Human Identity, By Marc Chagall 's Painting I And The Village Essay

Human Identity, By Marc Chagall 's Painting I And The Village Essay

Length: 1062 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

What is human identity; is it a characteristic defined by humanism, interpreted into arbitrary degrees of humanity or rather is it the manifestation, or possession of a soul, of divinity? If such defines our identity, then is being human an inherited genetic attribute or is it a state we achieve through knowledge and wisdom? Identity, however, is not always stable; it is an interpretation of the dynamic balance between humanity’s divine and animalistic personas, a debate of “ natural supremacy” between humans and nonhuman animals in nature.
While philosophers, like Plato, describe human identity by the possession of a divine soul, Marc Chagall’s painting I and the Village emphasizes how human identity is defined the ability to think about, to conceptualize, nature and the material realm. While nonhuman animals can only react to signs, or to stimuli that provoke linear, cause-and-effect sequences, human animals have the ability to create symbols, representational meanings imbued into natural abstractions. Through the manipulation of symbols, humans are able to create complex languages, such as mathematics, philosophy and science, influencing the evolution of knowledge. Though knowledge, humans learn how to rule over, and manipulate, nature and other nonhuman animals. However, while human identity is defined by the ability to think about and conceptualize reality, Chagall emphasizes that despite divine portrayals of human animals or the ability to create symbols, human animal are nonetheless neither deities nor gods. Chagall warns humans of the flaws of anthropocentric idealism, that both human and nonhuman animals are a part of nature, no greater or lesser than any of the other parts.
What differentiates human from nonhuman anim...


... middle of paper ...


...an animals. Chagall uses this biased perception of nature to criticize how people’s obliviousness to their own awareness is no longer capable of thinking about. Rather, they are merely reacting to the social norms and ideologies presented to them, neglecting the physical realm and centralizing around metaphorical abstractions meant to describe reality. Pliny also criticizes the lack of self-awareness, writing how
“[Human animals] are supposed to have notion, too, of the differences of religion; and when about to cross the sea, they cannot be prevailed upon to go on board the ship, until their [gods] has promised upon oath that they shall return home again.”

In other words, humanity’s distortion of reality through religion represents the devolution of rigorous intellectual thinking and self-identity, deliberating human animals from the qualities of human identity.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Rage in Baldwin's Stranger in the Village

- Rage in Baldwin's Stranger in the Village The rage of the disesteemed is personally fruitless, but it is also absolutely inevitable; this rage, so generally discounted, so little understood even among the people whose daily bread it is, is one of the things that makes history. -- James Baldwin, ?Stranger in the Village. (130) In his essay 'Stranger in the Village' (1955), many of James Baldwin?s innermost feelings are exposed to the reader. One of the emotions I believe Baldwin feels most strongly is rage....   [tags: Stranger Village]

Better Essays
593 words (1.7 pages)

Essay on From Longhouse to Village by R. Daniel Shaw

- After reading “From Longhouse to Village” by R. Daniel Shaw, I was able to understand the point that he was trying to make throughout the chapters that I read. In chapter 5: From Micro dialects to Language Identity: Linguistic Synthesis. Shaw states, “The comparison of words on lists spread across a room provides a greater understanding of linguistic connections that, in turn, give us a perspective of cultural similarity as well as variation. Language and culture work closely together; what people do, they talk about....   [tags: from longhouse to village, daniel shaw]

Better Essays
873 words (2.5 pages)

Marc Forster’s Monster’s Ball Essay

- Marc Forster’s Monster’s Ball Marc Forster’s Monster’s Ball is a depiction of one man’s journey to overcome his lifelong ignorance, but this seems to be the film’s only accomplishment. The grisly drama attempts to address pressing racial issues, but instead it creates a monstrous web of unanswered questions and unfulfilled plotlines cleverly masked by brilliant acting and cinematic beauty. The first half of Monster’s Ball revolves around a family of executioners responsible for the last days of a black death-row inmate....   [tags: Marc Forster Monster's Ball Essays]

Better Essays
1042 words (3 pages)

Essay about Claude Monet 's The Windmill On Painting

- The art piece chosen for analyzing in this essay is from Claude Monet, The Windmill on the Onbekende Gracht Amsterdam oil on canvas painting from 1874. Claude Monet was born on November 14 in 1840 in Paris, French, and he death on December 5 in 1926 in Giverny, France. He was a founder of French impressionist painting, and the most consistent and prolific practitioner of the movement 's philosophy of expressing one 's perceptions before nature, especially as applied to plain air landscape painting....   [tags: Impressionism, Claude Monet, Color, Painting]

Better Essays
849 words (2.4 pages)

Quantum Mechanics and Marc Lange's "An Introduction to The Philosophy of Physics"

- Of the many counter intuitive quirks of quantum mechanics, the strangest quirk is perhaps the notion of quantum entanglement. Very roughly, quantum entanglement a phenomenon where the state of a large system cannot be described by the state of the smaller systems that compose it. On the standard metaphysical interpretation of quantum entanglement, this is taken to show that there exists emergent properties1. If this standard interpretation is correct, it seems that physics paints a far different picture of the world then commonsense leads one to believe....   [tags: Quantum Mechanics, science, Marc Lange, Introducti]

Better Essays
2570 words (7.3 pages)

Analysis Of The Painting ' The Oil On Canvas ' Essays

- Winter Landscape on the Banks of the Seine is a Neo-Impressionist painting. Matisse created this painting in CA. 1904-1905. The oil on canvas is 12 3/4 x 15 3/4 inches on its own. In the frame the painting is 19 1/4 x 23 1/8 inches. This painting is located in the Seattle Museum of Art where it hangs with other Neo-Impressionist paintings. This painting generates a sense of serenity and sets the mood in a romantic tone. This is created by the colors, the setting, and the style that Matisse chose to use in this painting....   [tags: Oil painting, Painting, Emotion]

Better Essays
1052 words (3 pages)

James Baldwin's Stranger in the Village Essay

- James Baldwin's Stranger in the Village In paragraph three of James Baldwin's 'Stranger in the Village' (1955), he alludes to emotions that are significant, dealing with conflicts that arise in the Swiss village. Of these emotions are two, astonishment and outrage, which represent the relevant feelings of Baldwin, an American black man. These two emotions, for Baldwin's ancestors, create arguments about the 'Negro' and their rights to be considered 'human beings' (Baldwin 131). Baldwin, an American Negro, feels undeniable rage toward the village because of the misconception of his complexion, a misconception that denies Baldwin human credibility and allows him to be perceived as a 'living...   [tags: James Baldwin Stranger Village Essays Papers]

Better Essays
892 words (2.5 pages)

Essay on Black Americans' Struggle in Baldwin's Stranger in the Village

- Black Americans' Struggle in Baldwin's Stranger in the Village In ?Stranger in the Village. (1955), James Baldwin, a writer born and raised in Harlem, experiences extreme emotions during his stay in a 'tiny Swiss village'(127). James Baldwin?s feelings of inadequacy and insecurities of being an American black man bring out a rage in him toward the white man's power over him. His deep feelings of outrage, bringing back hurtful memories as a black child in America, are revived as he is forced to endure the unintentional cruelties of the villagers....   [tags: Stranger Village Baldwin Essays]

Free Essays
406 words (1.2 pages)

Marc Chagall Essay

- Marc Chagall Marc Chagall as an artist and as a person cannot be categorized. He was born in Vitebsk, Russia, learned to paint in St. Petersburg and lived in Paris, Berlin, and the United States. His career is influenced by many different factors. His Hasidic Jewish upbringing reflected in the content of his paintings greatly. The lyrical fairy tales of Jewish mysticism, the stories of the Bible, and the Rabbis and scholars who surrounded him in his childhood come out onto his work. When he went to art school in St....   [tags: History]

Better Essays
1387 words (4 pages)

A Village By The Sea - Anita Desai Essays

- Anita Desai's novel, The Village by the Sea, is a vibrant narration of perseverance and hope in distress. It is a saga of changes and adaptation, a little of evil and more about the goodness of nature and human kindness. Based on true events, it is a story set in a small coastal village Thul near Bombay. The two main characters of the novel are a brother and sister duo, 13-year-old Lila and 12-year-old Hari. They have two young school-going sisters, Bela and Kamal, a chronically ill mother and a good-for-nothing drunkard father....   [tags: Desai Village Sea Book Analysis]

Free Essays
1019 words (2.9 pages)