To begin, the husband and wife’s lack of communication in their relationship is made evident within the first few lines, and Hanif, Jamil, and Mahmood feel that Amy had a mental disorder that prevented communication between her and her husband. They say, “The wife Amy, on the other hand, cannot come in the position to accept the truth of reality” because of her actions throughout the poem, for example, her refusal to talk about the child’s death (Hanif, Jamil, and Mahmood 9). The husband says, “I will find out now---you must tell me, dear” implying that this lackluster communication has been occurring for a while and the husband wishes to mend the strained relationship (Frost 12). However, the problem lies with the wife’s perspective on the husband’s grief. Hanif, Jamil, and Mahmood explain because of the mental disorder that comes from isolating herself, she constantly “…misinterprets her husband…” (10). They also feel that she took shelter in her emotions as they wrote, “Amy discovers shelter in her personal feelings as compared to the impartiality of the husband who is ready to express his emotions about the death of his new born baby” (...
... middle of paper ...
...e on” (10).
To conclude, Hanif, Jamil, and Mahood were correct in their assessment of the poem. Robert Frost depicted the devastation of this imagined situation elegantly and portrayed a troubled woman struggling with her emotions, and a man who struggled to save his marriage. Readers must look at the poem in this manner to understand that the husband does care about the wife and child, but the wife’s inability to escape her grief creates a vast chasm between them. Without the idea that the wife is inescapably depressed the marriage’s destruction seems to be the husbands fault, but it is shown throughout the poem that he is doing everything within his power to fix the marriage. The wife is overly distraught the death of the child, and this leads to her isolating herself from her husband while she misinterprets his actions, and this is what destroys the marriage.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- In “Home Burial,” Robert Frost uses language and imagery to show how differently a man and a women deal with grief. The poem not only describes the grief the two feel for the loss of their child but also the impending death of a marriage. Frost shows this by using a dramatic style set in New England. In his narrative poem, Frost starts a tense conversation between the man and the wife whose first child had died recently. Not only is there dissonance between the couple,but also a major communication conflict between the husband and the wife.... [tags: Poetry, Frost, imagery]
1316 words (3.8 pages)
- "Home Burial," a dramatic narrative largely in the form of dialogue, has 116 lines in informal blank verse. The setting is a windowed stairway in a rural home in which an unnamed farmer and his wife, Amy, live. The immediate intent of the title is made clear when the reader learns that the husband has recently buried their first-born child, a boy, in his family graveyard behind the house. The title can also be taken to suggest that the parents so fundamentally disagree about how to mourn that their "home" life is in mortal jeopardyin danger of being buried.... [tags: Frost Home Burial]
1398 words (4 pages)
- Marriage Graveyard In Robert Frost’s poem “Home Burial”, he shares with us the deep loss of a child, the devastation of a crumbling marriage and a family that has fallen apart. Robert Frost himself experienced great loss and turmoil throughout his life. As he writes this poem, his audience can feel the emotion the characters are feeling. He has the ability to transform you into the moment and feel the hurt, anger, frustration and concoction of emotions that these two people are feeling because he has felt those same things, in the same way.... [tags: Emotion, Feeling, Poetry, Robert Frost]
1789 words (5.1 pages)
- Robert Frost’s poem “Home Burial” allows readers to consider the devastation that parents experience when they lose a child. “Home Burial” captures the differences in the ways people deal with loss and grief. Munaza Hanif, Anila Jamil, and Rabia Mahmood also analyze this fascinating poem in their paper, “AN ANALYSIS OF HOME BURIAL (1914) BY FROST IN PSYCHOANALYTIC PERSPECTIVE” for its representation of people and their grief. Hanif, Jamil, and Mahmood’s analysis of Amy’s psychological breakdown displays how she and her husband’s lack of communication leads to the death of the marriage.... [tags: Marriage, Husband, Wife, Spouse]
1155 words (3.3 pages)
- Home Burial as a Reflection of Reality Robert Frost's "Home Burial" is a masterfully written work, conceived from his and his wife's anguish at the loss of their first-born son as well as from the estrangement between his sister-in-law and her husband due to the death of their child. In Donald J. Greiner's commentary on Frost's works, "The Indespensible Robert Frost," it is revealed that "Mrs. Frost could not ease her grief following Elliot's death, and Frost later reported that she knew then that the world was evil.... [tags: Home Burial Essays]
934 words (2.7 pages)
- The Selfish Misery of Home Burial Robert Frost's poem "Home Burial" is an intriguing portrait of a marital relationship that has gone wrong. Though at first glance it may seem that the cause for the couple's trouble is the death of their child, closer reading allows the reader to see that there are other serious, deeper-rooted problems at work. The couples differences in their approach to grieving is only the beginning of their problems. Many of the real problems lie in the wife's self-absorbed attitude of consuming unhappiness and anger.... [tags: Home Burial Essays]
1675 words (4.8 pages)
- The Insensitive, Selfish Husband of Home Burial Even in the closest of relationships, the death of a baby can separate and form a wedge between a husband and wife. Husbands and wives tend to handle the process of mourning differently, not only because of the differences between male and female, but also because of personality and the social molding in one's upbringing. In the poem, "Home Burial," Robert Frost gives a glimpse of the conflicts caused by non-communication and misunderstanding between a husband and wife upon the death of their first and only child.... [tags: Home Burial Essays]
1192 words (3.4 pages)
- The Three Tragedies of Home Burial Robert Frost’s "Home Burial" is a narrative poem that speaks of life’s tragedies. The theme of "Home Burial” centers around the death of a child. During the time period in which the poem is set, society dictated that men did not show their feelings. Therefore, men dealt with conflicts by working hard and being domineering. "Home Burial" demonstrates how one tragedy can cause another to occur. The unnamed couple in this poem has lost a baby to death.... [tags: Home Burial Essays]
1279 words (3.7 pages)
- Robert Frost's Home Burial Robert Frost's dramatic dialogue poem, "Home Burial," is the story of a short, but important, episode in the marriage of a typical New England farm couple. They are "typical" because their "public" personalities are stoic and unimaginative, and because their lives are set within the stark necessities of northeastern American farm life. Yet, they are also typical in that their emotions are those one might expect of young parents who have abruptly and, to them, inexplicably lost their baby.... [tags: Poetry Poets Dialogue Poems Essays]
1250 words (3.6 pages)
- Robert Frost's "Love and a Question," "Mending Wall," and "Home Burial" In Robert Frost’s poems “Love and a Question,” “Mending Wall,” and “Home Burial,” there is a significant barrier present between man and man or woman. Conflict between people is a major theme for these poems, and it alters the outcome of them. There is a great deal of tension present between the characters, causing unstable relationships, as well as a desire for no relationship at all. These three poems are based around knowing that conflict is inevitable, and it evidently causes a desire for little to no human interaction.... [tags: Robert Frost Question Mending Burial Essays]
2363 words (6.8 pages)