The Historians and The Critics: Ronald S. Crane´s View on Literature

The Historians and The Critics: Ronald S. Crane´s View on Literature

Length: 529 words (1.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Ronald S. Crane’s essay concerns the way in which the literary scholar should be viewed. There are two different ideas: the historian and the critic. Crane mentions Howard Mumford Jones, placing him at one end of the spectrum. Jones believes when approaching literature, one must focus on the world and how it is changing, recording all events so those who come after him/her can understand and pass judgments based on facts. At the other end of the spectrum, Crane sets John Livingston Lowes in the foreground, stating that criticism is the only justification to literature. He does not say that we should ignore history, but rather should use it as tool to understand human emotion and to find the deeper meaning through literature.
In Crane’s argument for history, he proposes we ask what is involved in writing history and apply those findings to literature, when it is considered an art form. He says what we take from historical criticism is the same thing we take from any type of historical study: we want to know how humanity has changed. While he believes this is all good, we need to see that it is not the only thing, or the best thing, when it comes to literature. In the second section, Crane begins to show his side of the argument, namely that literary criticism is superior to that of historical criticism. Crane believes that literature is art, so before one criticizes it, one must appreciate it. Also, he states that art is meant to be enjoyed and those who read literary texts should be sensitive to that fact and thus cannot merely be “learned men.”
At the end of his essay, Crane makes it clear he believes that literary criticism is superior to historical criticism. He believes that students should read literature, not about it. His “new criticism” is one that follows pluralism and is a melding of the two previously stated ideas. Crane talks of both literary criticism and historical criticism as a spring board to fully understanding literature and believes that in the future, we can decide on what is a true critical fact rather than all these theories. He says we need to revive the classics and when that happens, the “renewed cultivation” of reading and writing will commence. This, Crane believes, is what any worthy piece of literary criticism should be based on.
The spectrum of criticism about the author is vast.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Historians and The Critics: Ronald S. Crane´s View on Literature." 11 Dec 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Formalist Critics, by Cleanth Brooks Essay

- Cleanth Brooks writes in his essay “The Formalist Critics” from 1951 about criticism that formalist critics encounter and tries to show these arguments from his point of view and even indicates common ground with other literary critics. Cleanth Brooks argues that we lose the intrinsically obvious points of works of literature if we view the work through the different lenses of literary theory, however we are always viewing the literary work through a subjective lens, since the author and the critic cannot subjectively separate themselves from themselves and in making these points he contradicts himself....   [tags: the formalist critics, cleanth brooks]

Research Papers
1507 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on Ronald Reagan, a True Hero

- Ronald Reagan was a true hero to many Americans. He was a strong president who cared for this country dearly, and Reagan really proved this by his actions during his presidency. He also proved his love for country by serving in the U.S Army during World War II. Ronald Reagan also came through as a hero by fixing the American Economy that was heading for disaster just like today’s. If you can reflect on what he had accomplished throughout his administration you can clearly see why he was a popular two term president....   [tags: Ronald Reagan, heroes, history, ]

Research Papers
771 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on The Legacy Of Ronald Reagan

- Ronald Reagan, like many other presidents, had his successes and his failures while in office. He led the nation with a conservative agenda that a lot of critics disagreed with. Some of his actions can be called a success or a failure depending on who is looking at it. His successes included the tax cuts of 1981, appointing the first woman to the United States Supreme Court, reduced the amount of nuclear arms by signing a deal with the Soviet Union, made progress towards the end of the Cold War, got the Soviet Union to leave Afghanistan, released the Air Traffic Controllers who went on strike, the rescue mission in Grenada, the Anti-Drug Abuse Act of 1986, and the Strategic Defense Strategy...   [tags: Ronald Reagan, Mikhail Gorbachev, Cold War]

Research Papers
1100 words (3.1 pages)

Critical Examination of Brooks' The Formalist Critics Essay

- Brooks starts his essay by listing “articles of faith I could subscribe to” (Brooks 19) and pointing out statements about literary criticism that might go with a formalist criticism. Yet, he questions that list its end, and seems to complain that his that his writings have been largely misunderstood. What his statements have to do with faith in connection with literature is up to the reader, since in one of his articles he specifically mentions, “literature is not a surrogate for religion” (Brooks 19)....   [tags: literature, writer, faith]

Research Papers
1028 words (2.9 pages)

Ronald Reag President Of The Republican Party Essay

- Ronald Reagan Ronald Reagan is formerly known as a Hollywood actor before he entered the political spotlight. Ronald Reagan was also formerly the governor of California. Ronald Reagan was raised in a small town in Illinois by his parent Nelle and John Reagan. Throughout Reagans acting career he was in 53 films. Ronald Reagan was a member of the Republican Party. During ww2 draft Ronald Reagan was exempted due to his very poor eyesight. In Reagan’s younger years, he was a member of the Democratic Party....   [tags: Ronald Reagan, George H. W. Bush]

Research Papers
1689 words (4.8 pages)

Ronald Takaki's Iron Cages: Race and Culture in 19th-Century America Essay examples

- Ronald Takaki's Iron Cages: Race and Culture in 19th-Century America After America declared its independence from British rule, the founding fathers faced a conundrum: How to build and maintain a successful republican government that was ultimately dependent upon the passions and character of its people. Their solution was to propose the construction of what historians have called "iron cages," which were ideological devices intended to deter the corruption and folly that might consume a free people, and instead promoterational and virtuous American citizens....   [tags: Iron Cages Ronald Takaki Essays]

Research Papers
1673 words (4.8 pages)

Sleeping Beauty: Feminist Critics Essay

- The biological differences that set apart the male and female gender throughout any culture remain eminent. Men are perceived as the stronger and dominant gender; women play the role of the weaker. In each culture the expectation of the manner in which men and women behave are influenced by the ideals and customs of that culture. In most predominant cultures, the man undertakes the role as a leader, and the woman devotes her life to the husband. Throughout history, traditions and literature provide a template to the identities of various cultures....   [tags: Literature, Gender Studies]

Research Papers
1097 words (3.1 pages)

Essay about Most historians recognise 1917 as the year in which the Harlem

- Most historians recognise 1917 as the year in which the Harlem renaissance began. The Harlem Renaissance. Today most historians recognise 1917 as the year in which the Harlem renaissance began. Three events lead to this. First was the publication of two poems by Claude McKay. Second was the opening on Broadway of three plays about black life by a white writer, Ridgely Thomas. These plays were remarkable not only because they were performed by black artists but because they contained none of the usual racial stereotypes....   [tags: English Literature:]

Free Essays
499 words (1.4 pages)

Essay about Ronald Reagan: The Great Communicator

- Ronald Reagan is known as the "Great Communicator" by many. In 1992, as he delivered a speech at the Republican Convention, one would not doubt his excellence in public speaking. He demonstrated superiority of speech and was easy to critique because of the situation, the content of his speech, his credibility, and his delivery. The Republican Convention was held in support to reelect Republican Candidates President Bush and Vice President Quayle. There was an extremely large audience in support of the Republican campaign....   [tags: Ronald Reagan Essays]

Research Papers
1000 words (2.9 pages)

Progressive Historians Essay

- Progressive Historians One must decide the meaning of "progressive historiography." It can mean either the history written by "progressive historians," or it can mean history written by historians of the Progressive era of American history and shortly after. The focus that was chosen for this paper is more in keeping with the latter interpretation, if for no other reason than it provides a useful compare-and-contrast "control" literature. The caveat is this: the focus of this report is on the predominant question of the historiographical period: was the war a revolution or a war for independence....   [tags: American America History]

Free Essays
6483 words (18.5 pages)

We have Barthes, who kills him off and only focuses on the historical, Crane who only wants to focus on the critical analysis of the text itself, and Foucault who questions what an author is. Personally, I believe all the experts are wrong. Although I can see their points, and understand what it is they want from literature, I don’t necessarily believe it. When approaching a text, the reader must first and foremost keep an open mind. The reader needs to understand when and where the story takes place in order to keep an open mind. If you read Sarah, Plain and Tall without knowing when the story takes place, the fact that Sarah is a mail-order bride who moves halfway across the country would be very off-putting. At the same time, the reader must also focus on the text and not form an analysis solely based of the fact that the novel takes place in the late 19th century. Also, if one reads the lovely sonnets of the romantic poets, it helps to know for whom the poems are written. Keats writes “Bright Star” for his lovely Fanny Browne. Lord Byron focuses on his beloved Mary Haworth, whose perfection inspired many of his poems. Even Shelley, whose torrid love affairs were legendary, created many famous sonnets. One cannot form a successful critique of any work without knowing the background information from which the works were produced.

Return to