Human Species And Nonhuman Species Essay

Human Species And Nonhuman Species Essay

Length: 1228 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

It is apparent that there are many philosophers that stand on both sides of the argument. One side is clearly expressing that while there may be some overlap between the human species and nonhuman species, we are not equal because of the concept of rationality, for example. However, I see Singer’s arguments as much stronger than the other philosophers. He draws on many solid points backed up by concrete evidence that is easily understandable on many points, pulling from different experiences and true events. I defend Singer’s view that nonhuman animals are equal to human beings because he points cannot be discounted, but more heavily supported the more he digs into them.
He begins his statements by outlining the conditions on which we treat animals. From a Kantian perspective, he explains that our most direct contact with an animal is when we consume them. This, therefore, is treating the animal as a pure means to our ends by using them as nutrition and for satisfaction. We brutally inflict pain upon the animals, not exclusively in the final moments as they are being slaughtered, but for the most part, during their entire life. Many animals know nothing other than a life in a dark, crowded barn or factory treated as meat before they are even killed. These terrible conditions blatantly show that we do not care about these animals and we simply rear and kill them in order to satisfy our trivial interests. The cruelty imposed upon these helpless animals is shocking and it is not rare for people to turn a blind eye to the brutality. Another commonplace would be for a meat consumer to say that humans are “ends in themselves, while everything other than a person can only have value for a person” (C. Vlastos). People believe that...

... middle of paper ... the most evident and common in our society, but unfortunately, not the only occurrences. Speciesism is a commonplace throughout the world in every culture and it is time that we, as humans with the ability to feel moral obligation, begin to empathize for the beings that we share this planet with. It pains me to imagine that a person could say all humans are equal based on our history. How is it possible to morally say that a man like Hitler or Stalin or a mass murderer deserves to be treated as equal as you and I? What amount of worth do those murderers possess that an innocent deer that has just been skinned, or a baby calf who will only know a life of confinement do not? It is our job and our moral responsibility to fight against the all too common notion that we feel superior to other mammals, that are more similar to us than our conscious wants us to believe.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Protecting the Welfare of Nonhuman Animals Essay example

- ‘Hominum causa omne ius constitutum: all law was established for man’s sake’. Endorsed by early Judaeo-Christian beliefs, holding that humans were created in God’s image having ‘dominion over all animals’. This statement remains true today, despite such assertions being undermined by scientific developments proving homo sapiens to simply be biological entities like any other organism. Such discoveries call into scrutiny the determination of rights on the basis of species and have lead to modern philosophers asserting the contention that animals should be included within the spectrum of rights....   [tags: ]

Better Essays
1617 words (4.6 pages)

Nonhuman Animal Rights Essay

- In regards to animals, the issue of rights and whether they exist becomes a touchy subject. In the essay, “Nonhuman Animal Rights: Sorely Neglected,” author Tom Regan asserts that animals have rights based upon inherent value of experiencing subjects of a life. Regan’s argument will first be expressed, later explained, and evaluated in further detail. Lastly, that fact that Regan thinks rights are harbored under the circumstance of being an experiencing subject of a life will also be discussed in terms of the incapacitated, etc....   [tags: Ethics, Tom Regan]

Better Essays
1245 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on An Analysis Of Donna Haraway 's ' When Species Meet '

- Donna Haraway’s (2008) ‘When Species Meet’ is a post human analysis of the categorisation of the world into human and non-human, questioning the divisions that define contemporary Western society. Chapter twelve, ‘Parting Bites’ summarises her work, a critical evaluation of the dichotomy between animals seen as companion animals and pets, and animals that aren’t. She focuses on the ‘technocultural’ climate of today, proposing the notion of ‘companion species,’ a coming together of more than just humans and animals; technologies, organisms and landscapes are among those that she argues ‘break bread’ together with humans (Haraway 2008:95)....   [tags: Human, Mammal, Chimpanzee, Humans]

Better Essays
1532 words (4.4 pages)

Organ Tranplantation: Should Xenotransplantation’s be Allowed? Essay

- Organ transplantation saves thousands of lives every year, and is arguably one of the most significant medical innovations of the past century. However the demand for organs far outweighs that of the supply, with many people not being able to receive the life saving organs they need. That is where Xenotransplants come in; Xenotransplantation involves the transplantation of nonhuman tissues or organs into human recipients. This essay will look at whether Xenotransplantation should be allowed by exploring the positive and negative aspects of the procedure....   [tags: nonhuman tissues, immunology]

Better Essays
1149 words (3.3 pages)

The Evils Polluition Portrays on the Environment and the Species that Occupy It

- The Evils Pollution Portrays on the Environment and the Species That Occupy It “One hundred and fifty years ago, the monster began, this country had become a place of industry. Factories grew on the landscape like weeds. Trees fell, fields were up-ended, rivers blackened. The sky choked on smoke and ash, and the people did, too, spending their days coughing and itching, their eyes turned forever toward the ground. Villages grew into town, towns into cities. And people began to live on the earth rather than within it.” -Patrick Ness This quote by Patrick Ness should sink and open our minds into what we are doing to this planet we call home....   [tags: environmental detriments]

Better Essays
1976 words (5.6 pages)

Essay on Stem Cell Research – Developing a Cross between Species

- Ethics of Stem Cell Research – Developing a Cross between Species The idea of a chimera, a cross between species, has been around since the mythological creatures of ancient Greece, such as the centaur (a man’s torso with a horses body) and the griffin (the wings, head, and claws of an eagle and the body of a lion). Today, due to our advances in biotechnology, we are seeing this mythology become a reality, but in a different respect. Human-nonhuman animal chimeras are being developed by injecting animal blastocysts with human embryonic stem cells....   [tags: Exploratory Essays Research Papers]

Better Essays
610 words (1.7 pages)

Essay on We Are All Animals By Harry Harlow

- We are all animals. According to the Merriam-Webster Dictionary, an animal is simply defined as any living thing that is not a plant. Thus, humans, by definition, are just a species of animal. Most people would be outraged by this bold assertion, but as a matter of fact it is scientifically proven. Experiments conducted by Harry Harlow illustrated the common need both baby humans and chimpanzees have for love-- especially from a motherly figure. Also, renowned psychoanalyst Sigmund Freud often used animal tendencies to explain common human behaviors....   [tags: Human, Chimpanzee, Species, Science]

Better Essays
1084 words (3.1 pages)

The Ethics Of The Endangered Species Act Essay

- In today’s society everyone seems to have an opinion on everything. It seems the more uninformed one is on a subject the more strongly the feel about it. Occasionally there are those who address issues they are well informed on in a well-organized and civilized manner, weighing both the pros and cons of the side they advocate. Brandon M. Middleton does an exceptional job of this in his article on the Endangered Species Act, where he talks about the effectiveness of the Federal government’s current involvement with endangered species....   [tags: Endangered species, Species]

Better Essays
1423 words (4.1 pages)

Essay about Why Animals Are Endangered Species

- The earth has experienced many unexpected outcomes over the years. The changes on earth have affected many animals, plants, and ecosystems. Different kinds of species stay involved with the dramatic changes the earth has went through. The past includes climate changes, distinctions, meteorites, and evolution processes. The changes on earth will always impact different species no matter where the species occupies. The changes on earth have led to many species becoming endangered. Endangered species continue to increase and without help, earth’s species will become distinct....   [tags: Species, Extinction, Endangered species, Hunting]

Better Essays
984 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about Endangered Species

- Humans are destructive. Not a lot of us think about how what we do affects the world around us. We almost act like we are the only ones on this planet. We go around polluting and destroying our world with no regard for our actions. The things that live out in the wild are paying the price for it. Every day that passes there is another animal or plant that is placed on an endangered list. This is happening at an alarming rate. Because of man’s desire to expand and conquer their surroundings, there are animals and plants that are on the brink of extinction that will not be around for our kids and future generations to enjoy if something is not done about it now....   [tags: Biology, Extinct Species]

Better Essays
2010 words (5.7 pages)