Harry Potter And Twilight Comparison Essay

1205 Words3 Pages

Harry Potter and Twilight are both wildly popular book series. Harry Potter written by J.K. Rowling follows a young wizard through his discovery of his wizardry, education in magic, and avenging the death of his parents. Twilight written by Stephanie Meyers is about a teenaged girl who falls in love with a boy from school only to find out he is a vampire. Both books were developed into films. Twilight’s plot revolves around romance, while the Harry Potter series has recurring themes of friendship, bravery, and sacrifice. Harry Potter not only has a deeper, more interesting plot, but also teaches valuable morals and life lessons. Twilight begins when a young girl named Bella Swan moves to Forks, Washington to live with her father. Awkward and …show more content…

The few times it is actually brought up, Twilight conveys friendship as a relatively useless idea. Bella’s friends are hardly supportive and mostly unaware of her situation. She has no real friends that she can trust aside from Edward and is practically useless in his absence. The friends Bella makes in the first movie make very few appearances in any of the sequels and play little to no role in her life. Harry’s friendship with Ron and Hermione, on the other hand, is one of his main sources of happiness. They keep each other grounded, have each other’s backs, and keep one another accountable. Each time one of the trio finds themselves in a predicament, the other two come to their aid and refuse to abandon each …show more content…

Bella is forced to decide between Edward and her mortality- both decisions could be considered brave. Of course if she stays with Edward she has to leave behind her family and friends, constantly moving to remain undetected by those around her. This seems to be the braver choice, however, leaving Edward would mean leaving the love of her life. Although, it can be argued that this relationship was anything but healthy. “Edward leaves Bella after an attack that nearly claimed her life, and in her depression she falls into yet another paranormal relationship- this time with werewolf Jacob Black” (“The Twilight Saga: New Moon”). This description on IMDb describes the synopsis of the second installment in the Twilight series. After Bella is attacked by another vampire and almost killed, Edward decides to abandon her without a word, leaving her confused and heartbroken. Bella allows this to consume her and unable to function properly, is eventually driven to another man. Harry Potter demonstrates the importance of bravery countless times. In the seventh installment Harry, Ron, and Hermione are hunting down Horcruxes- pieces of Lord Voldemort’s soul- when Ron becomes agitated. He has an outburst and leaves Harry and Hermione. Ron and Hermione, despite not having much time or energy to work on their romance, do have somewhat of a relationship blooming when Ron disappears. Hermione is devastated, but continues to keep

Open Document