I Never Promised You a Rose Garden by Joanna Greenberg

I Never Promised You a Rose Garden by Joanna Greenberg

Length: 1714 words (4.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
I Never Promised You a Rose Garden by Joanna Greenberg
I Never Promised You a Rose Garden, written by Joanne Greenberg, has by far been the most difficult book to read and understand. With its difficulty aside, I couldn't set the book down. I found it so interesting to read what goes on inside a person's head who suffers from schizophrenia. It made me understand and appreciate why people with a mental illness behave the way they do. We can't see what goes on in their thoughts, or what they are feeling. So why are we so quick to judge? This book has taught me not to judge, or laugh at a person's behavior while suffering from an illness. It has made me have a greater sympathy and respect for the sufferers of mental illnesses. I can't imagine living in the mentality world as Deborah Blau. Her world was so real to her, the world of Yri. She couldn't escape. She couldn't betray her god Anterrabae. Imagine walking one day in her shoes. It's a scary thought.
I Never Promised You a Rose Garden has made me realize so many things.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"I Never Promised You a Rose Garden by Joanna Greenberg." 123HelpMe.com. 18 Nov 2018

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

I Never Promised You a Rose Garden by Joanne Greenberg Essay examples

- "I Never Promised You a Rose Garden" by Joanne Greenberg Schizophrenia has long been a devastating mental illness and only recently have we begun to see an improvement in our capabilities to treat this disorder. The development of neuroleptics such as, Haldol, Risperidal, and Zyprexa have given psychiatrists, psychologists and their patients great hope in the battle against this mental disease. However, during the 1960s, drugs were not available and psychologists relied upon psychotherapy in order to treat patients....   [tags: Never Promised Rose Garden Greenberg Essays]

Research Papers
1449 words (4.1 pages)

I Never Promised You a Rose Garden by Joanne Greenberg Essay example

- I Never Promised You a Rose Garden by Joanne Greenberg      The cold tone of this story starts out right in the beginning and her mother and father are quite distraught because of the daughter’s illness and the fact that they must trust the doctors; they seem to not trust anyone. They even told their own family that Deborah is at convalescent school, not a mental institution. Of course the time period of the book is much earlier than now so it is more understandable why they were upset. Hopefully parents now are less ignorant and would try and be proud of their child to willingly get help....   [tags: Never Promised Rose Garden Greenberg Essays]

Research Papers
1199 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on I Never Promised You A Rose Garden

- I Never Promised You A Rose Garden Analysis I Never Promised You a Rose Garden, by Joanne Greenberg, is a description of a sixteen-year-old girl's battle with schizophrenia, which lasts for three years. It is a semi-autobiographical account of the author’s experiences in a mental hospital during her own bout with the illness. This novel is written to help fight the stigmatisms and prejudices held against mental illness. Joanne Greenberg was born in Brooklyn in 1932, and is a very respected and award-winning author....   [tags: Essays Papers]

Research Papers
708 words (2 pages)

Characters, Language and Physical Characteristics in I Never Promised You a Rose Garden

- Characters, Language and Physical Characteristics in I Never Promised You a Rose Garden     A past of discomfort and sorrow, loneliness and pain shadowed an innocent girl with so much potential. She lay broken under the weight of her own secret longing, while no one seemed to care. Then, through a thick veil of anguish, Deborah noticed an unfamiliar, yet inviting light sprouting from within herself. Through the open door of this needed world Deborah ventured, drowning in her own relief....   [tags: Never Promised Rose Garden]

Research Papers
1340 words (3.8 pages)

I Never Promised You A Rose Garden Essay example

- I Never Promised You a Rose Garden by Hannah Greene I Never Promised You a Rose Garden takes place in the late 1940s. The main setting is in a mental hospital just outside Chicago. But it also goes back and forth between the hospital and the main character’s home in Chicago. This book is about a girl named Deborah who is diagnosed with schizophrenia. She is sent to a mental hospital after trying to commit suicide. Deborah lives in her own world of Yri and has lost touch with reality. In fact, she wants no part of the real world....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
752 words (2.1 pages)

Commentary on Bill Cosby´s Dr. Spock Never Promised Us a Rose Garden Essay

- I’M GOING TO KNOCK YOU INTO NEXT WEEK IF YOU DON’T… I am pretty sure many parents have or would tell their children those words. It’s the main threat that almost every child has heard in his or her lifetime. Whether the mom or dad was talking to them or someone else, in Bill Cosby’s “Dr. Spock Never Promised Us a Rose Garden” he explains and breaks down the dynamics of parenting from both the mother and father’s role. As a father of five children, you would think of having the parenting “thing” down packed, but raising children doesn’t get easier, you will just become more advanced into raising the child you have....   [tags: Parenting, Children]

Research Papers
602 words (1.7 pages)

A Rose for Emily Essays

- "A Rose for Emily" is a wonderful short story written by William Faulkner. It begins with at the end of Miss Emily’s life and told from an unknown person who most probably would be the voice of the town. Emily Grierson is a protagonist in this story and the life of her used as an allegory about the changes of a South town in Jefferson after the civil war, early 1900's. Beginning from the title, William Faulkner uses symbolism such as house, Miss Emily as a “monument “, her hair, Homer Barron, and even Emily’s “rose” to expresses the passing of time and the changes....   [tags: A Rose For Emily, William Faulkner]

Research Papers
1032 words (2.9 pages)

The Use of Irony in Barbara L. Greenberg's The Faithful Wife Essay

- The Use of Irony in Barbara L. Greenberg's The Faithful Wife "The Faithful Wife" by Barbara L. Greenberg is a fascinating, satirical account of what the speaker would do if she were unfaithful to her husband. Upon the first reading of this poem, I thought the woman in this poem was saying that her husband was irreplaceable and because of that she would never be unfaithful. Also I thought that if she did betray him, she would choose someone totally different from him, which somehow wouldn't dishonor this great man....   [tags: Greenberg Faithful Wife Essays]

Research Papers
676 words (1.9 pages)

What Laura Didn't learn in The Garden Party Essay

- At the conclusion of The Garden Party, Laura is exposed to a side of life she has never encountered before, and comes to a sudden realization that "life and death may indeed coexist and that their common existence in one world may be beautiful" (Magalaner 101). Death is not necessarily associated with ugliness, she learns, but rather it is a natural process which she likens to sound, peaceful sleep. However, her ostensible epiphany is really only astonishment. Laura’s world revolves around the finer things in life, garden parties, and flowers, and she has been surrounded by beauty her whole life....   [tags: Garden Party Essays]

Research Papers
1959 words (5.6 pages)

Identity Formation in Mansfield’s The Garden Party Essays

-   "The budding rose above the rose full blown," writes William Henry Wordsworth, elevating the process of emerging, changing and evolving over those already developed, established and matured. While Wordsworth’s remark regards a rose, the statement also accurately describes Katherine Mansfield’s protagonist in The Garden Party. The narrative focuses on a wealthy family from New Zealand, jaded by elite lifestyle and prominent social standing. The youngest daughter, Laura, "the budding rose" of the story, seeks to break the constraints of upper class society, causing her to be both more mature and compassionate than other members of her well to do family....   [tags: The Garden Party Essays]

Research Papers
3813 words (10.9 pages)

I learned that a mental illness affects everyone, not just the patient. A mental illness, especially one as severe as schizophrenia, will have a huge impact on the lives of parents, family, friends, and even the team of medical authorities and doctors. It has also made me recognize the differences in the approach doctors take when attempting to treat a mental illness. Throughout the story, Deborah developed such a strong relationship and friendship with Dr. Clara Fried, her therapist. This took time, but was an important factor in order to overcome Deborah's illness. Dr. Fried took a more laid back approach as compared to Dr. Royson, the therapist who temporarily filled in for Dr. Fried while she was away one summer. He focused on trying to logically prove that Yri is Deborah's own creation, not a real kingdom. He bombarded her with questions, trying to find answers. Dr. Fried empathized with Deborah. She allowed Deborah to know that she could always go back to her kingdom, providing her with comfort. She gained Deborah's trust and respect. Dr. Fried had the education and experience, as do many doctors. What puts her above the rest is her ability to sympathize with her patients. Dr. Clara Fried declined several other professional opportunities in order to take on Deborah's case. I must say it was the most unselfish, best decision she could have made. Her empathy is her greatest gift as a doctor. With her help, Deborah gained the courage to fight her way through schizophrenia.
Deborah's schizophrenia was able to be traced back to the age of five, when her first words of Yr's were uttered. When she was five, she suffered from a tumor. She felt violated when the doctors examined her, and outraged when they told her there would be no pain. The truth is… it was very painful for Deborah, and she did not appreciate the lies. Terrified, Deborah fled into her own world, the world she created on her own, the Kingdom of Yr.
The tumor was not the only thing that triggered Deborah to retreat to Yr. Although her early childhood surgery clearly had an important influence, there were many other things that took place in her life. Her grandfather's martyr complex, her father's shame at depending on her grandparents financially, the anti-Semitic prejudices of her peers and neighbors, and the jealousy created from birth of her younger sister Suzy all affected how Deborah expressed her illness.
Now, at the age of sixteen and a failed attempt of suicide, Deborah's father Jacob and her mother Esther decide to take up their family physicians advice. Dr. Lister recommends that Deborah be taken to a mental hospital for treatment. Her parents face self-doubt and self-blame. They are concerned about the reaction of their relatives to finding out about where Deborah was being sent. They decided on telling Esther's parents and Suzy that she is at a convalescent school.
In the hospital, Deborah is surrounded by a lot of people of her kind. Over the course of three years, she befriends some of them and is hurt by others. She hears about Dorris Rivera, a previous patient at the hospital that managed to leave the hospital and live a normal life. Deborah hopes she can someday do the same. The gods of Yr shout to Deborah that she could never go out into the world again, causing another psychotic episode. Deborah is transferred to the Disturbed ward, causing great concern from her parents.
Deborah's psychotic episodes often correspond with moments that reveal details of Yr to Dr. Fried. Although it may appear like her illness is getting worse, it actually is a sign that she is beginning to fight it. For years Deborah hid Yr, but now she feels no pressure to hide her illness, to live a lie. While Deborah struggles to free herself from her illness, her family is also undergoing a difficult coping process. Her parents stay strong as hard as it may be for them. They realize there is no quick easy cure for their daughter's illness. Therefore, they tell Suzy the truth about where her sister really is. Suzy unexpectedly understands.
There is a long road to recovery for Deborah that lies ahead. While in the hospital, Deborah continued to burn herself in order to ease the pressure of the "volcano inside her." She hid the burns well, and the doctors suggested moving her back to the B ward. Deborah knew that this may result in her death, therefore she revealed her burns. Deborah's burn wounds refused to heal. Meanwhile, Deborah decided that she would not use the patients' cigarette butts or Dr. Fried's matches to burn herself anymore. Deborah still experienced psychotic episodes. Once she wrote Yri words all over the bathroom, in her own blood. After this episode, Deborah begun to realize that the death she fears so much may not be a physical one.
At one point, Deborah threatens to give up her treatment. Dr. Fried told Deborah that the "poor little girl" could stay crazy forever if she would like. Yet she urged her to still try first. She reminded her that she never promised the fight to health would be an easy one. This is where the title of the book comes into play, I Never Promised You a Rose Garden. She never promised the road to a happy, normal, healthy life would be fast and simple. It was a fight, a struggle.
Deborah still continued to suffer from frequent psychotic episodes, yet the staff begun to treat her more kindly now. Dr. Fried explained to Deborah that she never actually attempted to kill her younger sister Suzy when she was five. It was simply not physically possible. Deborah begun to realize that this all took place in her mind, this along with so much more.
Deborah requested that she be allowed to live in the nearby town. She took place in the social life in the town, and everyone eventually treated her with politeness. She finally, after three years, admitted to creating Yr and its gods herself. However, she still feared that they somehow might still be real. Deborah begun taking classes to prepare herself for the GED examination, for she realized she needed a high school diploma to get a job. She then experiences another psychotic episode. She feared that Yr no longer had its same logic now that she has begun to accept the laws of Earth. Regardless, she passed the GED exam with a high enough score to pursue a college degree if she wished to. Deborah suffers one last psychotic episode. She feared she would never be able to live like average people, the wall between her and them would always be there. After returning to consciousness, she opened her textbooks. She told the gods of Yr that she is going to fight for her place on Earth. Despite their attempts to hold her back, she wasn't giving in. For the first time in her life, Deborah was a normal determined young woman who had a future to look forward to.
Deborah's illness had its own language, its own logic. It would be too simple for us to dismiss Deborah's world as an "imaginary world." Her world was very real to her. Dr. Fried was able to understand and accept this "reality" or Yr. This was crucial for Deborah to gain trust in her. It was this trust that led to such a strong relationship. That trust and relationship led to Deborah's understanding of her illness. Without that understanding, fighting this illness would not have been possible. I Never Promised You a Rose Garden taught me so much about the struggles people face when overcoming mental illnesses. It showed me how it affects everyone, not just the patient. It gave me insight into the minds of these patients, which led to such a great understanding of what we see on the outside and what is really going on in the inside. Deborah's character shows reality, the reality that many people suffering from a mental illness face all there lives. Maybe all the medication and therapy in the world can't completely cure a patient. What it can do is guide them, teaching them how to live with this illness. They can maintain and fight this illness. They can adapt to live normal lives. It is possible. Deborah's character has shown this to me. Never give up hope or faith. Anything is possible. If you try hard enough, one can overcome any obstacle.
Return to 123HelpMe.com