The Healthy-Mindedness and the Sick-Soul Distinction

1154 Words3 Pages

The Healthy-Mindedness and the Sick-Soul Distinction
Healthy-mindedness and its relations to religion is a popular topic in the novel “The Varieties of the Religious Experience” by William James. The religion of the healthy-mindedness comes into light in the fourth and fifth lecture where James describes the healthy minded individuals as having a thought process that minimizes or sometimes ignores the evil of existence. James does not seem to agree with the healthy-minded ways but he does dissect them for the reader. James does a great job at showing individuals in their bare religious states. The Healthy-mindedness is only one type of individual James discovers and projects in this way. James indicates that the sick soul individuals are very much too aware of the evil in existence. In James's mind these sick-soul individuals are far better off than the healthy-minded. This may be due to the sick soul being better at coping with devastating life experiences than the healthy-minded. For example a healthy-minded individual who has a diseased relative is either forced to face death and may not be able to handle the loss, or try to keep it out of their mind.
The healthy-minded could be labeled as optimistic, happy, and hopeful. However like mentioned earlier these individuals can ignore evil. James makes this clear in this passage, “When happiness is actually in possession, the thought of evil can no more acquire the feeling of reality than the thought of good can gain reality when melancholy rules. To the man actively happy, from whatever cause, evil simply cannot then and there be believed in. He must ignore it; and to the bystander he may then seem perversely to shut his eyes to it and hush it up.”(p.88) This behavior could b...

... middle of paper ...

...thy-minded individuals, what advantage and disadvantage qualities do they both have from a psychology point of view.
Trying to understand the healthy minded and its implications on the individual in a healthy way is important to understand the thoughts of individuals and how they can either be manipulated or changed. These thoughts can cause a individual a significant amount of harm and frustration throughout their lives. It is in a psychologist best interest to research and understand these thoughts and behaviors and use the most strategic way of changing them. This is a very good way of understanding some of these thoughts processes that individuals go through and change as they grow and adapt to the world. If there are better ways of thinking and if they can be helped it is a psychologist duty to try and implement it into society for us to be better as a whole.

Open Document