Health Care Providers Should Start Antibiotics For Mr. Dawson 's Pneumonia

Health Care Providers Should Start Antibiotics For Mr. Dawson 's Pneumonia

Length: 1108 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview



Situation Assessment Procedure


Step 1: Identify the ethical issues and problems.

Answer these questions:

• What are the different perspectives?
- Mrs. Dawson wants the healthcare team to do everything they possibly can to save her husband and live at home with him. The health care providers are divided; some of the members believe that he will recover and some believe additional treatment is prolonging the inevitable and perhaps causing Mr. Dawson more suffering.
• What is the main issue?
- The main issue is whether the health care providers should start antibiotics for Mr. Dawson’s pneumonia. The team is divided on starting the treatment or don’t start because the treatment would just prolong Mr. Dawson’s suffering.
• What are the hidden, unstated issues?
- For Mrs. Dawson, if her husband were to come home, they would need round the clock assistance from a nurse to take care of her husband and herself. He is no longer able to drive her around to different places; they would need someone to help them around the city. Mrs. Dawson would need emotional support, because although she wants her husband home, he may never be the same after two strokes.
• What are the complexities of the situation?
- Not treating the patient for an illness is perceived as malpractice on the health care providers unless otherwise stated by the patient their power of attorney. Although they may feel the treatment is a waste, they are expected to treat the patient based on what the family wants.
• Is anything being overlooked?
- Does the patient have a living will, power of attorney, or did he verbally say how he wanted his plan of care? It is important to consider the patients needs and also discuss all the options and specific treatment with the ...


... middle of paper ...


...treat this illness, the nurses fail at providing proper care to the patient and making sure that they did everything they could to improve the patients quality of life.
• Understand the shortcomings of the justification.
- That patient may not be able to do anything for himself after discharge. Risk for infection will still be high with all of the tubing’s they have inserted. The nurses still need to evaluate the patient and make sure no other complications arise. In order to decrease suffering during treatment, they should make sure they are checking on the patient, asking him about pain level and his level of comfort.
• Anticipate objections to the justification.
- Treating Mr. Dawson for his pneumonia may be an objection from other health care providers. Also, if the patient was allergic to certain medications, or medication interaction could harm the patient.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The United States Health Care System Essay

- The United States is, debatably, one of the top tier countries on the Earth in regards to military power and research, along with many other notable achievements.  While America appears to be a great country, there is one area that many other nations are actually surpassing America 's glory, and that is in their ability to provide gold standard health care to their citizens.  In regards to the United States health care system, the US is ranked one of the lowest rated, allowing many other nations surpass their health care prowess....   [tags: Health economics, Universal health care, Medicine]

Better Essays
1488 words (4.3 pages)

Recreational Marijuana Should NOT Be Legal Essay

- The first law that regarded marijuana in America required farmers to grow hemp in the year 1619 for clothing, rope, and other materials, but “as early as 1840, doctors recognized the medical applications of marijuana, and the drug was freely sold in pharmacies for over a century.” (Rich and Stingl). In 1937, the use and possession of marijuana was made illegal, but “before 1937 marijuana was freely bought, sold, grown, and used.”(Rich and Stingl). In 1970 the congress decided to classify marijuana as a schedule one drug, which has made the legalization more difficult, “schedule one drugs are considered dangerous, addictive, and have no medical benefits.”(Rich and Stingl)....   [tags: Anti Marijuana Essays]

Better Essays
1696 words (4.8 pages)

Essay about Smoking Should Be Banned : Smoking

- Smoking should be banned Smoking is a nasty habit. Cigarette smoke is toxic and harmful to breathe. People gag and choke just by getting a whiff of cigarette smoke of a passing smoker. Others can have life-threatening reactions. People have the right to clean air and to enjoy life without the stink of smoke. A smoking ban will solve this problem. Second-hand smoke is just as bad as smoking a cigarette. Per the Center for Disease Control (CDC), second-hand smoke contains more than 7,000 chemicals....   [tags: Smoking, Smoking ban, Cigarette, Tobacco smoking]

Better Essays
864 words (2.5 pages)

Smoking Should Not Be Legal Essay

- Cigarettes are so addictive, so why are they still legal today. The effects of smoking on a person and around that person are so extreme and harmful that smoking should not be legal for anyone. It really amazes me why anybody would smoke and harm their body if they knew how bad it can harm their health, and potentially cause death. Not only is smoking just unhealthy, the bigger problem is that smoking can lead to death. Smoking should be made illegal since there are many negative and dangerous consequences such as secondhand, and thirdhand smoke related illnesses, health risks to the smoker, and health risks to people around the smoker....   [tags: Smoking, Nicotine, Lung cancer, Tobacco]

Better Essays
1542 words (4.4 pages)

Community Health Nursing Case Review Essay

- Parkinson’s disease is a disorder that affects the nerve cells, in a part of the brain that controls the movement of muscles. Symptoms of this debilitating disease include trembling of hands, arms, legs, jaw and face, stiffness of arms, legs and trunk, slowness of movement, poor balance and coordination. As symptoms get progressively worse, people may experience depression, sleep problems, swallowing and speaking problems. Till now there is no cure for this disease. Viewpoint of Client- This client lived her entire life very actively....   [tags: Medical Ethics, Parkinson’s Disease]

Better Essays
1660 words (4.7 pages)

Should Smoking Be Banned? Essay

- Smoking is literally paying someone to kill you, tobacco companies become rich, and meanwhile you have a one in five chance of dying because smoking causes twenty percent of all deaths in the United States each year. Smoking causes 3,000 cancer deaths in non-smokers and 400,000 cancer deaths in smokers every year (Patient handout). Smoking is a very dangerous habit, the effects are extremely serious to one’s health. The chemicals that make up cigarettes are extremely hazardous, it is a difficult habit to break, and smoking had led to multiple types of cancer, heart disease, and hundreds of other cases of problems with the body (Kowalski)....   [tags: Smoking, Tobacco, Nicotine, Passive smoking]

Better Essays
1687 words (4.8 pages)

Should Marijuana Be Legalized? Essay example

- Marijuana is an incredibly prominent and controversial issue in society today. Our American society is facing a tremendous drug problem. A public debate is going on to find a solution to the drug dilemma and legalizing marijuana is not the way to go. Marijuana also known as Cannabis should not be legalized because it is a harmful gateway drug, it causes health issues and is a mind altering perception. Marijuana is a gateway drug that potentially introduces users to additional serious illegal substances in which they abuse, which pose an even greater threat to the public....   [tags: Illegal drug trade, Drug addiction, Drug]

Better Essays
714 words (2 pages)

Effects of Smoking on Health Essays

- Effects of Smoking on Health Smoking is the act of inhaling the fumes of burning substances. It used to be men who mainly smoked pipes and cigars which involve little inhalation. Now a days the amount of young women and children smoking is on the increase although the overall amount of people who smoke is declining in most countries. There are thought to be around 4000 different chemical in a cigarette, many are toxic and 43 of them are carcinogens. The main substances in a cigarette are tar, carbon monoxide and nicotine....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Example Essays]

Better Essays
1072 words (3.1 pages)

Streptococcus Pneumoniae Essay

- In accordance with the World Health Organization, pneumonia still remains one of the main killers of children under the age of five, taking more than 1.1 million lives of boys and girls annually (WHO Pneumonia factsheet, 2013). Pneumonia is more prevalent in South Asia and sub-Saharan Africa. It is well known that pneumonia is a disease of respiratory system that affects the alveoli, which are the constituent part of the lungs. Normally alveoli fill with air during the breath of a healthy person, while the one with pneumonia has alveoli, which are filled with fluid and pus; hence the breathing process is painful and limits the oxygen consumption by organism....   [tags: Pneumonia, World Health Organization]

Better Essays
1010 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about Pneumonia

- Pneumonia is a condition that occurs in the lungs that causes inflammation. It is caused by infections at large. However, bacteria, fungi, viruses and other parasites may also be responsible for the condition. Older people who are above 65 years, people having chronic illness and those who have a week immune system are more prone and likely to this kind of inflammation. Pneumonia can range from mild to life threatening illness. In fact this condition is characterized with high inflammation in the lungs which is caused by the abnormal filling of fluid in the alveolar....   [tags: Health]

Better Essays
924 words (2.6 pages)