Essay about Homosexual Marriages: Two Sides of the Story

Essay about Homosexual Marriages: Two Sides of the Story

Length: 811 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The topic of homosexual marriages, or the marrying of two people of the same sex, is rather disputed among the majority of people in today’s society. Only small amounts of the population have opinions that are strongly favoring one side of the debate. For most of society who are the middle-of-the-road citizens, it is a tough call to make one way or the other. The main topics that are disputed are raising children in a same-sex household, the capacity of churches to allow such a marriage, and the integrity of a marriage as a legal document. These arguments will be expressed through the viewpoints of Andrew Sullivan and William Bennett. Sullivan is the author of the essay “Let Gays Marry” which was printed by Newsweek in June of 1996. William Bennett also contributed his essay to Newsweek in 1996 which was entitled “Leave Marriage Alone”.

Andrew Sullivan expresses his opinion in which he believes that homosexuals should have the right to get married. Sullivan’s main idea is that the marriage of gays should not be illegal. They are human beings just like you and I, “the sons and daughters of countless mothers and fathers” (Sullivan 25) and should have the same opportunities to pursue happiness by marrying the one that they love. Sullivan does not want churches to change their practices, just to allow everyone to be themselves, a principle that the United States was created on. Sullivan presents his case in a very logical fashion, calmly displaying his points there in the text for all to see. I believe that Sullivan has an effective introduction. He uses a statement declared by the United States Supreme Court which states, “A state cannot deem a class of persons a stranger to its laws” (Sullivan 25). Plus, the concept of marriage ...


... middle of paper ...


...y of polygamous marriages. Bennett says marriage is about the raising of children and creation of a family. Sullivan, on the contrary, brings up the fact that many notable “childless heterosexual couples” exist in today’s society such as Senator Bob Dole and his wife Elizabeth Dole (Sullivan 26).

In conclusion, as seen from the two texts contrasted in this essay, homosexual marriages are quite a controversial topic. Both Andrew Sullivan and William Bennett present convincing and provocative arguments for their respective sides. The main topics that are disputed are raising children in a same-sex household, the capacity of churches to allow such a marriage, and the integrity of a marriage as a legal document. In my own personal opinion, I believe that homosexual marriages should be allowed because they are people just like you and I as Sullivan has already stated.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Homosexuality: Two Sides of the Debate Essay

- In today’s society, it is impossible to go two weeks without seeing a headline detailing a recently proposed law regarding same-sex marriages or a news report depicting a mildly influential individual being publicly crucified for expressing degrading comments about homosexuality. Despite the commotion that surrounds the issue, I believe that it is not that complicated of a topic. Personally, I believe that the dispute should be separated into two distinct situations with two distinct solutions. On one hand, you have a political debate....   [tags: same-sex marriage, homosexuality in the church]

Better Essays
1115 words (3.2 pages)

Same Sex Marriages Should be Legal Essay example

- Same Sex Marriages Should be Legal   Flowers, candles, and music are all part of a wedding. As the organist plays "Here Comes the Bride," I notice this is where the similarities end. The bride, who is a woman, is marrying a groom, who is also a woman. Single-sex marriages are only allowed in a few states. However, single-sex marriages should become legal so that couples could enjoy the advantages of marriage. Legalizing single-sex marriage would create more family units and create more tolerance from society, allowing single-sex couples a legal way of expressing their love to each other....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics Gay Lesbian]

Better Essays
835 words (2.4 pages)

Essay about The Fight for Gay Marriage

- Over the past several years the homosexual community has made great strides in attempting to justify their right to legally join in matrimony. Society as a whole has come a long way in becoming more tolerant and acknowledging of same sex partners and their choices to form families. Given our first amendment right to freedom of speech, there are plenty of sentiments regarding whether or not laws should be ratified permitting these male or female partners to have the legal right to marry. There are numerous of current trends that provide absolute support to the homosexual community with hopes of increasing the level of tolerance....   [tags: homosexual rights/legislature]

Better Essays
1374 words (3.9 pages)

Marriage Inequality: The Right to Marry Essay

- Marriage is defined as “(1) the state of being united to a person of the opposite sex as husband or wife in a consensual and contractual relationship recognized by law (2): the state of being united to a person of the same sex in a relationship like that of a traditional marriage ("Marriage," 2003, p. 659). Despite the latter definition’s addition to dictionaries in the past decade, this definition of marriage is still debated. Being a touchy subject in both politics and religion today, it’s been very hard to come to an agreement....   [tags: homosexual,same sex marriage,lgbt community]

Better Essays
1029 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Same Sex Relationship

- What has the world come to. This introduces the clarity and resolution of three group’s civil union, traditionalist and liberals. The three groups have different opinions on same-sex relationships but all use a Christian opinion on the topic. Liberals and Traditionalist have been divided between the profound opinions over same-sex relationships. The realization is that the groups will never agree on the issue, but people hope they will find a way to live together. No doubt this issue is causing a division in churches and society....   [tags: Legal Issues, Homosexual Rights]

Better Essays
1163 words (3.3 pages)

Same-Sex Marriage Essay

- Same-Sex Marriages Marriage is humanity’s version of love written in a legally binding document. Typically when you think of a happy marriage you envision a woman and man exchanging vows of eternal love and support in a church. However, as time has passed homosexuality that was once seen as a“curse” or “affliction” that needs to be driven out has waned by extreme measures, and gay couples’s petition for the right to marry and have their love recognized by the government. Coming from a family with two lesbian sisters and a strong heterosexual father who is a Christian; I’ve seen arguments from both sides and still find that same-sex marriages should be allowed....   [tags: homosexual rights, gay unions]

Better Essays
952 words (2.7 pages)

Should Gays Marry? Essay

- Should Gays Marry. The essays by William Bennett and Andrew Sullivan are just the tip of the iceberg in the debate over homosexual marriage. This debate has been going on for years, with many solidly supported opinions on the topic. Both authors provide strong points and well written essays, and include some similar ideas, even though the message of each essay is contradictory to the other. Andrew Sullivan’s essay, “Let Gays Marry,” is about how gays and lesbians have long been alienated from their basic rights as American citizens....   [tags: Gay Marriages Homosexuality Essays]

Free Essays
833 words (2.4 pages)

Compare and Contrast Two Views of Gay Marriage Essay

- One of the most controversial issues around today is gay marriages. Many believe that the media is primly responsible for the idea of same-sex marriages, but when it all comes down to it there are really only two sides; those who support gay marriages, and those who oppose them. Two authors write their opinions on their opposite views on this issue. Sullivan (2002) supports same-sex marriages and believes marriage to be a universal right, not just restricted to heterosexuals. Contrary to Sullivan, Bennett (2002) believes that marriage is a sacred traditional family value that should be set aside for heterosexual couples....   [tags: Compare Contrast Comparison Essays]

Better Essays
596 words (1.7 pages)

Essay about The Debate on Homosexuals Adopting Children

- People may ask them self, is it acceptable for a homosexual marriage to adopt children. Would children be affected mentally being adopted by a homosexual marriage. Does it make the child happy. Some people say it’s better for a child to be in a gay marriage home than in foster care homes. In the other hand, other people say that it’ll affect children mentally and will be raised in the wrong way. In an online blog, Alpen Gideon describes the discussions people have over homosexual marriages adopting children....   [tags: Homosexual Marriages, Adoption]

Better Essays
1100 words (3.1 pages)

Against Legalizing Homosexual Marriages Essay

- Against Legalizing Homosexual Marriages The legalized marriage of individuals with the same gender is drawing more attention these days. When asked, most people want to avoid the subject of homosexuality altogether or they have a very strong opinion on it. The debate over whether the United States should allow homosexual couples to marry legally is giving rise to a new social dilemma in our country. This question has courtrooms nervous, churches wavering and equal rights activists angry. Courtrooms should be nervous though....   [tags: Gay Lesbian Marriage Papers]

Better Essays
1286 words (3.7 pages)