HIV and AIDS: Public Safety vs. Civil Liberties Essay

HIV and AIDS: Public Safety vs. Civil Liberties Essay

Length: 1673 words (4.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

When a nation is faced with a deadly epidemic does the country have the right to suspend individual’s rights in order to better protect the welfare of the community? This debate has emerged across the U.S.; many have implemented quarantines with regards to h1n1 virus and other contagious, potentially deadly diseases. This includes but is not limited to isolating individuals infected, closing schools, and shutting down public transportation systems. Others are considering enacting new and controversial rules. “Since the outbreak of the new flu strain, Massachusetts legislators have sought to pass a law that would allow officials to detain or quarantine someone even when there is uncertainty over the person's exposure to contagious disease. Other states have adopted similar laws in recent years” (Efarti 1). These laws can give states the right to contain persons, violating individual rights for the betterment of society.
With the government having the ability to quarantine patients infected with potentially harmful diseases on questions the rights the individual has. Can the country detain HIV victims so that the disease will be eliminated? Should the county detain these infected persons for the safety of the community? This issue is constantly debated; by presenting community safety and personal rights in America one can better understand societal nature.
Living with HIV is a constant battle, with the disease, self, others, and government. If one contrasts HIV there are legal ramifications one must abide too. Each state is different, this paper will explain the laws of, ‘Wisconsin’ and any legal obligations a person with HIV/AIDS must follow. Once getting an HIV test whether one gets a confidential or anonymous test, know that...


... middle of paper ...


...p://www.hsolc.org/policies/childcare/communicable-disease-protocol>.

2) Efarti, Amir. "Public Safety v. Civil Liberties: Health Crisis Leads to New Case." TheWallStreetJournal.com. 7 May 2009. Web. 15 Feb. 2011. .

3) Gallant, Joel E. 100 Questions & Answers about HIV and AIDS. Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett, 2009. Print.

4) "PHILA.GOV | Welcome to the City of Philadelphia." Internet Archive: Wayback Machine. Web. 01 Nov. 2011. .

5) "STD Lawsuits « Sexually Transmitted Diseases (STDs), Herpes, HIV Lawsuit." Sexually Transmitted Diseases (STDs), Herpes, HIV Lawsuit. Web. 01 Nov. 2011. .

6) Wisconsin State Law., art. 252, sec. 1-400. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The System of Governance and Americans' Rights and Liberties Essay examples

- Overall, the United States system of government is effective in protecting the rights and liberties of its citizens. The systems of checks and balances as well as concurrent powers exist to protect Americans’ liberties and represent their interests. The use of public opinion and the media also play a large role in the functioning of the system of governance and at the same time act to safeguard the liberties and rights of the American people. The United States government consists of three branches, in which each branch monitors the actions and decisions of the other two branches (Schmidt, 2013)....   [tags: individual rights and liberties]

Powerful Essays
2360 words (6.7 pages)

Hiv And Public Health Issues Essay

- HIV and Public Health Public health involves a number of factors; it is a science that aims to improve and educate the public in many aspects regarding health. A public health issue that can affect anyone anywhere is the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Public Health and HIV is a topic widely researched. Since there is no cure for such a disease, it is important to research and study this virus in hopes of bettering the outcomes for those inflicted with it. Ultimately, HIV can be prevented which is why it is necessary to raise awareness¬ to the public about the disease....   [tags: HIV, AIDS, Africa, Antiretroviral drug]

Powerful Essays
2043 words (5.8 pages)

Essay about The Patriot Act vs Civil Liberties

- Is the patriot act necessary if it protects but threatens our civil liberates. The patriot act threatens civil liberates. The U.S. is spying without the people’s consent. The patriot act will prevent terrorist attacks on the United States. The patriot act can be used to catch wanted criminals. The patriot act protects the people from danger but jeopardizes their civil rights. “We have to make a balance between security and civil liberties.”(Sensenbrenner 2). The patriot act was passed with very little congressional debate....   [tags: politics, civil liberties]

Powerful Essays
1016 words (2.9 pages)

Civil Liberties And Safety By Benjamin Franklin Essay

- Civil Liberties and safety Benjamin Franklin once said “Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.” It should be every rational citizen’s question if we should exchange our civil liberties for safety. How far do we have to go to keep our civil liberties from being violated. We are consistently surveyed by the government in every step. The government is going through our phone calls, text messages, private emails and social media....   [tags: United States Constitution]

Powerful Essays
1248 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on An Infectious Disease And Public Health Concerning Hiv And Aids

- This paper will cover the topics surrounding an infectious disease and public health concerning HIV and AIDS. It will address information consisting of: a description of the disease, work conducted by government departments to reduce the impact; investigations, research studies, and surveillance data; government finding and investigations; past current and ongoing research. Human immunodeficiency virus infection (HIV) and acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS) is a form of disease affecting the immune system resulting from the HIV virus....   [tags: AIDS, HIV, Immune system, Antiretroviral drug]

Powerful Essays
937 words (2.7 pages)

Using Hiv / Aids As An Example Of Public Health Surveillance Essay

- 1. Using HIV/AIDS as an example to discuss why public health authorities need to conduct public health surveillance and to describe how surveillance system is managed in Australia (9 marks) (up to 800 words) The term public health surveillance has been defined as ‘the continuous, systematic collection, analysis and interpretation of health-related data needed for the planning, implementation, and evaluation of public health practice’ (WHO, 2016). Consequently, the fundamental goal of public health surveillance is to collect information as to prevent, control and take action in relation to all forms of diseases, including HIVAIDS....   [tags: Epidemiology, Public health, AIDS]

Powerful Essays
1360 words (3.9 pages)

The Public Health Triad Essay

- Introduction The role of public health in our society cannot be underestimated. The main goal of public health is to prevent and control diseases with the aim of promoting health. Humans contribute to this health promotion. However, human actions are also responsible to some detrimental health effects. Human behavior through habitat modification has led to the emergence of infectious diseases “Modification of natural habitats by humans is a leading cause of emerging zoonoses” (Battle, 2009, P 32)....   [tags: Public Safety]

Powerful Essays
1024 words (2.9 pages)

HIV Essay

- HIV Many eyebrows raised late in 1979, when the then unkown HIV virus raised its ugly head. The first two cases of the rare cancer, Karposis Sarcoma was diagnosed in two homosexual men in N>Y>C. About the same time in Los Angeles, several cases of the rare infection, Pneumocytis cariini pneumonia were being treated. Incidences of these strange diseases and infections were sky-rocketting around the country. The disease was effecting mostly young gay men in their 30's. There was no official name for the syndrome, but it was referred to by various names, GRID (gay related inmmune disease), Gay Cancer, and, "Community Acquired Syndrome"....   [tags: STD, HIV, AIDS]

Free Essays
1024 words (2.9 pages)

HIV Essay

- HIV People who inherit only one copy of a mutated gene that has an effect on HIV's ability to enter CD4 T-helper cells appear to be substantially less likely to become infected with the virus, according to a new report by researchers at New York University School of Medicine in New York City and collaborators at other institutions. Such a protective effect, if proven, falls far short of completely safeguarding individuals who carry a single copy of the gene mutation from the risk of HIV infection....   [tags: HIV and AIDS]

Free Essays
420 words (1.2 pages)

HIV Essay

- HIV Like the majority of the American population I have lived in a cloud of ignorance about the HIV and AIDS crisis. I have never know anyone close to me that has been infected with either of the two viruses. So when the option to research something to do with sexuality arouse I felt this would definitely further my education about a lethal killer that is roaming this earth. Since I knew next to nothing about this topic I will start from the begging of the disease and discuss where it's at now....   [tags: HIV and AIDS]

Powerful Essays
1857 words (5.3 pages)