How Mill 's View On Paternalism And Its Relationship With The Liberty Of Choice

How Mill 's View On Paternalism And Its Relationship With The Liberty Of Choice

Length: 800 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


In this essay I will be discussing, in agreement, that the refusal to serve a 36 week pregnant woman alchohol is not a legitimate violation to her liberty. More specifically, I will be addressing firstly, that Mill’s harm principle allows society to interfere with the liberty of competant-thinking and acting adults on the basis of preventing harm done to others and that the consumption of alchohol while pregnant, does constitute harm to the unborn baby. Also, the roles of individuals in society does have some merit and duty where liberty can be violated; and lastly, I will portray how Mill’s view on paternalism and its relationship it has with the liberty of choice.
In the article posted by TVNZ under the program ONENEWS, a decision to refuse a heavily pregnant woman alcohol raised the question whether it was a violation of her rights after being told that as an adult, consenting female, she could not be served alcohol for the risk it may carry to the unborn child. I have aforementioned that using Mill’s harm principle allows society to interfere with the liberty of competent adults on the basis of preventing harm to others. In this article, the prevention of harm to others extends to a living unborn baby inside the pregnant woman, despite not causing harm to herself. The harm principle states that; “The only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilised community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others. His own good, either physical or moral, is not a sufficient warrant.” There is much controversy in the discussion of when fetus can be considered human beings however, it has been stated that by the 35th-38th week, the fetus is suffuciently developed for life outside the uterus. Furt...


... middle of paper ...


...and when she becomes pregnant. On the advise of the Ministry of Health, no alcohol should be consumed during pregnancy because there are no safe levels of ensuring that the baby would not be harmed by physical or mental alterations or deformaties due to the consumption of alcohol by the woman. Just like the example of how society is advised to give up their seat while traveling on a bus or a train (which negates utilitarianism because who likes to stand?), pregnant woman should play a role to deliver the baby safely and not risk the chances of causing abnormalities in the baby’s condition by drinking alcohol. Therefore, the waitress refusing to serve alcohol to the pregnant did not violate her rights as it is on the advise of authorities and the role of society to ensure the general well-being of the woman even if she does not believe her rights has been violated.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Brief Note On Mill And Its Effects On Society Essay

- Mill also addresses the idea of governments interfering in an individual’s life in some form of help or benefit without infringing on any liberties by presenting his three objections. The first of which being the idea that “… when the thing to be done is likely to be better done by individuals than by the government.” (Mill p.121). He believed that individuals can best decide matters which pertain to their own life because they are the ones who are most “personally interested in it.” (Mill p.121) and because the individual is indeed usually the one who possesses the most intimate knowledge of their own life that they should not allow others to decide what is best for them personally....   [tags: Liberalism, John Stuart Mill, John Rawls, Liberty]

Better Essays
1357 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on Marxist Critique Of On Liberty

- To begin a Marxist critique of On Liberty, a summary of both Karl Marx and John Mill’s views are pertinent to the basic understanding of their thoughts through their work. Laying out the fundamentals of their views will help us recognize what types of arguments they might have towards one another on the topic of Net Neutrality. Net Neutrality can broadly be defined as the government intervention to prevent internet providers from charging content providers more for greater access to their internet service....   [tags: Marxism, Social class, John Stuart Mill]

Better Essays
2262 words (6.5 pages)

Essay on John Stuart Mill on Individual Liberty

- John Stuart Mill on Individual Liberty Definition of Individual liberty In his work On Liberty, Mill placed much emphasis on individual liberty and its vital role in political society. To Mill, this phrase may be defined as the liberty of the individual to be the final judge over his actions; to decide what is right and wrong and to act upon that standard. On a secondary level, it also implies one's freedom to pursue one's own individuality. Mill believed in a society in which each individual leads his own distinctive life according to his own unique talents; unfettered by regulations upon thought, opinion, actions etc....   [tags: Politics Mill Liberty Philosophy]

Better Essays
2361 words (6.7 pages)

John Stuart Mill's View on Liberty Essay examples

- (1) Thesis: “...to bring a child into existence without a fair prospect of being able, not only to provide food for its body, but instruction and training for its mind is a moral crime, both against the unfortunate offspring and against society” – John Stuart Mill, On Liberty. What is liberty. That is a great question. Liberty is more than a simple definition. It a vast topic that has been widely debated for centuries. John Stuart Mill is an advocate for Liberty. He describes in tremendous detail in his On Liberty publishing how a society should work....   [tags: Fallacies: Harms and Paternalistic Laws]

Better Essays
1451 words (4.1 pages)

John Stewarat Mill's On Liberty and the Subjection of Women Essay

- John Stewarat Mill's On Liberty and the Subjection of Women Born in 1806, John Stewart Mill was an English philosopher who highly prized the Utilitarian belief system, or the doctrine of seeking the greatest amount of good for the greatest amount of people. Among his various political treatises, On Liberty and The Subjection of Women are excellent applications of his convictions in individualism and negative government. Though the subjects of each work differ to an extent, both are written in a dialogue format, and the general principles postulated in On Liberty can be easily applied to the second work....   [tags: Mill Liberty Subjection Women Essays]

Better Essays
993 words (2.8 pages)

John Stuart Mill's Essay On Liberty

- John Stuart Mill's Essay On Liberty The main theme of on liberty was the individual. Everything else, society, education,government and so forth had their basis in the individuals rights to his own liberty. No one, no member of society, government, even God, if he appeared before an individual, could inforce his will upon him. That is not to say that you couldnt change someones mind through discussions, but instead, that no one had a right to force his views upon another. Your happiness is yours(individual) to enjoy without any infringements....   [tags: John Stuart Mill On Liberty]

Better Essays
789 words (2.3 pages)

Liberty of Verbal Expression Essay

- The principle of non-harm was brought forth by James Stuart Mill in On Liberty by introducing two different spheres that make up life. The spheres were private and public. A meaningful life is found when a maximum private sphere is present because decisions are personally beneficial. Democratic historical and social context give background to why the non-harm principle was so revolutionary. The non-harm principle can be applied to freedom of speech in that harm by words only occurs when the result is instant physical harm....   [tags: James Stuart Mill, On Liberty]

Better Essays
2738 words (7.8 pages)

Liberty And Paternalism Essays

- LIBERTY AND PATERNALISM John Stuart Mill and Gerald Dworkin have distinctly opposing views on legal paternalism in that Mill is adamantly against any form of paternalism, whereas Dworkin believes that there do exist circumstances in which paternalism is justified. Both agree that paternalism is justified when the well being of another person is violated or put at risk. Mill takes on a utilitarian argument, explaining that allowing an individual to exercise his freedom of free choice is more beneficial to society than deciding for him what is in his best interests....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
1660 words (4.7 pages)

Essay on Comparing Rousseau And Mill On Liberty

- The term “civil or social liberties” is one that garners a lot of attention and focus from both Rousseau and Mill, although they tackle the subject from slightly different angles. Rousseau believes that the fundamental problem facing people’s capacity to leave the state of nature and enter a society in which their liberty is protected is the ability to “find a form of association that defends and protects the person and goods of each associate with all the common force, and by means of which each one, uniting with all, nevertheless obeys only himself and remains as free as before” (Rousseau 53)....   [tags: Rousseau vs Mill]

Better Essays
1828 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on John Stuart Mill's Views of Paternalism

- I will be discussing John Stuart Mill’s views on paternalism. I will argue how I feel about the subject. Then I will try my best to put myself into Mill’s shoes, argue back and try to see if I can understand where he is coming from with his arguments on paternalism. I plan on saying that there should be certain types of laws for different types of paternalistic acts, weak and strong for example. The laws should depend on what goes on when that act occurs and also after that act. I have strong views against Mill on the general way that he explains paternalism, but when I read more into depth Mill really says what I think should really be done....   [tags: Autonomy in Moral and Political Philosophy]

Better Essays
1697 words (4.8 pages)