Essay on Henry V, An Ideal Machiavellian Ruler

Essay on Henry V, An Ideal Machiavellian Ruler

Length: 1041 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

For hundreds of years, those who have read Henry V, or have seen the play performed, have admired Henry V's skills and decisions as a leader. Some assert that Henry V should be glorified and seen as an "ideal Christian king". Rejecting that idea completely, I would like to argue that Henry V should not be seen as the "ideal Christian king", but rather as a classic example of a Machiavellian ruler. If looking at the play superficially, Henry V may seem to be a religious, moral, and merciful ruler; however it was Niccolo Machiavelli himself that stated in his book, The Prince, that a ruler must "appear all mercy, all faith, all honesty, all humanity, [and] all religion" in order to keep control over his subjects (70). In the second act of the play, Henry V very convincingly acts as if he has no clue as to what the conspirators are planning behind his back, only to seconds later reveal he knew about their treacherous plans all along. If he can act as though he knows nothing of the conspirators' plans, what is to say that he acting elsewhere in the play, and only appearing to be a certain way? By delving deeper into the characteristics and behaviors of Henry V, I hope to reveal him to be a true Machiavellian ruler, rather than an "ideal king".
In regards to use the use of mercy and cruelty, Machiavelli states that a ruler should "desire to be held merciful and not cruel", but also "should not care about the infamy of cruelty, because with very few examples he will be more merciful" than those who show too much mercy to their subjects, and not enough cruelty (The Prince, 65). In other words, the ideal Machiavellian ruler must know how to use cruelty and mercy well.
The first aspect of this Machiavellian concept to be examined wil...

... middle of paper ...

... all of these are examples of when Henry V cried out to God, the most powerful example takes place when the war is finally over. In front of all of his remaining soldiers, he attributes the entire victory of the war to God, telling God to "take it.. for it is none but thine" (4.8.113-114).
The character of Henry V, in Shakespeare’s Henry V, displays several characteristics of a Machiavellian ruler. However, the most prominent is his ability to not only use cruelty well, but to appear merciful as well. Henry V is also a great actor, as seen in the second act with the conspirators, and uses his natural acting abilities to appear as though he is a moral and religious ruler. For Machiavelli himself says that although a ruler doesn't have to really be merciful, humane, honest and religious, it is useful for a ruler to appear to be all of these things (The Prince, 70).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Machiavelli 's The Prince, An Ideal Ruler Essay

- Although, Machiavelli argues that an ideal ruler must be cruel, feared and unjust in order to maintain power in his paper, "The Prince", this is not necessary true. An ideal ruler must be assertive, just and filled with integrity to maintain power, prestige, and the loyalty of those he governs. An ideal leader must be assertive in the sense that he is able to stand up for himself without undue anxiety, express his beliefs and honest feelings comfortably in direct and honest ways without denying the rights of others....   [tags: Leadership, Political philosophy]

Strong Essays
766 words (2.2 pages)

Vladimir Putin - A Modern Machiavellian Prince Essay

- In 1513, an Italian politician by the name of Niccolo Machiavelli distributed, though privately, a political treatise called The Prince. This treatise was, essentially, a guide on how to effectively rule one's country. It's important beforehand to define exactly what a Machiavellian is, before describing one. A Machiavellian is a leader who, through his power and influence, works toward the common good of his people. This can be done through fear, through deceit, even through manipulation. It is important to understand the main principle of a Machiavellian; the end justifies the means....   [tags: Machiavellian Leadership]

Strong Essays
2412 words (6.9 pages)

Why The Ruler Should Be An Effective Ruler? Essay

- Throughout the years there have been several different dynasties. These dynasties had their differences and their similarities. Each dynasty had good or bad rulers, however, the longest lasting dynasties had good effective rulers. These effective rulers helped to promote the growth of the government, which lead to increasing the length of their reign. In order to be an effective ruler, one must choose to exemplify these characteristics, being a role model, being active in the government and creating solutions to the issues facing his subjects, and also protecting them....   [tags: Government, Virtue, Good and evil, Ruler]

Strong Essays
1006 words (2.9 pages)

Three Features of an Ideal Ruler Contrasted in The Aenied and Antigone Essays

- An ideal ruler possesses 3 distinct features: courage, honor, and virtue. Courage is often shown when facing difficult leadership decisions. Honor is gained as one honor’s the gods or serves one’s own state. And virtue is gained as one looks out for the best interest of one’s own state. The importance of such virtues is contrasted in Antigone and The Aenied. In Antigone, Creon shows the 3 components of a good leader when he takes rule and objectively enforces the laws to maintain order. But as Antigone progresses and Creon’s hubris becomes more prominent, he loses sight of the three qualities that make a good leader....   [tags: Aenied, Antigone]

Strong Essays
1483 words (4.2 pages)

Prince Escalus from Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet: The Ideal Monarch Essay

- ... Shakespeare starts showing the ideal ruler, the one with the people in mind. Later in Romeo and Juliet, there is a fight between Mercutio and Tybalt and then Tybalt and Romeo. Prince Escalus arrives to break up the fight. In Romeus and Juliet, Mercutio is not in the scene, but Tybalt and Romeo still fight. Afterwards, both sides go to the Prince and ask for judgement. In both writings, the Prince shows mercy and only banishes Romeo. Shakespeare takes this to a different extent with Prince Escalus breaking up the fight, hearing from both sides, and making a reasonable judgement....   [tags: ruler, just, peace]

Strong Essays
520 words (1.5 pages)

Machiavelli’s The Prince: Examples of Machiavellian Leaders Essay

- Arguably, the most Machiavellian leader to ever exist would be Joseph Stalin. He abided by three major Machiavellian methods that were stated in the Prince: the ends justifies the means, crush any opposition, and displaying a false character. Stalin had a plan for Russia and did everything in his power to achieve that plan. He wanted to transform Russia into a industrial superpower, a military superpower, and a political superpower. To achieve his goals he committed many horrible crimes against humanity....   [tags: Machiavelli, The Prince]

Strong Essays
2033 words (5.8 pages)

Essay on Prospero as an Ideal Ruler in in Shakespeare's The Tempest

- Prospero as an Ideal Ruler in The Tempest       Prospero's magical powers allow him to single-handedly take control of a situation of slowly developing chaos, caused by his eviction from Milan, and turn the plot of The Tempest. Prospero has powers over his surroundings, far greater than those of an ordinary mortal, and he uses them for good in the course of the play. This essay will discuss whether Prospero combines his magic with power over the self, and whether Shakespeare actually presents him as an ideal ruler....   [tags: Tempest essays]

Strong Essays
1239 words (3.5 pages)

Henry: An Ideal Monarch? Essay

- Henry: An Ideal Monarch. In the 1590s, there was a very strict ideal of a Monarch. The way an ideal Monarch would be viewed in the 1590s was not far removed from the expectations of a King in the early 15th century. A 15th or 16th century King was expected to be a competent ruler above anything else, but far more was needed to lead the people of Medieval Briton. The role of the king in society progressed and differed throughout the middle ages, with the introduction of bureaucracy towards the end of the period and a gradual detachment from the Roman empire....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
966 words (2.8 pages)

Free Macbeth Essays: Duncan - The Ideal Ruler?

- Duncan - The Ideal ruler in Macbeth. Establishing whether Duncan was or was not an ideal ruler is crucial when examining Macbeth. Not only would a definite negative answer help in our understanding of the background of the play but it would also, in a way, justify Macbeth s decision of killing Duncan. When the play opens Duncan receives a report from the battlefield. The audience finds out that the threat which Scotland faces is of a double nature. A Norwegian invasion is being assisted by two rebellious thanes - Macdonwald and Cawdor....   [tags: GCSE Coursework Macbeth Essays]

Free Essays
693 words (2 pages)

A Feared Ruler? Essay

- Machiavelli was a man who was not worried about what was morally correct, but rather, what was politically deserved. He was in fact an honest and religious man, but he has become known for trickery and double-dealing. He thought that princes would have to start tricking his enemies, or even his people for the good of his state. In my opinion, his theory, “It is better to be feared than loved” is saying that when the people fear their ruler, the ruler will most likely get what he wants. When a ruler has control and intimidation over his people, they will most likely do what he says and follow his rules, out of fear....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
411 words (1.2 pages)