Harry Potter And The Twilight Essay

Harry Potter And The Twilight Essay

Length: 1205 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Harry Potter and Twilight are both wildly popular book series. Harry Potter written by J.K. Rowling follows a young wizard through his discovery of his wizardry, education in magic, and avenging the death of his parents. Twilight written by Stephanie Meyers is about a teenaged girl who falls in love with a boy from school only to find out he is a vampire. Both books were developed into films. Twilight’s plot revolves around romance, while the Harry Potter series has recurring themes of friendship, bravery, and sacrifice. Harry Potter not only has a deeper, more interesting plot, but also teaches valuable morals and life lessons.
Twilight begins when a young girl named Bella Swan moves to Forks, Washington to live with her father. Awkward and shy, Bella surprisingly befriends other students at lunch. A group of attractive students walk into the cafeteria and catching Bella’s attention, she asks her new friends who they are. She then spots one boy in the group and learns his name is Edward Cullen. The entire rest of the series revolves around their dramatic and unhealthy relationship. The main concern of the movies is that Edward is a vampire and Bella is not, and whether or not she should become one. The massive emphasis on their relationship is both shallow and misguiding to young teens.
Harry Potter is a much more extensive series, opening with a young boy who was orphaned as an infant and lives with his emotionally, verbally, and occasionally physically abusive aunt and uncle. At the age of eleven Harry learns he is a wizard and begins attending Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. He meets two other first-year students, Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger, who soon grow to be his best friends for the next seven plus years...


... middle of paper ...


...e subject to this decision. Countless people surrender to Lord Voldemort in exchange for the safety of their loved ones. Harry’s own parents, for example, are discovered by Lord Voldemort after several months of hiding. He arrives to personally murder them and Harry’s parents do everything possible to keep him alive. Harry’s mother throws herself in front of him just as Lord Voldemort attempts to take his life. Due to this act of selfless love, Lord Voldemort is unable to kill the Harry and is forced to abandon his mission, leaving him an orphan when he is just an infant.
Harry Potter demonstrates true friendship, acts of bravery, and noble sacrifice. It sets an example of admirable behavior to viewers, particularly those who are young. Twilight wrongly presents unhealthy relationships as praiseworthy, which can be detrimental to impressionable adolescent viewers.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Harry Potter And The Twilight Essay

- Harry Potter and Twilight are both wildly popular book series. Harry Potter written by J.K. Rowling follows a young wizard through his discovery of his wizardry, education in magic, and avenging the death of his parents. Twilight written by Stephanie Meyers is about a teenaged girl who falls in love with a boy from school only to find out he is a vampire. Both books were developed into films. Twilight’s plot revolves around romance, while the Harry Potter series has recurring themes of friendship, bravery, and sacrifice....   [tags: Harry Potter]

Better Essays
1205 words (3.4 pages)

Harry Potter vs. Edward Cullen Essay examples

- “There was a time when no one had heard of Harry Potter,” a title of an article published in the 2007 edition of the Chicago tribune. It attempted to describe the Harry Potter phenomenon. However, if written now it would be “There was a time when no one had heard of Harry Potter and Edward Cullen” the Twilight series has sparked a phenomenon equal to the Harry Potter series. The debate over which book is better is huge between the clashing fans, witches and wizards vs. vampires and werewolves, Harry vs....   [tags: Harry Potter, Twilight, ]

Better Essays
971 words (2.8 pages)

The, Star Wars The Twilight Sega And Harry Potter Essay examples

- Fandom is a result of a person or a group of people who are a fan of a particular object, person or thing. A fan can be an enthusiastic follower of sport or entertainment or an enthusiastic admirer of a celebrity. There are different types of situations in which people can call themselves a fan. In a small case you can be a fan of a particular person so you might go and watch them in movies or perform on stage. In other cases its when people decide to dress up like their favourite characters or tend to wait in line for hours to get a five second look at them when they come to town....   [tags: Harry Potter]

Better Essays
1161 words (3.3 pages)

The Impact of Modern Literature's Focus on Mystical and Fantasy Essay

- Reading can be vital because it "determines the focus of your mind" (Covington). Is reading bad for a person. Does this mean modern literature is partly responsible for the corruption of society because it determines the way people think. Reading can transport people to different places, times, and state of minds. But what you read will determine it all. Even though modern literature makes great reads, it is changing the views of society because magazines send the wrong messages and modern literature only focuses on mystical and fantasy ideas....   [tags: twilight, harry potter]

Better Essays
1564 words (4.5 pages)

Harry Potter Essays

- I have chosen two movies. These two movies mark the begging and the end of the era when world went mad about fantasy. They are the screen versions of the books, which tell the story of Harry Potter becoming adult. Books’ influence cannot be omitted, but movies brought the fame to the saga. ‘Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone’ is the first movie of series made in 2001. It opens the magic world. Most people consider it their favourite. ‘Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows part 2’ is the last movie from Harry Potter saga created in 2011....   [tags: Film Analysis, Fantasy]

Better Essays
1019 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on The Harry Potter Series by J.K Rowling

- The minds of children are the most impressionable. Children are not born with any predetermined judgments or ideas about controversial subjects. They do not know what racism, homophobia, or discrimination are, or how to practice them. They are not born knowing what religion they will practice, or even what religion is. This fact about children is among the reasons that children's literature is as important as it is. For as long as humans have been creating them, there have been books that have been considered controversial....   [tags: chilren, discrimination, criticism]

Better Essays
2082 words (5.9 pages)

Twilight: A Waste of Time and Money Essay

- In 2008, Twilight debuted in theaters across the county racking in a whopping $69,637,740 in just the first weekend alone (imdb, 2008). Directed by Catherine Hardwicke, Twilight is a movie based on the first in a series of four best-selling novels by Stephenie Meyer. The movies main focus is on a teenage girl named Bella (Kristen Stewart) who moves from Phoenix, Arizona to the town of Forks, Washington to live with her father Charlie (Billy Burke). On the first day of school, she meets Edward (Robert Pattinson), a mysterious guy who, she find out later in the movie, is a vampire....   [tags: Film Analysis]

Better Essays
1045 words (3 pages)

Twilight Merchandise Essay

- In 2005 a new phenomenon was born. Stephenie Meyer’s The Twilight Saga has given the world something new to obsess about this decade. Critics have even called Meyer the new J.K. Rowling, the author of the renowned Harry Potter series. Fans all around the world are now screaming the names of Edward Cullen, Jacob Black and Isabella ‘Bella’ Swan. It’s the classic Romeo and Juliet tale of forbidden love except with a gothic twist. Told from the perspective of Bella Swan a 17 year-old who just moved to Forks, Washington, The Twilight Saga is about the romance between Bella and her vampire sweetheart, Edward Cullen that is continuously sabotaged by sadistic and revengeful vampires, an old supercil...   [tags: Pop Culture]

Better Essays
2238 words (6.4 pages)

I Am A Fast Learner Essay

- During the beginning of my youth, I spent several nights sleeping in my mom 's bed. At the end of each night instead of hearing the notes of a lullaby, I often heard the soft crackle of a crisp page being turned in a book. Almost every night she would read, to herself of course. She didn 't read to me like a stereotypical mother would. On one hand, this seems harsh, but it was her display of passion that made me want to read. After giving birth to my two older sisters, my mom had built up an impressive personal children 's library....   [tags: Writing, Literature, High school, Harry Potter]

Better Essays
1084 words (3.1 pages)

Essay about Harry Potter : A Comparison Of Harry James Potter

- One of the most famous book and movie series is Harry Potter. They follow the life of a young wizard and his battle with a dark wizard named Lord Voldemort. Harry meets some friends and some foes along his journey one being Draco Malfoy. Draco and Harry quickly become rivals. Though they may be rivals there are many similarities and differences they share. Harry James Potter is the main character. He was born to James and Lilly Potter a half-blood family. Half-bloods are families that have both wizard and muggle family members....   [tags: Harry Potter]

Better Essays
822 words (2.3 pages)