Essay about History Of The Chinese Criminal Procedure Law

Essay about History Of The Chinese Criminal Procedure Law

Length: 1803 words (5.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Chapter Three – History of the Chinese Criminal Procedure Law

Section 1 – The Chinese Criminal Procedure Law before 1996

3-1-1 The Chinese Criminal Procedure Law before 1979

Along with its historical evolution of its economic, politic and social systems, the Chinese judicial system has been gradually developing. For hundreds of years Chinese judicial system has been proliferating by adopting legal doctrines from other countries however, today the Chinese judicial system as a whole is the result of a rich Chinese history and practical experience. Indeed, for around two millennia China had withheld its own unique legal system. During that time, the notion of “law” equated “punishment”. The Chinese traditional law, pre-1911, was conceived on the basis of an inclusive code containing many types of rules with criminal punishments.

3-1-1-1 Protection of individual’s rights

When talking about the Chinese traditional history of law it is often mentioned that China lacks emphasis on the rights of the individual in criminal justice. Indeed, in Chinese legal tradition there is no equivalent of the concept of western countries which was what was at the origin of the international regime of human rights as known today . During China’s history of feudal period (from 475 B.C to A.D 1840), the criminal justice was characterized by the presumption of guilt. Nevertheless, looking into the China’s legal culture it does seems that individuals and their dignity and values were recognized. For instance, Lu Xing have described that in former declaration on criminal procedure if the case was doubtful and guilt not conclusive, the court should not deal with this case . This emphasizes that if a person could not be proven guilty by evidence, then he ...


... middle of paper ...


...d in the Criminal Procedure Law. And already by the end of 1995, the National People’s Congress’s Standing Committee had already approximately twenty revisions concerning criminal procedure matters.

As a result from these inconsistencies and need of further development of fundamental principles, Chinese scholars began to discuss further improvement of the Chinese Criminal Procedure Law in the early 1990s. Also, during that time, China began opening up its economy to the outside world. This opening up to western culture meant that scholars increasingly looked into the European and North American judicial systems in order to develop a way to improve their current criminal procedure law. This led to the discussion by the National People’s Congress of the Draft Amendment to The Criminal Procedure Law and adopted the Decision to Revise the Criminal Procedure Law in 1996.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Germany And The Criminal Justice System Essay

- On the other side of the criminal justice spectrum, there is Germany, a nation with a shaky and complex history. Until October of 1990, Germany was divided into two separate nations, West Germany and East Germany. The criminal justice system existing in modern Germany represents a combination of “Civil Law” as well as “Common Law.” The history and culture of Germany is deeply rooted into the crafting and maintenance of the German criminal justice system. In Germany, “obedience to the laws of the state, and firm discipline conforming itself with these laws, are, in Germany thought to be the most needful things in public life (Hartmann, 1911)....   [tags: Law, Criminal justice, Police, Germany]

Strong Essays
971 words (2.8 pages)

The Main Types Of Ancient Chinese Punishment Essay

- Form ancient times until now, punishment acts as an indispensable part of the legal system for each country. The penal system is an important tool which protects private ownership, guarantees civil security, and maintains political domination. China is a famous country which has been advocate criminal law since thousands of year ago. Therefore, the Chinese penal system is a valuable reference for studying the variety of punishments. We can consider the three main types of ancient Chinese punishment: imprisonment, corporal punishment, seriously, and capital punishment....   [tags: Prison, Capital punishment, China, Criminal law]

Strong Essays
713 words (2 pages)

How Law is Made and Interpreted in France, China and Indonesia Essay

- Outline How Law is Made and Interpreted in French Civil Law System French Civil Code of 1804 Sources of French Civil Law Doctrine How Law is Made and Interpreted in China Confucianism Legalism How Sharia Law is Made and Interpreted in Pluralist Indonesian System How Law is Made and Interpreted in French Civil Law System The civil law is a branch of private law governing relations between people, whether individuals or legal entities (Sacco, 1991, p.25). It comprises of: 1. The law of obligations (including contract law); 2. The right people; 3. The family law; 4. The right of property; 5. The law of succession....   [tags: Transnational Law Essays]

Strong Essays
2636 words (7.5 pages)

Guns in American History Essay

- Guns have played a big part in American history. The first settlers found an abundant amount of edible game when they came to this continent. Guns were very useful in hunting for food in this vas landscape. Familiarity with a rifle was an essential skill which also helped the Colonist of the new world to defeat the British troops during the Revolutionary War that was fought from 1775-1783. After the Revolutionary War was over, guns became even more important to American history in the taming of the west....   [tags: america, USA, history, guns, ]

Strong Essays
1077 words (3.1 pages)

Forensic Science: The Future of Criminal Justice Essay

- Forensic Science The idea of using the science has been started before the debuting of Sherlock Holmes in 1887, who had introduced about the forensic science to help criminal investigation. In history, the work of forensic scientists was performed by medical personnel. Until the end of eighteenth century, the attempts of French medical jurist Antoine Louis, crime solving Chinese book “ Hsi Duan Yu”(the washing way of wrongs), etc gave ideas about determining time of death, analyzing blood stain, identifying chemical used in crime, etc....   [tags: Criminology ]

Strong Essays
972 words (2.8 pages)

Race, Drugs, And The Criminal Justice System Essay

- Race, Drugs, and the Criminal Justice System In February 1914, the New York Times published an article titled “Negro Cocaine ‘Fiend’ New Southern Menace”, this article claimed that black men addicted to cocaine were “uniquely murderous”, “better marksmen”, and “resistant to fatal wounds” (Williams). Unsurprisingly this article wasn’t the only one of its kind. During the late 1800’s there were many articles written about the exaggerated effects of cocaine usage that were used to justify the lynching of black men and eventually went on to influence narcotic legislation (Hart)....   [tags: Drug, Drug addiction, Heroin, Morphine]

Strong Essays
1312 words (3.7 pages)

A Formal Legal System Of China Essay

- Historically, China has operated without a formal legal system and has instead relied on methods relating to social control and mediation. Instead of implementing a comprehensive legal system, the Chinese government has relied on Confucian and Taoist principles to settle disputes. Since the beginning Chinese history, until the Communist takeover, all legal disputes have been settled through compromise and mediation (Dammer & Albanese, 2011, p. 76). Any criminal codes that did exist before this time were merely used as a means of protecting the totalitarian governments in place (Dammer & Albanese, 2011, p....   [tags: Law, Criminal law, Crime, Police]

Strong Essays
774 words (2.2 pages)

The Freedom Of Assembly Law Essays

- While looking online through different websites that contained articles and history involving the freedom to assemble, I found out about the Peace Protests in Burma. The country has a history of fighting for their rights, but there has been an uproar in recent months regarding the people peacefully protesting for changes in land and education in their country. Although their country rules are different from the United States, they still have the right to assemble peacefully if they get permission from the government five days in advance before they protest....   [tags: Nonviolence, Civil disobedience, Human rights]

Strong Essays
1452 words (4.1 pages)

The Fall of the Qing Dynasty Essay

- D’Addese 1 The Qing Dynasty prospered well into the 20th century despite the numerous problems the administration faced. However, during the early days of the 20th century, civil disorders continued to grow in such unmanageable factions that the administration was pushed to do something about it. The high living standards of the previous century had contributed to a sharp increase in China’s population, there was approximately 400 million people living in China around the nineteenth century. This spike increased population density, it also created a surplus of labour shortages, land shortages, inadequate food production and several famines....   [tags: Chinese history, politics, economics]

Strong Essays
1673 words (4.8 pages)

Hong Kong’s Criminal Justice System Essay

- Hong Kong has a rich and vibrant history from plundering wild pirates, influential clans and bounteous European traders. The Hong Kong we know today was created when China's Qing dynasty government was overthrown in what was called the First Opium War in 1842, when it surrendered the island of Hong Kong to Britain. This set off a landslide of events that would change Hong Kong. In 1898, China leased 235 islands to Britain for 99 years. During those 99 years many changes took place, that changed Hong Kong to a special administrative region of the People's Republic of China (PRC)(http://www.discoverhongkong.com/eng/plan-your-trip/know-hong-kong/history.jsp) A Brief History In 1937, Sino-Japane...   [tags: china, hong kong, chris pattern]

Strong Essays
888 words (2.5 pages)