Henry David Thoreau 's Letter From Birmingham Jail Essay

Henry David Thoreau 's Letter From Birmingham Jail Essay

Length: 865 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In Martin Luther King Jr’s “Letter from Birmingham Jail,” he cites conscience as a guide to obeying just laws and disobeying unjust laws. In the same way, Henry David Thoreau wrote in his famous essay, “Civil Disobedience,” that people should do what their conscience tells them and refuse to follow unjust laws. The positions of the two writers are very close; they both use a common theme of conscience, and they use a similar rhetorical appeal to ethos.
Henry David Thoreau in his essay “Civil Disobedience” Thoreau asserts that men should react from their conscience. Thoreau believed it was the duty of a person to defy the law if his conscience says that the law is unjust. He believed this even if the law was made by a democratic action. Thoreau wrote that a law is not just, although the majority votes and favors a law. He wrote, “Can there not be a government in which the majorities do not practically decide right and wrong, but conscience?” (Thoreau 306). In this statement Thoreau believes that someone who is subject to the government (a citizen) can never, be forced to defy his conscience -- or else it would mean that ‘conscience’ has no purpose. Henry David Thoreau arguments are significant because he claims that men should act from their conscience. I agree with his argument because i believe that people can be free and happy if there wasn 't an authority dictating what to do. For example, if a young man who just turned eighteen decides not to sign up for the military draft, then that 's his decision upon his liberties and freedoms and not the government 's.
By acting civil yet disobedient you are able to nonviolently protest things you don 't think are fair and this is the tactic that Martin Luther King Jr. used to fight aga...

... middle of paper ...

... letting the police get away with it. This is an example of injustice to all blacks because police seem to be murdering these innocent people only because of their race. This situation is also similar to the civil rights movement because a lot of people in different states in the United States are in protest to obtain justice for the black men that have been killed by the police. The people in protest are also trying to use King’s tactic of having peaceful protest. Both Thoreau’s and King’s beliefs is about the responsibility of the citizen to act morally in the face of unjust laws. King wants to change the laws because he think think that they are morally wrong and Thoreau wants to change the law because he thinks what 's the point of having individuals with brains who have thoughts of their own if they are not allowed to think for themselves and do what they want.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Civil Disobedience, By Henry David Thoreau And Letter From A Birmingham Jail

- Mahatma Gandhi, a prominent leader in the independence movement of India once said, “Civil disobedience becomes a sacred duty when the state becomes lawless and corrupt.”(brainyquotes.com) Gandhi states that protest and civil disobedience are necessary when the authority becomes unscrupulous. This correlates to “Declaration of Independence,” by Thomas Jefferson; “Civil Disobedience,” by Henry David Thoreau; and “Letter from a Birmingham Jail,” by Martin Luther King Jr., because all three leaders felt that civil disobedience was important to help protest against an unjust ruling....   [tags: United States Declaration of Independence]

Better Essays
1321 words (3.8 pages)

Civil Disobedience, by Henry David Thoreau and Letter From Birmingham Jail, by Martin Luther King Jr.

- The essays, "Civil Disobedience," by Henry David Thoreau, and "Letter from a Birmingham Jail," by Martin Luther King, Jr., incorporate the authors’ opinions of justice. Each author efficiently shows their main point; Thoreau deals with justice as it relates to government, he asks for,”not at one no government, but at once a better government.”(Paragraph 3). King believed,” injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere." (Paragraph 4). Each essay shows a valid argument for justice, but King's philosophy is more effective, because it has more logical points of views....   [tags: Comparative Analysis]

Better Essays
894 words (2.6 pages)

Comparing Civil Disobedience by Henry David Thoreau and Martin Luther King's Letter from Birmingham Jail

- "...A little rebellion now and then is a good thing...It is a medicine necessary for the sound health of government." Thomas JeffersonThoreau, a transcendentalist from the mid 19th century and Martin Luther King Jr., the Civil Rights movement leader of a century later both believed the necessity of medicine for government. Although they showed disagreement of opinion on issues regarding voting, both writers agreed on the necessity to reform the government and the means of accomplishing it....   [tags: Compare Contrast Comparison]

Better Essays
724 words (2.1 pages)

Henry David Thoreau's Civil Disobedience and Martin Luther King's Letter from Birmingham Jail

- Henry David Thoreau's Civil Disobedience and Martin Luther King's Letter from Birmingham Jail Henry David Thoreau and Martin Luther King, in “Civil Disobedience” and “Letter from Birmingham Jail,” respectively, both conjure a definitive argument on the rights of insubordination during specified epochs of societal injustice. Thoreau, in his enduring contemplation of life and its purpose, insightfully analyzes the conflicting relationship between the government and the people it governs. He considerately evokes the notion that the majority of people are restrained by the government and society from making decisions with consideration of their conscience and that people need to overcome the...   [tags: Compare Contrast Essays]

Better Essays
817 words (2.3 pages)

Henry David Thoreau And Martin Luther King Jr. Essays

- ... Each individual has the ability to rid themselves of immorality, yet the vast majority of individuals do nothing and just allow the injustice to continue. Thoreau supports his claim through illustrating how individuals oppose unjust laws, yet ignore their ability to make changes within their own country. “A wise man will not leave the right mercy of chance nor wish it” (Thoreau 4). A man cannot allow injustice to occur and must protest the government in order to achieve much needed justice. Having men who follow their morality rather than an unjust law has more value....   [tags: Henry David Thoreau, Civil disobedience]

Better Essays
1177 words (3.4 pages)

Henry David Thoreau 's Argument On The Duty Of Civil Disobedience Essay

- When it comes to civil rights, there are two pieces of literature commonly discussed. One of these pieces is Henry David Thoreau’s persuasive lecture On the Duty of Civil Disobedience. In this work, Thoreau discusses how one must combat the government with disobedience of unjust laws and positive friction to create change. The second piece is the commonly known article Letter From a Birmingham Jail by Martin Luther King Jr. This letter covers the ways in which peaceful protest and standing up against injustice can lead to positive results....   [tags: Civil disobedience, Henry David Thoreau]

Better Essays
1261 words (3.6 pages)

Comparing Letter from a Birmingham Jail and Civil Disobedience Essay

- Martin Luther King and Henry David Thoreau each write exemplary persuasive essays that depict social injustice and discuss civil disobedience, which is the refusal to comply with the law in order to prove a point. In his “Letter from a Birmingham Jail,” King speaks to a specific audience: the African Americans, and discusses why he feels they should bring an end to segregation. Thoreau on the other hand, in “Civil Disobedience,” speaks to a broader, non-addressed audience as he largely expresses his feelings towards what he feels is an unjust government....   [tags: compare/contrast]

Better Essays
1558 words (4.5 pages)

Comparing Thoreau’s Civil Disobedience and King's Letter From a Birmingham Jail

- Comparing Thoreau’s Civil Disobedience and Martin Luther King's Letter From a Birmingham Jail The two essays, "Civil Disobedience," by Henry David Thoreau, and "Letter From a Birmingham Jail," by Martin Luther King, Jr., effectively illustrate the authors' opinions of justice. Each author has his main point; Thoreau, in dealing with justice as it relates to government, asks for "not at once no government, but at once a better government. King contends that "injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere." Both essays offer a complete argument for justice, but, given the conditions, King's essay remains more effective, in that its persuasive techniques have more practical applicat...   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Better Essays
1049 words (3 pages)

Civil Disobedience, by Henry David Thoreau Essay

- “Civil Disobedience” by Henry David Thoreau was a means of educating people on why they should not settle for a less than perfect government. Thoreau’s work is a reminder that it is our duty to throw off an unsatisfactory government, as stated by Thomas Jefferson in the “Declaration of Independence.” Civil Disobedience touches on the subject of why people choose to do nothing about a government they are unhappy with. People fear the consequences they might suffer if they do interfere with the current government....   [tags: Civil Disobedience Essays]

Better Essays
1167 words (3.3 pages)

Essay Henry Thoreau's Civil Disobedience and Martin Luther King Jr.

- Henry David Thoreau’s Civil Disobedience took the original idea of transcendentalism and put it into action. His civil acts of defiance were revolutionary as he endorsed a form of protest that did not incorporate violence or fear. Thoreau’s initial actions involving the protest of many governmental issues, including slavery, landed him in jail as he refused to pay taxes or to run away. Ironically, more than one hundred years later, the same issue of equal rights was tearing the United States apart....   [tags: Henry Thoreau, Martin Luther King]

Free Essays
1215 words (3.5 pages)