How Issues With Validity Impact The Way Mental Disorders Are Categorized

How Issues With Validity Impact The Way Mental Disorders Are Categorized

Length: 1421 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Analyze how issues with validity impact the way mental disorders are categorized.
In all aspects, science demands evidence, and that is where the validity of results come in. The diagnosis of mental illnesses differs with that of physical ailments. For example, diagnosing malaria is a simple process that with tests can be diagnosed. One takes the patient’s blood, tests it for the parasites that cause the disease and makes the diagnosis. There is no room for subjectivity or debate. For many physical diseases, the diagnosis accuracy rate is 100%. The same cannot be said of mental illnesses including dementia and Alzheimer’s.
For these two, the only definite diagnosis can come after death when pathologists inspect the brain under a microscope (Eaton et al, 2012). The damage is usually not clearly defined in scans, and can be overlooked. However, there are standardized tests for the disease, to help understand the outcome of what is happening to the patient. These tests are based on evidence gathered over the years through research and reports by medical professionals. The oral and written assessment questions are standard and based the standard view of how they should be answered by a person without any issues. However, there are still many aspects of the diagnosis that are subjective. One assessor might see signs of dementia while another disagrees. It is the reason that even the best have an accuracy rate of 90% when it comes to diagnosis.
Validity does present a problem in several ways. One of them is that it makes it much easier for practitioners to misdiagnose a patient and get away with it. With the assessment having subjective aspects, practitioners have much more legal room than doctors dealing with physical ailments (Eaton e...


... middle of paper ...


... gets trodden upon. The more a government is involved in research, the more facts it will have with which to judge data provided by pharmaceutical companies.
Dementia and Alzheimer’s are different. The former is a group of symptoms while the latter is a progressive brain disease. John has dementia as the symptoms in the case indicate. He, however, needs to have scans of his brain done to confirm the absence of any other illness. Diagnosis of mental illnesses is in many ways subjective. It is the reason that culture has such an effect on the diagnostic processes and results. Pharmaceutical companies also affect the industry through sponsorship of research, support of KOLs and advertising. The country and the industry, therefore, have to raise their respective ethical codes. Otherwise, the validity of diagnoses will continue to fall to the detriment of mental health.


Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Effects Of Mental Illness On College Students Essay

- Although usually hidden from the public view, a significant number of college students suffer from mental illness. What does it actually mean to suffer from a mental illness. According to Holley A. Belch, “Mental illnesses are medical conditions that disrupt a person’s thinking, feeling, mood, ability to relate to others, and daily functioning” (Belch, 2011, p.75). Upon consideration of this definition, the relevance of mental illnesses pertaining to the college population seems more applicable....   [tags: Mental health, Psychiatry, Mental disorder]

Better Essays
839 words (2.4 pages)

Analysis of Mental Health in Canada Essay

- Close to six million Canadians live with mental illness; let alone the thousands that are undiagnosed. Mental illness has made big headlines in the news in the recent years. The people suffering from mental illness have been faced with discrimination a caused by a stigma towards them. Mental illness can be caused by many different factors whether they are psychological or environmental. Although only twenty percent of Canadians personally experience mental illness in their lifetime, it affects everyone in their lives....   [tags: mental illness,clara hurghes, mental treatment]

Better Essays
1572 words (4.5 pages)

Mental Illness And Its Effects On The Lives Of Those Who Suffer With Mental Condition

- When the subject of defining abnormality is brought to consciousness, many perspectives are put into play. Most would label a person abnormal if he or she deviates from the ideal social norm of a culture, or possessed a maladaptive behavior. Without even realizing what has been perceived, people subconsciously assume that being “abnormal” or possessing an abnormality is a negative factor, making an individual less likely to prosper in his or her life. Mental health conditions are one of the many conditions that are relative to possessing maladaptive behaviors, as well as deviation from the norm of society....   [tags: Psychiatry, Mental disorder, Schizophrenia]

Better Essays
1257 words (3.6 pages)

Mandatory Mental Illness And Developmental Disorder Class Essay

- Kelsi Osterman Dr. O’Brien ENGL 1160-008 20 April, 2016 Mandatory Mental Illness and Developmental Disorder Class in a High School Curriculum A college student goes through the same daily routine. Wake up, go to class, work on homework, go to work, and finally go to sleep. As she continues to do this repetitively, she finds no reward in these activities. School no longer matters to her and her grades begin to drop. She quits her job, and begins to withdraw from her friends. She sleeps most of the time, and she doesn’t know why she feels this way, but she has lost her motivation....   [tags: Abnormal psychology, Mental disorder]

Better Essays
1973 words (5.6 pages)

Essay on Mental Illness And The World Of Criminal Justice And Psychology

- Mental illness is undoubtedly a controversial illness in the world of criminal justice and psychology. When the question is asked, is a mental disorder considered a physiological disorder, one would have to first acknowledge other physiological illnesses and breakdown the word physiological to gain understanding. Mental illness has a tendency to be categorized differently from physiological illness such as heart disease asthma and other diseases (Arboleda-Flórez, 2009). The main question is why....   [tags: Mental disorder, Schizophrenia]

Better Essays
1015 words (2.9 pages)

Mental Health As A Whole And It 's Differences Cross Culturally Essay

- When confronted with the topic of psychological abnormality, typically one will think that it is fairly simple to explain and define. However, nailing down an explicit definition is not as easy as one may think. Saying that it is an action or persistent pattern of thought that is outside of the norm is far too vague to have any impact on the field of psychology, or help anyone who may be struggling with a disorder. Furthermore, when introducing a broader scope of understanding abnormal psychology and mental health, the variability of different cultures makes this all the more challenging....   [tags: Sociology, Mental disorder, Culture]

Better Essays
840 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Sleep Disorders: Rapid Eye Movement

- "Sleep disorders appear to be a global epidemic, affecting up to 45% of the world's population" (Noor, et al n.p.). That’s leaving a 55% chunk of the world’s population not affected. More than 70 million people in our nation experience sleep disorders, most of whom are unaware of the impact on their daily life (Wells,Vaughn 234). Due to a large portion of people being unaware of sleep disorders’ impaction, the number continuously increases. Major sleep disorders are known to be Rapid Eye Movement(REM), Insomnia, and Obstructive Sleep Apnea(OSA)....   [tags: disruptive sleep, success, achievement, insomnia]

Better Essays
1718 words (4.9 pages)

Obsessive Compulsive Related Disorders: Body Dysmorphic Disorder Essay

- Body Dysmorphic Disorder is a relatively common disorder that is categorized with Obsessive Compulsive related disorders. It is defined by the DSM-IV as the preoccupation with an imagined or slight defect in physical appearance that is observable or appear slight to others (Wolrich, 2011) 3. These individuals focus on things such as their face, hair, skin, breast size, muscle size, and genitalia. A Body Dysmorphic Disorder diagnosis is categorized into two criteria. (Criteria A) consist of a individual having a preoccupation with one defect or flaw in their physical appearance, which they believe look ugly, unattractive, abnormal or deformed....   [tags: slight defect, face, hair, skin]

Better Essays
1123 words (3.2 pages)

Exploring Social Marketing Strategies in Addressing Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder

- There are various health disorders, and diseases that can be either preventable or non-preventable within communities. One disorder that can potentially be preventable is Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder (FASD) (Idrus & Thomas, 2011). FASD is an, “umbrella term that encompasses the following disorders: Fetal Alcohol Syndrome, partial Fetal Alcohol Syndrome, Alcohol Related Neurological Disorder, and Alcohol Related Brain Disorder” (Saskatchewan Prevention Institute (SPI), 2009, p. 4). For the purpose of this paper the writer will use the umbrella term, FASD....   [tags: Health, Disorders]

Better Essays
1480 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on Eating Disorders Are Not Categorized Into One Illness

- Eating disorders are not categorized into one illness; there are three subcategories: anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa, and binge eating. “Over one-half of teenage girls and nearly one-third of teenage boys use unhealthy weight control behaviors such as skipping meals, fasting, smoking cigarettes, vomiting, and taking laxatives.” (Neumark-Sztainer, 2005). It is a common misconception that people who suffer from E.D. are easy to point out; this is not true. Approximately 24 million Americans are touched by this disorder yet only 10% seek treatment....   [tags: Eating disorders, Bulimia nervosa]

Better Essays
2049 words (5.9 pages)