Sloan, 2015 below). These might be useful for examples to discuss in implications for practice. I’d like to see the piece build and speak to the ongoing conversations in management and business ethics education much more directly.
c. Building on the above statement, I’m not sure why you reference Pierce & Wooloff (2012) article since it’s not a comparison study of video games and other media. Furthermore, since you are writing for a management education audience, there are dozens and dozens of articles about movies/other m...

... middle of paper ...

... you to use an outside reader to catch these before your next submission as they are distracting from the quality of your ideas.
b. There are some formatting issues in your references (capitalization, proper italicizing & bolding, spacing, etc.). Please pay careful attention to these details in your next edits.

6. Model Representation
a. In the model “Figures” on page 38 there is an opportunity for you to highlight with coloring or formatting which aspects are new or unique that your paper contributes. Peer-coaching and feedback and reflection have been around for quite a while. Is there a way to add some adjectives about what’s distinctive with these?
In closing, best wishes with your revisions. There are some clear strengths to build on with your interdisciplinary literature, acknowledgement of critiques, evolving theory and innovative teaching and learning ideas.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Role Of Religion On Business Ethics Essay

- Role of Religion in Business Ethics Today in our global business environment ethics is a key term describing how Race, gender, age and religion are used to communicate and make decisions. But to me religion is used the most in global business deals. I say this because another country’s ethics is grown out of this culture which then forms their religious beliefs. These beliefs dictate business decisions worldwide considering how many different religions there are around the globe, from Buddhism to Christianity....   [tags: Judaism, Christianity, Religion, Ethics]

Better Essays
1954 words (5.6 pages)

Combining Military Leadership With Civilian Management Work Ethics Essay

- Why do military trained personnel feel they have better work ethic than their civilian counterparts and vice versa. Peter D. Feaver (2001) fellow researcher of the international security program noted a statement by former Secretary of Defense William Cohen declared that a "chasm" is opening between the military and civilian worlds. Even though civilians have good work ethics, military personnel have the equally valuable yet different work ethics because of the training they received. A study, conducted by researchers at Princeton University, “found that while senior officials [of] the military services received higher evaluations from employees than their [civilian]non-service counterparts...   [tags: Ethics ]

Better Essays
2571 words (7.3 pages)

Leadership Briefing Paper

- LEADERSHIP BRIEFING PAPER Leadership Briefing Paper After spending your entire working life in one giant corporation that went down overnight; investing most of your retirement in stock options that plummet to zero; you are suddenly jobless and your retirement money is gone. Yet, perhaps even more threatening; our skilled and managerial jobs are steadily going abroad, due to poor corporate ethics....   [tags: Business Ethics]

Better Essays
946 words (2.7 pages)

John D. Rockefeller a Business Man in the Oil Industry and an Industrialist

- “If you want to succeed you should strike out on new paths rather than travel the worn paths of accepted success.” These inspiring words highlight the principles that many of the late 1800s industrialists lived by. These industrialists of the late 1800s, known as the “Robber Barons” or “Captains of Industry”, were very influential in America, from their own industry to even the Capitol. One the most influential of them all was John D. Rockefeller. Rockefeller dominated oil industry, which was a budding industry in the 1860s....   [tags: Ethics, Monopolist, Fortune]

Better Essays
842 words (2.4 pages)

How Good Character Can Be Taught Through The Beliefs And Theories Of Aristotle And Through Effective Business Ethics Courses

- Central Theme The central theme in this article is directing its readers that good character can be taught through the beliefs and theories of Aristotle and through effective business ethics courses (mainly case studies). The author, Hartman, uses Aristotle’s perspectives to illustrate how good character is taught, or could be possibly taught. The reason I say possibly is because teaching students and teaching them something as crucial as good character must be done efficiently, which I think Hartman tries to emphasize throughout the article....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Education, Business ethics]

Better Essays
1149 words (3.3 pages)

Business Ethics And Globalization : Business Essay

- Business Ethics and Globalization In recent years many policy makers, business executives, and economists have argued for the necessity of global business in promoting economic development and reducing world poverty. "Multinational corporations, the world trade organization, the G8 summit and various international financial institutions are supposed to advance free trade and promote economic development for the people of various participating countries, including those who are less developed" (Ho, 2004) In a number of different ways the increased globalization of the economies of the United States, Western Europe, and Japan is making business practices more uniform....   [tags: Business ethics, Ethics, Management, Business]

Better Essays
1135 words (3.2 pages)

Business Ethics Of The Business World Essay

- Ethics in the business world in my viewpoint are a great thing for businesses. The term ethics, according to Understanding Business, is the standards of moral behavior, that is, behavior accepted by society as right versus wrong (Nickels, 2013). In the view of a consumer it would be ideal to have interactions with an ethically bound business. My personal standpoint in dealing with an ethically correct business would instill trust into the business. If I knew they weren’t handling things internally or externally the correct way my view and opinions would go down....   [tags: Ethics, Business ethics, Business, Consumer]

Better Essays
1189 words (3.4 pages)

Ethics And Business Relationships : Ethics Essay

- Ethics and Business Relationships Ethics impacts all business relationships, be it with employees, vendors, contractors, competitors, or customers. Those who display ethical behavior are trusted by others. Employees will follow an ethical leader because they trust that he will do the right thing, and they will respect him. Employees will feel secure in knowing that they will be treated and dealt with in a straightforward, honest, and fair way. Employees want to be employed at an ethical company, therefore, they will stay with such a company and there will be a lower turnover rate....   [tags: Ethics, Business ethics, Leadership, Management]

Better Essays
975 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on Ethics In Business

- Ethics are very important to all business people. Yet, many neglect ethics as an important concept that has a major impact upon a person's success as an entrepreneur and investor. Consider something as simple as sales. Many would-be entrepreneurs actually hate the sales process, which is a serious disadvantage, given that generating sales is a company's most important activity. In Flying Solo: How To Start An Individual Practitioner Consulting Business, Stuart Walesh says new consultants often associate negative connotations with marketing....   [tags: Business Ethics Morals]

Free Essays
892 words (2.5 pages)

Business Ethics Essay

- In today’s global society, a Code of Ethics policy is used to label established, acceptable behaviors among that industry’s business associates, potential investors, and the corporation’s executive officers and employees, and most important, the consumer (Ethics Resource Center, 2003). In an attempt to promote an increased efficiency and productivity potential level, among employees and prospective clients, a corporation’s standard Code of Ethics should guide its members toward a more in-depth examination of their personal moral activity, and how these actions affect the people or acquaintances they encounter....   [tags: Business Ethics Morals]

Better Essays
1180 words (3.4 pages)