HEAVEN – CHOOSE ONE OF THE AFTER DEATH SITUATIONS (HEAVEN) AND ANALYSE WHETHER IT WAS PERCEIVED AS A PLACE OR A STATE DURING THE LATER MIDDLE AGES.
The period between 1300 and 1500 has been classified as the later Middle Ages, with Heaven finding a significant place in the minds of society at the time. Arguments and critics have surrounding the issue of Heaven as a state or a place, with the perceptions during the later Middle Ages forming a significant time period in the debate. However, arguably, heaven in the later Middle Ages was more regarding as a place within the perception of individuals, with elements of tangible, locational nature evident in much of the literature surrounding the debate.
It has been highlighted throughout the later
…show more content…
Much literature also demonstrates perception of heaven as an ‘Edenic Garden’ much like the garden in which Adam and Eve were located in the book of Genesis. Heaven was frequently depicted in the terms of a garden during the later Middle Ages, with much imagery at the time illustrating heaven through flowery imagery and fragrant smells. By placing heaven in perceivable terms, it highlighted to the societies of the later Middle Ages the locational elements of heaven, not only giving individuals a perceived idea of heaven but also highlighting it as a realistic goal in the minds of the society. This idea was further emphasised through the writings of the time, with writings including the Ars Moriendi, recalling in the prayer for death the “joys of Paradise” surrounding heaven. Through this prayer, the images of heaven as a paradise a demonstrated, helping highlight heaven as having a locational sense attached to it. However it does illustrate another significant argument surrounding heaven, illustrating the idea that heaven was also a state of mind in which the individuals of the later Middle Ages accepted. J.B. Russell argues this idea of heaven in the sense of an edenic garden contributing more to the ideas of heaven being more of a state of mind, describing heaven as a concept of the Middle Ages society in …show more content…
These included the maps and cathedral images as well as folklore, poems and visions & . These apocalyptic visions highlight a significant element in understanding heaven as a place. These visions usually highlighted a tangible element including that of “a wind, a bird, an angel, or a chariot of fire” in which moves towards heaven . Heaven is further illustrated in the portrayal of Christ who is described as life, grace and heaven .
The relationship between place and state are further merged with Chidester demonstrating the symbolic nature of heaven as both eternal – timelessness – and earthly – time bound – further illustrating the issue of distinguishing between heaven as a state and
...such as extreme spiritual austerities can hold their place in history because they mattered to the people who practiced them, not necessarily because they were an agent for driving change. Bynum rejects morally absolutist reconstructions of the past in favour of a more relativistic reading which delves into the imagination and subconscious of the medieval writers themselves. She meets them, as much as possible, in their own milieu rather than projecting modern constructions (such as ‘anorexia nervosa’) into the past where they serve little use in our understanding of the medieval mind. Despite her close work with the Annalist School, Bynum makes no attempt toward ‘l’Histoire Totale’ or some grand narrative of the past, and in this regard the work is most honest, thought-provoking, and definitive for 21st century scholars studying the medieval mind and its times.
Sargent, Michael G. “Mystical Writings and Dramatic Texts in Late Medieval England.” Religion & Literature , Vol. 37, No. 2 (Summer, 2005), pp. 77-98
Leeming, David Adams. “The Middle Ages.” Element of Literature, Sixth Course. Austin: Holt, Rhinehart & Winston, 1997. 72-88. Print.
... burial places. Not only did it provide these individuals with an eternal essence, it was a demonstration of their wealth and taste. These burial practices are cultural dedications that engage with society. Though are not all the same, they provide the same type message. This message is in regard to the heavy presence of power at a certain time. The society of elites engages in the world, competes with each other and in this generates a sense of control. Creating tombs and spaces for themselves ensures them that their mark on the world lasts forever even when their body doesn’t. It is religious in that it provides space for someone who has died and ascended yet it is symbolic of the spirit where the individual can back to the high ether and be where the gods live.
Lahiri, Jhumpa. “Hell-Heaven.” The Bedford Introduction to Literature. Ed. Michael Meyer. 9th ed. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin’s, 2011. 638-651. Print.
In Dante’s Inferno hell is divided into nine “circles” of hell; the higher the number correlates to the grimmer the sin and the pain you will endure. However, I do not completely agree with Dante’s version of hell, perhaps due to the difference in time periods. In this essay I will be pointing out my concerns with Dante’s description of hell and how I would recreate hell if I were Dante.
This investigation will analyse responses to death in medieval religious culture. Relationships with death arguably varied between social classes, making it difficult to assert a generalised response to death. Death was commonplace amongst peasants and therefore few sources document it. Responses to death can be inferred by sermons, which were influential to the beliefs of lower classes. The nobility on the other hand, provided accounts of deaths and from these sources responses can be asserted. Similarly, it is difficult to assert a general definition of death as in the medieval period the concept of death was multidimensional. Death was both physical and spiritual to medieval religious culture. Additionally, medieval religious culture was diverse. This investigation will approach these problems by utilising specific religious sources, for both lower and upper classes and analysing their content to decipher whether responses to death were characterised by fear.
The Middle Ages spawned a revolutionary arc in religious activity. Having welcomed Christianity, and taking roots from Greek and Roman spirituality, the arts had evolved alongside divine beliefs. Dante Alighieri’s Divine Comedy explored the realms of Christianity, which included Hell (Inferno), Purgatory (Purgatorio), and Heaven (Paradiso), with the fictitious account of Dante himself traveling to each individual place. As such, his masterpiece had become a wonder of the literature world. Alongside it, the artistic visions of Donatello and Brunelleschi had held Greek and Roman beliefs in high regards as a majority of their architecture, sculptures, and other artistic aspects had derived directly from those ancient beliefs. Finally, music had
Heaven is a place on earth. In the hit Netflix original television series Black Mirror, specifically the episode “San Junipero,” individuals are allotted 5 hours a week to enter a virtual reality to live as a younger version of themselves. Individuals can then choose to ‘pass over’ or upload their consciousness into a cloud and become permanent residents of the town, San Junipero. The show centers around two women who become lovers connected by their want of nostalgia. Nostalgia defined by Svetlana Boym is a “longing for a home that no longer exists or has never existed… a sentiment of loss and displacement” (XIII). San Junipero, has allowed two broken people connected by nostalgia to live together forever in a utopia but in reality, San Junipero
Otto, Rudolf. The Idea of the Holy. Trans. John W. Harvey. New York: Oxford UP, 1958. Print.
Russell, J.B. 1986. Lucifer, the Devil in the Middle Ages. New York: Cornell University Press.
Kleiner, Fred, Gardner's Art through the Ages: A Global History, Fourteenth Edition The Middle Ages, Book B (Boston: Wadsworth, 2013), 348.
Babb, Lawrence. The Moral Cosmos of Paradise Lost. [East Lansing]: Michigan State UP, 1970. Print.
- - - . New Heaven and New Earth: Visionary Experience in Literature. New York: Vanguard Press, 1979. Print.
Perry, Marvin, Peden, Joseph, and Von Laue, Theodore, eds. “Medieval Learning: Synthesis of Reason and Christian Faith.” Sources of the Western Tradition. 5th ed. New York: Houghton Mifflin Co., 2003. 239.