Throughout the articles, Allen’s tone and approach express doubts about the effectiveness of the vaccination, while Adams’ tone and approach is geared toward his anger at the political system and drug companies. Allen’s more objective approach and Adams’ less objective approach are evident in their word choices, calls to action, and use of punctuation. Adams’ word choices are more inflammatory, while Allen is more understated. For example, Allen in describing the mandate says he has “reservations” (449). Adams describes the vaccine as “absolutely worthless” (445). Allen speaks of those involved as the “medical community” (449) and “drug firms” (449). Adams speaks of the “sick care industry” (446) and “Big Pharma” (447). The articles each present a call to action; Adams asks that the reader reject the vaccination entirely, and stand up to this “tyranny” (447) and spread the word by posting a cartoon and linking to his article. Allen urges that the Government “shouldn’t rush” (450) the mandate to give it time to gain “credibility” (450). Adams’ use of punctuation is much more emotionally laden. He freque...
... middle of paper ...
Clearly there are a number of opinions on whether this vaccine should be mandatory or not, and further investigation is needed. Some critics are against the vaccine itself; others like Allen question the timing of the mandate. Allen’s essay convincingly argues that the mandate should be delayed to get public buy in. It is unfortunate that Adams’ style and lack of support keep his essay from making what could be valid points about the safety of the vaccine, and the possibly unethical relationship between drug companies and politicians regarding this mandate.
Ackley, Katherine Anne, ed. Perspectives on Contemporary Issues: Reading across the Disciplines. 6th ed. Boston: Wadsworth, Cengage learning, 2009. Print.
Adams, Mike. “HPV Vaccine Texas Tyranny.” Ackley 445-47.
Allen, Arthur. “The HPV Debate Needs an Injection of Reality.” Ackley 448-49.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- If you could help protect yourself against cancer with a vaccine would you get that vaccine. HPV short for Human Papillomavirus is a virus that affects a widespread of people. HPV can cause cervical cancer, vaginal cancer, and vulvar cancer, in females. It can cause anal cancer in both males and females along with genital warts. Twenty four million Americans are estimated to be infected with the HPV virus. This virus is transmitted through genital-to-genital contact not only sexual intercourse. Symptoms of the HPV virus can be latent.... [tags: Human papillomavirus, HPV vaccine]
1789 words (5.1 pages)
- The Human papillomavirus (HPV) is the most common Sexually Transmitted Infection, which affects nearly all women and men at some point in their life. Currently, 79 million Americans are infected with this virus, with 14 million, usually young adults, being infected every year. HPV consists of a group of about 100 viruses, some of which are harmless and do not need treatment. However, others can have malevolent effects on the body. For example, strains 6 and 11, which are some of the most common, cause low grade and benign cell anomalies, which can lead to warts.... [tags: HPV vaccine, Human papillomavirus]
1233 words (3.5 pages)
- A human papillomavirus (HPV) is transmitted sexual behavior and a major cause of cervical cancer; about 70% of all cervical cancer occur HPVs 16 and 18 (Markowitz et al., 2013). An estimated prevalence of a HPV infection in the US was 39.9 million women and approximately 8.88million women among aged 15 to 24 years had HPV infections in 2008 (Satterwhite et al., 2013). A HPV Vaccine has been approved and has been recommended in females aged 9 to 26 years in the United States since 2006 (Centers for Diseases Control and Prevention [CDC], 2014).... [tags: HPV vaccine, Human papillomavirus]
1714 words (4.9 pages)
- The Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Vaccine The unforgettable story of vaccines is a story of triumph and controversy. The saddest part of the story is persistent ignorance and a lack of education, comingled with the personal need of some parents to explain away the problems of their children, have caused the controversy to arise. The good news is that the triumphant reality of vaccines as a whole is still the larger enduring legacy. The human papillomavirus vaccine is not an exception to this rule; in fact despite all the controversy surrounding the vaccine, it is one of medicine’s greatest lifesaving gifts to us.... [tags: HPV Cancer, Cervical Cancer]
1596 words (4.6 pages)
- The HPV vaccination presented by Gerasil in 2006 has caused a controversy in the realms of science, religion, and philosophy. With nearly 6 million new cases of HVP every year, the vaccination itself has not been the issue, however it is the compulsory use of the vaccination that has been proposed in most states and implemented in a few that has caused a scene. James Colgrove of the New England Journal of Medicine presents the varying positions concerning the compulsory use of the vaccination and the arguments for and against it.... [tags: HPV Cancer, Cervical Cancer]
883 words (2.5 pages)
- According to the Journal of the American Medical Association, 80% of people in America are infected by the Human Papillomavirus, also known as HPV, at some point in their lifetime. Compared to this class, 25 out of the 30 students here have had this sexually transmitted disease. Only one of your tables is safe. The rest of you are all at risk. This is an incredibly common, and potentially deadly, virus, which is why we should mandate the HPV vaccine, Gardasil, for all teenage girls entering middle school.... [tags: HPV Cancer, Cervical Cancer]
878 words (2.5 pages)
- According to the Journal of the American Medical Association, 80% of people in America are infected by the Human Papillomavirus, also known as HPV, at some point in their lifetime. That would be as though, 25 out of the 30 students in this classroom have or have had this sexually transmitted disease. Only one group of desks in this class would be safe from its harmful effects. This is an incredibly common, and potentially deadly, virus, which is why we should mandate the HPV vaccine, Gardasil, for all teenage girls entering middle school.... [tags: HPV Cancer, Cervical Cancer]
892 words (2.5 pages)
- Human papillomavirus (HPV) is a killer. It is an awful disease that is the culprit of many deaths each year. We have the means for its prevention, yet HPV vaccination for girls is a controversial topic to some. This controversy carries over to the current question on whether or not males should also be vaccinated. The issue is starting to play a huge role in the media; Fox news recently broadcasted a story on male HPV vaccinations. This story makes clear the benefits that would come from vaccinating males, including a statement from the Center for Disease Control that, “The HPV vaccine will afford protection against certain HPV-related conditions and cancers in males, and vaccination of mal... [tags: HPV Vaccination 2014]
940 words (2.7 pages)
- The Concept of Tyranny in Literature All social contract theorists and classical thinkers understand tyranny to be someone (or government) with unrestrained power that is unjust or unfair to the body, it governs. They each share some views about the effects of tyranny but they have different views on the preventions and the circumstances that give rise to tyranny. In the end, Locke has the most effective ideas as opposed to Plato and Hobbes. Although, they are all equally great minds, based on the democracy that Americans hold true, Locke’s analysis can be the only logical means of proposed prevention.... [tags: Tyranny Plato John Locke Governmental Essays]
1320 words (3.8 pages)
- HPV & Cervical Cancer - What Every Woman Should Know I was eighteen years old when I had my first abnormal pap smear. I received a call from my OB/GYN's office and was informed that I had the Human Papilloma Virus show up on my pap smear. This was the first pap smear I had ever had, and I was terrified. The news got worse. I researched this virus and learned that it was actually a sexually transmitted disease that could either cause cervical cancer, or genital warts. I didn’t understand, I had been with my boyfriend for five years and he was my first partner.... [tags: HPV Cancer, Cervical Cancer]
2544 words (7.3 pages)