The National Education Association (NEA) does not believe one exam should determine if a student moves onto the next grade or graduates, according to Dunne (2000). Promotion exams, which require students to pass comprehensive end of year tests to move from grade to grade, really test for knowledge retention. This does not mean a student cannot succeed at the next grade level. A comprehensive end of year exam does not illustrate whether a student has the aptitude to perform well, which is why they are a weak indicator of academic advancement. Even though there are schools that provide various opportunities to pass the exams, they are detrimental to have at each grade level. Instead of being opportunistic and eager to garner more knowledge, students will become more focused on end of year exams. Therefore, promotion exams facilitate an unhealthy learning environment, which is non conducive to education.
In 2007, there were only seven schools in the U.S. that gave promotion exams, according to Lloyd (2008). This can create an extreme amount of pressur...
... middle of paper ...
Dunne, D. (2000, July 3). How Important Should One Test Be? Retrieved February 21, 2010 from, Education World Web site: http://www.educationworld.com/a_issues/issues096.shtml
FairTest (2008, January 4). What's Wrong with Graduation and Promotion Tests? Retrieved February 21, 2010 from, The National Center for Fair & Open Testing Web site: http://www.fairtest.org/whats-wrong-graduation-and-promotion-tests
Lloyd, S. (2008, January 2). Few States Require Promotion Exams. Retrieved February 22, 2010 from, Editorial Projects in Education Research Center Web site: http://www.edweek.org/rc/articles/2008/01/03/sow0103.h27.html
Urbina, I. (2010, January 10). As School Exit Tests Prove Tough, States Ease Standards. Retrieved February 21, 2010 from, New York Times Web site: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/12/education/12exit.html?pagewanted=1
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The NCLB Act has obligated the government to find a way to keep track of progress, which, in their minds, is administering high-stakes tests. High-stakes testing is scrutinized all the time, since some believe it is the only indicator of tracking students and teachers. They seemed to have been ridiculed by many and favored by few; nonetheless there are significant disparities in the public’s and government’s opinion. According to Dunne (2000), “Tests aren't just tests anymore -- at least not high-stakes tests, which are being used in some states to determine which students stay back a grade, which high school seniors receive diplomas, which teachers get bonuses, and more.” The National Educ... [tags: public Education, NCLB, achievement tests]
1540 words (4.4 pages)
- The issue of high-stakes testing is a substantial topic in the world of education today. Some find it to be a useful tool in making decisions in education. By using the results from a high stakes test, schools are able to decide where each student should go next. By setting high standards and high expectations, schools are ensuring that their tests have a purpose. (National Research Council, 1999) Others disagree and find high-stakes testing to be a complete waste of time. In Massachusetts, professors are protesting the use of these tests.... [tags: education, schools]
1195 words (3.4 pages)
- Imagine that you are a 3rd grade teacher, standardized testing is around the corner and if your class performs poorly, your salary will be cut in the following year. It 's true that many within the school system believe high stakes testing is appropriate, but it negatively effects the school system from the district to the student. The destructive effects, however minimal, are not to be overlooked, no matter the constructive progress. High Stakes testing began as an exercise in accountability, however, it has morphed into a nest of politics that is negatively upsetting many aspects of learning.... [tags: Education, Standardized test, High-stakes testing]
1105 words (3.2 pages)
- Imagine that you are a teacher with a classroom full of eight-year-olds. High stakes testing (HST) will be administered soon, then used to determine if your salary will be cut in the following year. While true that many believe in the validity and benefit produced by HST. Unfortunately, it negatively affects the school system from the district to the student. The destructive effects, however minimal, are not to be overlooked. HST began as an exercise in accountability. However, it has morphed into a nest of politics that negatively upsets various aspects of learning.... [tags: Education, Standardized test, High-stakes testing]
2142 words (6.1 pages)
- What is High Stakes Testing Doing for your Child. Schools have changed a lot over the past generations. Building relationships with classmates has taken a back seat to the importance of high stakes and standardized testing. Schools have become more political and place the importance of funding before the well-being of students. Students are used to boost statistics and are not being taught everything that the curriculum requires them to learn, but only what is going to tested. School is supposed to be a place where a child is brought up to have the skills to go out into the ‘real world’, but this simply does not happen because they are essentially treated like another student instead of a hu... [tags: High school, Education, Teacher, School]
978 words (2.8 pages)
- “It’s awful. I just cringe every time I walk in the teacher’s room because these tests are the only topic of conservation in there, and it raises your anxiety just to hear how scared everybody is. A few years ago, I really loved teaching, but this is intense… I’m not sure how long I can take it “(Barksdale-Ladd, Thomas 390). Two major classifications of standardized testing are norm-referenced and criterion-referenced testing. These two tests are the most frequently used and well known method of testing in the United States as well as numerous other countries in the world.... [tags: High-Stakes Testing]
2110 words (6 pages)
- The United States of America is ranked 15th in the world for it’s quality of education. Improvement in our education system is necessary if we want to keep up with the best nations in the world. Over the past ten years, a new push has been made to improve education in America through programs like No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top. States across the country are assessing teachers and schools by using standardized test scores. By using standardized test scores, states link high stakes to the results such as grant money, salary, and jobs as incentive to improve the scores for the following year.... [tags: high-stakes testing essays]
2455 words (7 pages)
- As children grow up some of their frightful memories include a visit to the dentist or to the first day in elementary school. Perhaps their greatest nightmare is standardized testing. Since starting school as first graders students are taught to test in the United States. In many cases students are placed in remedial classes or even held back because of their low grades. Many do not realize that the students with low grades are mainly students who are not good test takers, and educators start to believe that these students are low achievers.... [tags: High-Stakes Standardized Testing]
1908 words (5.5 pages)
- I remember being in fourth and fifth grade and being terrified of taking the test not knowing if I would make the score to get promoted to the next grade level or not. High stakes testing is a single assessment that requires all students to pass with a passing score in order to get promoted to the next grade level or be eligible for graduation. I do not agree with high stakes testing, because I do not think that it is a fair way to assess all student’s knowledge and skills. First of all, I disagree with high stakes testing because it is one single assessment administered to every single student.... [tags: Education, Psychometrics, Test]
1229 words (3.5 pages)
- High Stakes Testing In 1997, President Bill Clinton stated that the United States needed, “ a national crusade for education standards - not federal government standards, but national standards, representing what all our students must know to succeed in the knowledge economy of the twenty-first century”(http://books.nap.edu/books/0309062802/html/13.html). The way to succeed in this journey is through standardized testing that results in consequences for teachers and students. Throughout this paper, I will be discussing how important high stakes testing is to our country.... [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Education Essays]
1319 words (3.8 pages)