Hemingway’s, A Farewell to Arms: Does The Film Do Justice To The Novel?

846 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Critical Analysis of A FAREWELL TO ARMS’

A Farewell to Arms, published in 1929, is a classic short story written by Ernest Hemingway about the hardships and cruelties of love and war. In 1932, a film adaptation of the novel was developed by Director Frank Borzage and nonetheless the unquestionable originality of his photography as well as for his excellent directorial concepts; Borzage misses on many levels of Hemingway’s brilliant description and significant dialogue between the main character Lieutenant Frederic Henry and his fellow Italian officers. The film is voiced and positioned towards the eyes of Borzage rather than the story of Hemingway and the incidents are frequently noticeable throughout the film. But to be reasonable, the novel is a difficult task, considering that the story is told in the first person. If anyone has not read Hemingway’s, A Farewell to Arms, the film will appeal as a rather interesting tragic romance but in some of the scenes, however, the producers take this for granted and assume that the spectator has read the book before. My argument is that the film misses on many of the important aspects that Hemingway’s print version offers. The film does not do justice to the book. Director Frank Borzage focuses merely on the romance characteristics of the story, ignoring the brutalities of war, skipping over many scenes, trying to enhance the melancholy approach to the book.

The films explanations skip too quickly for my liking, from one chapter to another and the sufferings and understandings of Lieutenant Henry are passed over too brusquely, being advised rather than voiced. Violence within the film is drastically censored, in fact there is no recollections of the violence and brutality of war and in some scenes, Borzage does not even attempt ...

... middle of paper ...

...are executing them on the spot. In the text, Frederic manages to escape by jumping into a river and swimming to safety, this portion of the book is not even mentioned or shown in the film. Overall I have to say that the film is not an actuate representation of Hemingway’s novel.

Director Frank Borzage’s establishes only one aspect of Hemingway’s novel, which is the romance. Having changed the storyline and ending from the novel, Borzage undermines Hemingway’s point of view and ultimately alters the book as a whole. Hemingway’s approach in writing A Farewell to Arms was to show readers the powerful descriptions of life during and immediately following World War I, which Borzage clearly ignores. Both text and film are in opposites from their creators and seeing the clear differences from text and film, it is quite evident that Borzage’s adaptation is false.

Show More
Related

  • Similarities Between Night And A Farewell To Arms

    535 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Don’t talk about the war,” he says after abandoning the front, “it was over…but I did not have the feeling it was really over” (Hemingway 245). For Frederic the war captured his mind in a way that he

    Read More

  • Mrs.Mallards character (The story of an hour)

    2257 Words  | 5 Pages

    One observation that can be made on Hemingway’s narrative technique as shown in his short stories is his clipped, spare style, which aims to produce a sense of objectivity through highly selected details. Hemingway refuses to romanticize his characters. Being “tough” people, such as boxers, bullfighters, gangsters, and soldiers, they are depicted as leading a life more or less without thought. The world is full of s...

    Read More

  • A Time for Men to Fight for Their Country in A Farewell to Arms by Ernest Hemmingway

    820 Words  | 2 Pages

    Assadnassab, Sara. "Hemingway´s Depiction of Women in A Farewell to Arms.”. http://epubl.ltu.se/1402-1773/2005/117/LTU-CUPP-05117-SE.pdf (accessed April 17, 2013).

    Read More

  • Analysis Of A Farewell To Arms By Ernest Hemingway

    2941 Words  | 6 Pages

    Ernest Hemingway was born on July 21, 1899, in Oak Park, Illinois. His mother, Grace Hall, was a trained opera singer and later on, a music teacher. His father, Clarence Hemingway, was a doctor and an avid naturalist ("Ernest Hemingway: An Inventory”). Just after graduating high school, at the age of eighteen, Hemingway enlisted in the army to fight in World War I ("The Big Read"). After being severely wounded in the war, he moved to Paris in 1921, and devoted himself to writing fiction (Baker). It is said that, “No American writer is more associated with writing about war in the early 20th century than Ernest Hemingway” (Putnam). Hemingway’s book A Farewell to Arms was published in 1929, and was based off of the events that happened to him in the war and what happened in his love life. Fredrick Henry, the protagonist, is an American ambulance driver fighting for the allies during World War I. He is introduced to a nurse named Catherine, who he later on falls in love with. Henry was hit by a trench mortar shell and was very badly injured. He is then sent to Milan, where Catherine later on comes to help nurse him to health. The two fall in love and Henry no longer is involved with the war, so they try and have a child, but both Catherine and the child die during labor, and Henry is left alone. Psychoanalytical approach views the psychological motivations of characters, which refer to the dynamics of personality development and behavior based on the unconscious motivations of a person ("Psychoanalytic Theory”). Hemingway’s writing was greatly impacted by his real life tragedies, which consist of witnessing the gruesomeness of war and his discovery and loss of love, this helps exhibi...

    Read More

  • Ernest Hemingway's A Farewell to Arms - Hopeless Suffering

    743 Words  | 2 Pages

    Hopeless Suffering in A Farewell to Arms Near the end of A Farewell to Arms Ernest Hemingway has Fredrick Henry describe the time he placed a log full of ants on a fire. This incident allows us to understand a much larger occurrence, Catherine's pregnancy. Combined, both of these events form commentary on the backdrop for the entire story, World War One. After he finds out his son was stillborn, Lt. Henry remembers the time when he placed a log full of ants on a fire.

    Read More

  • A Farewell To Arms - Imagery Paper

    1603 Words  | 4 Pages

    Ernest Hemingway used an abundant amount of imagery in his War World I novel, A Farewell to Arms. In the five books that the novel is composed of, the mind is a witness to the senses of sight, touch, smell, hearing, and taste. All of the these senses in a way connects to the themes that run through the novel. We get to view Hemingway’s writing style in a greater depth and almost feel, or mentally view World War I and the affects it generates through Lieutenant Henry’s eyes.

    Read More

  • Farewell To Arms

    560 Words  | 2 Pages

    “I loved to take her hair down and she sat on the bed and kept very still, except suddenly she would dip down to kiss me while I was doing it...inside a tent or behind a falls.'; This novel is very graphic when it comes to them having sex or while he is at the whorehouses during his leave time. Many things in this novel are inappropriate for children and adults. In more ways then one, Hemingway didn’t like women very much, one example is in chapter nine where he takes page and a half to describe how a solder dies who is not a main character in the book. But in chapter forty-one, he only uses approximately three lines to tell that Catharine dies, and she is a main character. In this novel there are a few things wrong.

    Read More

  • Comparing A Farewell to Arms and The Sun Also Rises

    522 Words  | 2 Pages

    "After a while I went out and left the hospital and walked back to the hotel in the rain" (332). This last line of the novel gives an understanding of Ernest Hemingway's style and tone. The overall tone of the book is much different than that of The Sun Also Rises. The characters in the book are propelled by outside forces, in this case WWI, where the characters in The Sun Also Rises seemed to have no direction. Frederick's actions are determined by his position until he deserts the army. Floating down the river with barely a hold on a piece of wood his life, he abandons everything except Catherine and lets the river take him to a new life that becomes increasing difficult to understand. Nevertheless, Hemingway's style and tone make A Farewell to Arms one of the great American novels. Critics usually describe Hemingway's style as simple, spare, and journalistic. These are all good words they all apply. Perhaps because of his training as a newspaperman, Hemingway is a master of the declarative, subject-verb-object sentence. His writing has been likened to a boxer's punches--combinations of lefts and rights coming at us without pause. As illustrated on page 145 "She went down the hall. The porter carried the sack. He knew what was in it," one can see that Hemingway's style is to-the-point and easy to understand. The simplicity and the sensory richness flow directly from Hemingway's and his characters' beliefs. The punchy, vivid language has the immediacy of a news bulletin: these are facts, Hemingway is telling us, and they can't be ignored. And just as Frederic Henry comes to distrust abstractions like "patriotism," so does Hemingway distrust them. Instead he seeks the concrete and the tangible. A simple "good" becomes higher praise than another writer's string of decorative adjectives. Hemingway's style changes, too, when it reflects his characters' changing states of mind. Writing from Frederic Henry's point of view, he sometimes uses a modified stream-of-consciousness technique, a method for spilling out on paper the inner thoughts of a character. Usually Henry's thoughts are choppy, staccato, but when he becomes drunk the language does too, as in the passage on page 13, "I had gone to no such place but to the smoke of cafes and nights when the room whirled and you

    Read More

  • A Farewell To Arms Plot Twist Analysis

    487 Words  | 1 Pages

    The plot of a Farewell to Arms, by Ernest Hemingway, is a strong influence on the novel. The plot is interesting, unique, and allows the story to flow. Without it, the story would be very blunt and uninteresting. There are many key points of this plot and Hemingway reveals this throughout the novel. In the beginning, we do not even know the main character’s first name until he is injured. Hemingway explains Frederick Henry’s character over the first half of the book. In this part we get to learn who he is and how he acts slowly, yet thoroughly. Throught the second half, the novel focuses on Henry’s conflicts and his relationship with Catherine.

    Read More

  • A Comparison of Hemingway and Frederic in A Farewell to Arms

    1706 Words  | 4 Pages

    Bloom, Harold. Introduction. Ernest Hemingway's A Farewell to Arms. Ed. Harold Bloom. New York: Chelsea, 1987.

    Read More

  • Progression of Love in Ernest Hemingway's A Farewell to Arms

    1314 Words  | 3 Pages

    Works Cited and Consulted Hemingway, Ernest. A Farewell to Arms. Simon & Schuster, Inc.; New York, NY; 1929. The Cambridge Companion to Ernest Hemingway; edited by Scott Donaldson; Cambridge U. P.; New York, NY; 1996. Mandel, Miriam B.; Reading Hemingway: The Facts in the Fictions; The Scarecrow Press, Inc.; Metuchen, NJ; 1995.

    Read More

  • Biographical References in and Hemingway's Male Characters

    3948 Words  | 8 Pages

    Stewart, Matthew C. "Ernest Hemingway and World War I: Combatting Recent Psychobiographical Reassessments, Restoring the War." Papers on Language & Literature 36.2 (2000): 198-221.

    Read More

  • The Symbolism of Water in A Farewell to Arms by Ernest Hemingway

    599 Words  | 2 Pages

    A Farewell to Arms, by Ernest Hemingway, is a story about love and war. Frederic Henry, a young American, works as an ambulance driver for the Italian army in World War I. He falls tragically in love with a beautiful English nurse, Miss Catherine Barkley. This tragedy is reflected by water. Throughout the novel Ernest Hemingway uses water as metaphors. Rivers are used as symbols of rebirth and escape and rain as tragedy and disaster, which show how water plays an important role in the story.

    Read More

  • Essay On The Sun Also Rises By Ernest Hemingway

    1052 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Sun Also Rises is Hemingway’s first momentous literary work. It is a story about the lives of a number of Americans who were living in Europe after World War I. An American World War I expatriate and journalist, Jake Barnes, tell the novel’s storyline. The themes that are depicted by Hemingway in this novel include purposelessness of the ‘Lost Generation’, masculine insecurity, communication breakdown, binge alcohol consumption, and fake friendships. Nonetheless, as essential as the premise and the context of the novel are, the characters are the heart and soul of the Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises

    Read More

  • Themes of Love and War in A Farewell to Arms

    2035 Words  | 5 Pages

    Theme is a literary element used in literature and has inspired many poets, playwrights, and authors. The themes of love and war are featured in literature, and inspire authors to write wartime romances that highlight these two themes. Ernest Hemingway’s A Farewell to Arms deals with the collective themes in the human experience such as love and the reality of war. A Farewell to Arms is narrated from the perspective of Fredric Henry, an ambulance driver in the Italian army, and pertains to his experiences in the war. The novel also highlights the passionate relationship between Henry and Catherine Barkley, a British nurse in Italy. Henry’s insight into the war and his intense love for Catherine emphasize that love and war are the predominant themes in the novel and these themes contribute to bringing out the implicit and explicit meaning of the novel. Being a part of the Italian army, Henry is closely involved with the war and has developed an aversion to the war. Henry’s association with the war has also made him realise that war is inglorious and the sacrifices made in war are meaningless. Specifically, Henry wants the war to end because he is disillusioned by the war and knows that war is not as glorious as it is made up to be. The state of affairs and the grim reality of the war lead Henry towards an ardent desire for a peaceful life, and as a result Henry repudiates his fellow soldiers at the warfront. Henry’s desertion of the war is also related to his passionate love for Catherine. Henry’s love for Catherine is progressive and ironic. This love develops gradually in “stages”: Henry’s attempt at pretending love for Catherine towards the beginning of the novel, his gradually developing love for her, and finally, Henry’s impas...

    Read More

More about Hemingway’s, A Farewell to Arms: Does The Film Do Justice To The Novel?

Open Document