History Is Not An Exact Science Essay

History Is Not An Exact Science Essay

Length: 2665 words (7.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Research Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview


Some define History as science due to its approach on analysing facts and the use of all resources in the aim of finding an answer while others claim it is merely an artistic study of the ages. J.B Bury claimed “History is a science, no more and no less”, in a time just after dramatic changes had been made to the approach of analgising History as he represented many people in the Victorian generation and their want in a more factual basis of history. Throughout the nineteenth century we saw calls from the people for a more accurate understanding of the past. Jared Diamond claims historians “receive little training in acknowledged sciences and their methodologies.” Many schools and philosophers are of the opinion that history is not a science, due to its lack of ability to provide definite answers. However many argue there are many similar methodologies used by both practices, along with similar end goals of perhaps learning from past mistakes to counteract future and current problems . It will be difficult to come with a definite answer in this essay whether history is a science as it has been debated by some of the top historians of our century such as Edward Carr. By using sources from Carr and other top philosophers and historians I will aim to outline the meaning of history and science, the similarities in the two, along with the differences. I will also outline the fine line between the subjects as part of my analysis in an aim to come up with as structured of an answer as possible on a very complex topic of debate.

To successfully analyses whether History is a science, or more, or less than we must decide on an accurate approach to the term science. Mikael Karlsson stated in a lecture to the University of Genova that...


... middle of paper ...


... and Social Theory (Cambridge, 1992
Carr, Edward. ‘What is History?’. (Suffolk, 1987)
Cureo, Ernest. ‘Science and History’. (New York, 1963)
Dovring, Folke. ‘History as a Social Science’. (The Hague, 1960)
Gaddis, John Lewis “The Landscape of History” (Oxford, 2002)
Goodheart, Eugene. Philosophy and Literature, Is History a Science Volume 29, Number 2, (October 2005)
Haskell,Fain. History and Theory History as Science” vol 9 (1970) p. 154-173
Shafer. Boyd C. Pacific Historical Review, History, not art, not science but history. Vol. 29, No. 2 (May, 1960) pp. 159-170
Teggart F.J., Theory and Processes of History (Berkeley,1960),
Tosh, Josh & Lang, Sean. ‘The Pursuit of History’. (Dorchester, 2006)
Nasson, Bill. History: The meaning and role of history in human development , accessed 26/12/2013 http://www.eolss.net/sample-chapters/c04/e6-22-00-00.pdf


Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Science, Non Science And Pseudo Science

- When it comes to the word ‘science’ most of the people have some kind of knowledge about science or when they think of it there is some kind of image related to science, a theory, scientific words or scientific research, many different sorts of ideas float into an individual’s mind. Every individual has a different perception about science and how he/she perceives it. This illustrates that each individual can identify science in some sort of form. This indicates that science plays a vital role in our everyday lives (Lederman & Tobin, 2002)....   [tags: Scientific method, Theory, Science, Pseudoscience]

Research Papers
1482 words (4.2 pages)

Comparing History and Human Science Essay

- Historians use sources and knowledge to piece together the history of the human existence while Human scientist study the human behavior as well as the lifestyle we live in. They indeed focus on these areas and provide information to each other. However, a historian will also look to the future and foretell using his or her knowledge of the past. In the same way, a human scientist might look at human behavior today and compare it with the past. For when we look at human science, historians find it as useful term for science with the word ‘human’ as the subject (Smith)....   [tags: philosophy, human behavior]

Research Papers
1064 words (3 pages)

Human Science and History Essay

- “The historian’s task is to understand the past; the human scientist, by contrast, is looking to change the future.” To what extent is this true in these areas of knowledge. As historians study, compiles and writes events in chronological order or arranged events in the order it came to be, people understood what came before them. Historians are the authority on it that no one ever tried to question what was written but instead we accepted it as facts and from those facts we learned and knew that as time and years go by people could and can change the future....   [tags: Human Innovation, Intuition]

Research Papers
1027 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on The Role of Natural History

- In Cuvier’s introduction he discusses the essence of natural sciences as to “render sensible in all its parts the mutual influence of every being” (Cuvier, 4). Cuvier is able to show that natural history is an indispensible part of natural philosophy and can successfully unveil the laws of nature. In making this assertion Cuvier argues that natural history plays an equal and scientific role in uncovering the system of natural sciences when compared to more empirical methods such as dynamics or chemistry....   [tags: Science]

Research Papers
758 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Homosexuality Throughout History

- Homosexuality can be tracked throughout history. In ancient Rome, philosophers, such as Socrates, were having sexual relations with their students. They believed it was a part of becoming a man. The Bible, one of the oldest books in literature, discusses homosexual practices among the citizens of Sodom and Gomorrah. Some of the most influential people throughout history were discovered to be homosexual: Susan B. Anthony, William Shakespeare, Leonardo Da Vinci, and Tennessee Williams. Homosexuality is worldwide and has a global impact on society; it transcends borders, cultures, and governments....   [tags: A Brief History of Homosexuality]

Research Papers
2385 words (6.8 pages)

Is Politics A Soft Science? Essay

- As many scholars from around the world are studying political sciences and a large number of work is related with political science, a debate has been rising and taking place on whether or not they are legitimate, and if so in political or/and science. Can we consider them political and/or scientists. If not, how can one consider their work. Can one give any meaning to why they are studying or working in this particular domain. Should the word science and scientist be reconsidered as many tend to think that politics is a soft science, meaning not reliable or with an inconstant method, while others argue that looking through its epistemology, politics has its own and righteous place in scienc...   [tags: Social sciences, Scientific method, Politics]

Research Papers
1428 words (4.1 pages)

The Role of Vocabulary in Understanding Science, Mathematics, History and Art Concepts

- When acquiring knowledge from the areas of science, mathematics, history and art, we use language as a tool to understand or communicate certain concepts. Language consists of vocabulary- a set of words that a person may use while communicating these concepts. If we consider living without any language, would we still know what we know. The answer is quite possibly, no. Naturally, as vocabulary is a part of a language, it too plays an essential role in the understanding and communication of these concepts....   [tags: Language ]

Research Papers
1481 words (4.2 pages)

Forensic Sciences: The Science of Fingerprint Identification Essay

- After giving much thought to the many areas covered by Forensics Sciences, the main criteria to which my choices were narrowed and ultimately the final decision of Ballistics and/or Fingerprint Analysis was based on by the complexity of the job, need for a keen eye, and my wanting to be challenged in a career. I have no doubt that there are other areas that would be just if not more challenging however interest is a another key element in the making such a life changing and difficult decision. The history of firearm and tool-mark identification has been a long one having evolved with great bounds over the last 165 years from the simple observation, physical matching, and caliber determinati...   [tags: Career Research ]

Research Papers
1863 words (5.3 pages)

Essay about Psychology is a Science

- Psychology is definitely not what I thought it was. It is not just a therapist wanting to take your money and not do anything for it. Psychology is an exact science that uses the scientific method to figure out problems. Things like astrology and graphology are not a real science, they do not use true science to deduct things and find a true answer. There are a lot of different ideas within the history of psychology. There was Structuralism, which focused on the structure of the mind. Fuctionalism believed in adapting to ones environment, Gesalt Psychology, focusing on the whole rather than the parts, Behaviorism, no studying of the mental processes, only behaviors, and Psychoanalysis, which...   [tags: essays research papers]

Research Papers
503 words (1.4 pages)

Science vs. Religion Essay

- Science vs. Religion The question as to whether or not religion belongs in a science classroom is a very complex and difficult question. Religion can be looked at from different angles, starting from its validity. Despite the lack of evidence to support the idea of creationism, that in itself is not enough to warrant its exclusion from schools. I don't think students should be told who or what to believe in, but they should acquire enough knowledge on both subjects in order to think and make the decision for themselves....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
437 words (1.2 pages)