Historians' Changing Opinions of Oliver Cromwell Essay

Historians' Changing Opinions of Oliver Cromwell Essay

Length: 1122 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Oliver Cromwell was a well known military dictator. He helped the Parliamentarians win the First Civil War and was named Lord Protector. He died in 1658 but many people still remember him as one of the best leaders in history although others believe he was a harsh tyrant and always wanted too much power for himself. Throughout the years, numerous historians have changed their views on whether he was a good leader or not. This work will look at three interpretations from different people on who Cromwell was and what he was like and compare them.

Winstanley said, “Cromwell was the English monster who tried to destroy our monarchy.” William Winstanley, a writer and diarist, was a strong Royalist. He was also known as “The Man Who Saved Christmas”.

His opinion could be thought of as biased because he was a Royalist the opposite of Cromwell, the Parliamentarian. This would mean he had beliefs completely different. He experienced life under Cromwell’s power, lived through the civil war and would have witnessed how harsh Cromwell could be. This would of course taint any view he had of the man.

Winstanley came from a wealthy family and would not have suffered the same as poor people and with being a Royalist this meant that he risked getting on the wrong side of Cromwell.

Another factor was that Cromwell cancelled Christmas for 18 years so was a real life Scrooge and it was not celebrated again till after Cromwell’s death. Winstanley continued celebrating the holiday and it is probably due to him that Christmas is not just another frosty day.

The monarchy had only just been reformed in 1660 so when Winstanley made this statement, little time had passed. However, with Cromwell being heavily involved in the trial and ex...

... middle of paper ...

... understand that side of Cromwell.
Winstanley is a partly dependable resource as he lived at the time of Cromwell. His differing view from Cromwell must have influenced his opinion but his statement is for the most part based in truth, other than the personal insult of calling Cromwell ‘the English monster’.
Roseberry is possibly the least believable as he was writing over 200 years after the matter and his opinions were tainted by the things happening at the time i.e. the Boer War, etc. He was a Liberal and well educated and this could hint that he was capable of analysing the evidence well, so it is difficult to know how accurate his statement is and he could be using Cromwell’s previous success to influence current matters.

It is important to understand the background of the person doing the reporting of events as it can influence what they think and say.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Oliver Cromwell Essay

- Oliver Cromwell Oliver Cromwell, a Puritan fundamentalist and undefeated commander of the "Ironsides", forever changed the history of England with, perhaps, what he did not do, rather than what he did do after the success of the insurrection he led against Charles. Though rather unsuccessful as a politician, Cromwell, single-handedly redefining the art of war and military strategy, proved to be one of the greatest military geniuses of all time. Despite the professionally trained forces that often outnumbered him three to one in battle, he struck fear in his opposition and maintained an untarnished record in battle that proved the degree of his skill....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
685 words (2 pages)

Essay on cromwell

- Cromwell, Oliver (1599-1658), led the armed forces of Parliament to victory in the English Civil War in the 1640's and ruled England from 1653 to 1658. He had an iron will and was a military genius. Few leaders have inspired more love and respect or more fear and hatred. Cromwell was born in Huntingdon, England, near Peterborough. He came from a wealthy and influential family. Cromwell studied at Sidney Sussex College in Cambridge, but his father's death forced him to leave before getting a degree....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
720 words (2.1 pages)

Oliver Cromwell as a Hero or Villain Essay examples

- The aim of this essay, is to answer the long-awaited question 'Was Oliver Cromwell a hero or a villain. This question, is a hard one to answer. James Heath once said "His name and memory stink." In opposition, Samuel Pepys said "People look back and praise him." True. Or Not. This essay will argue Edmond Ludlow's words," How glorious, but then such betrayal!" Oliver Cromwell was neither a hero nor a villain. The evidence and opinions gathered will state, how he went from good to bad, and from bad to evil....   [tags: History Ireland Cromwell]

Strong Essays
1645 words (4.7 pages)

Oliver Cromwell a Hero not a Villain Essay

- Was Oliver Cromwell a hero or a villain. I think Oliver Cromwell was a hero. He was good – hearted and ambitious, and he wanted England to be at it’s best with no corruption and unfair methods. He thought Charles was not doing the right thing, so he worked hard and got him executed. Oliver Cromwell was a Member of Parliament (MP) and was against king Charles and his ways, so he worked hard and got the king executed. After that, he got offered the post of king, but he refused it, but was Lord Protector of the country....   [tags: Leaders Politics English History]

Strong Essays
847 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Oliver Cromwell - A Hero for Some but a Villian for Many

- ... After the death of the king, Parliament ran England - but still, in Cromwell’s point of view this system did not work effectively. He saw that the people in England were suffering and therefore he rose to become Protector of the Commonwealth. In spite of disagreements with Parliament, Cromwell brought peace and prosperity to England, which was one of the greatest benefits he earned for his country. He was even offered the crown in 1657 but rejected it. As mentioned above, Cromwell’s reign in England was immensely shaped by his religious beliefs and numerous of his reforms concerned religion....   [tags: british and irish history, biography]

Strong Essays
644 words (1.8 pages)

Oliver Cromwell Essay

- A strong man, with skillful military ability, helped to construct a plan to overthrow King Charles I during his reign of tyranny (Iggulden, Conn and Iggulden 79). Oliver Cromwell was well-known as one of the most controversial heroes of his time. Cromwell played a big part in the military as a soldier and a general. He was also a part of the English Parliament, which was somewhat corrupt during this time period. Oliver Cromwell was born April 25, 1599, in Huntingdon, England; near the end of the Elizabethan age (Kaplan 5)....   [tags: Biography]

Strong Essays
1592 words (4.5 pages)

Oliver Cromwell's Life Essay

- Oliver Cromwell was born on April 25, 1599 to Robert Cromwell and Elizabeth Steward, and died in 1658. He grew up in Huntingdon, and his family was very prominent. While his immediate family was not well off, extended parts of his family were very wealthy. He was registered at Sydney Sussex College in 1616, and left in 1617 after his father passed away. He had to return home to take care of his family and help his mother. On August 22, 1620 he was married to Elizabeth Bourchier, who was the daughter of a retired fur trader, with a substantial amount of land in Essex and ties to influential families there....   [tags: england, puritan, lord protector]

Strong Essays
1515 words (4.3 pages)

Oliver Cromwell Essay

- Oliver Cromwell Oliver Cromwell is one of the most controversial personalities in England's history. Many scientists have been arguing about him for centuries. Some of them assert that Cromwell was a hypocritical and selfish tyrant, rebelling only for the sake of money and fame, while others argue that he was a real revolutionary and fighter for wellbeing of the English nation. Who is right. What is a reasonable evaluation of Cromwell today. "The English bourgeois revolution of the 17th century was the first revolution on a European scale....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1056 words (3 pages)

Oliver Cromwell Essay

- Oliver Cromwell Although the disputation of religion also helped to stir up the English civil war, its fundamental causes were the constitutional conflicts. Many English and the members of the parliament, including Oliver Cromwell, were not satisfied with how the king ruled over their country. This was interfused with the conflicting issues over religions. Many English may have been frustrated by William Laud, Charles’ main political advisor pointed as the archbishop of Canterbury in 1633, who attempted to make reforms in the Church of England....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
726 words (2.1 pages)

Oliver Cromwell's Achievement of His Objectives from 1642 to 1658 Essay

- Oliver Cromwell's Achievement of His Objectives from 1642 to 1658 To look at Cromwell’s aims and whether he achieved them or not is to enter “a minefield of` historical controversy and uncertainty,” as modern day historian Barry Coward put it. Cromwell’s aims have always been somewhat of a paradox so to answer whether he achieved them all would be impossible. Many of his goals contradicted or obstructed some of his other views. The views which he held closest to his heart were ‘Liberty of Conscience’ – Cromwell’s belief in religious toleration, a united National Church, the ‘Reformations of Manners’- his goal of a nation of Godly people, and social and legal refo...   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1876 words (5.4 pages)