The Harmful Myth Of Asian Superiority Essay

The Harmful Myth Of Asian Superiority Essay

Length: 1597 words (4.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

We’ve all heard it said that Asian Americans are good at math; anything involving science, technology, and medicine. They study all the time, work really hard, and live a version of the American dream many of us never thought to dream of. And of course, we know these stereotypes are dangerous and often untrue, but perhaps we still find ourselves buying into them. Ronald Takaki”, the ethnic studies expert, writes about the idea that Asian Americans are more successful than any other American minority group in his article “The Harmful Myth of Asian Superiority. Takaki refutes this idea by strategically, and somewhat effectively, using reason, statistics, and word choice to show that Asian Americans still face some of the same hardships and barriers as every other racially defined group in America.
Takaki misses a chance to develop minor pathos in paragraph eleven. In this two sentence paragraph, Takaki describes successful Asian American college graduates as hitting the glass ceiling, or “the barrier through which high management positions can be seen but not reached” (p. 118). By using the phrase “glass ceiling” Takaki gives his audience a visual that is easier to sympathize with than a simple explanation of the popular phrase. But the vast opportunity the phrase offered went undeveloped by Takaki, who could have described the Asian American college graduates as reaching for positions that were far out of their reach despite their ample preparation, but he did not. Instead, Takaki chose to leave his reader with the raw statement given with words that could hint at pathos, but ultimately blend in with their surroundings and are taken in without a second thought. As a reader, I have to ask myself why Takaki did not use pathos. Did ...


... middle of paper ...


...n Americans” ( paragraph 15, p.118). Explaining the tension between these two minority groups and why it exists would have strengthened Takaki’s argument, given it some pathos, and added to his credibility. Otherwise, the article would be better if Takaki had not mentioned “African American resentment toward Asian Americans” (p.117) at all because it makes the paper seem unfocused.
Takaki gets his point across in his article, but he could have conveyed the information more clearly and with greater focus. Takaki clearly knows the material, yet many of his points are left underdeveloped and unclear. Ronald Takaki reminds his readers that though some Asian Americans may be good at math, or science; study often; and work really hard; they are just people like everyone else. Whatever advances Asian American may have made, they still haven’t achieved the dream of equality.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Harmful Myth Of Asian Superiority Essay

- Asian Americans are commonly seen by many as superior to other minorities, but this is not the case. They are surprisingly at a small disadvantage compared to other races. Ronald Takaki argued in his article “The Harmful Myth of Asian Superiority” that Asians are not a model race that should be celebrated and compared to other minorities. He mentioned when other minorities are compared to Asian Americans, it can cause other races, such as African Americans, to feel resentment towards them. Ronald Takaki states that Asian Americans are just like everyone else, but many people only see them as being aloof, hardworking, successful entrepreneurs....   [tags: Asian American, United States, White American]

Better Essays
741 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about Asian American Ethnic Groups Of Asian Americans

- In at least one point in everyone’s lives, they are faced with micro aggressions or discriminating adjectives about their race, gender, or sexual orientation. Most of the time, it is said without the intent of insulting the individual, but most times, it’s much more harmful than they think. Asian Americans, for example, have been “complimented” in stereotypical characteristics. They are told that they are good at math or science because they are Asian, that they are wealthy because their parents are doctors or lawyers, and that they are pretty much the second Whites of society....   [tags: Asian American, United States, Ethnic group]

Better Essays
1574 words (4.5 pages)

Asian Americans And Values Around Academic Achievement Essay

- The topic being investigated in this paper relates to Asian Americans and values around their academic achievement. This cultural group is made up of individuals from any Asian country that have migrated to the United States. For purposes of this paper, differences between first-generation and second-generation are not considered, although there may exist differences between these two groups. Academic achievement is an important issue in regards to this population due to a strong cultural emphasis on education (Kim & Chun, 1994)....   [tags: Asian American, United States, White American]

Better Essays
1400 words (4 pages)

Essay on Couseling Asian Immigrants

- Counseling Asian Immigrants Demographic review According to U.S. Census Bureau, the term Asian refers to those having origins of the native people of the Far East, Southeast Asia, and Indian subcontinent (U.S. Census Bureau, 2004b). Pacific Islander is another common term which refers to those having origins of Hawaii, Samoa, Guam, or other Pacific Islands. In the U.S, Asian American a more acceptable term, which is represented by more than 43 different ethnic groups of people originated from different geographic areas....   [tags: discrimination, racism, myth, services]

Better Essays
1176 words (3.4 pages)

Asian American And Asian Americans Essay

- Since the first influx of Asian immigrants to the United States, Asian Americans were never treated as an integral part of the American population. Accounting for five percent of the US demographic, often times, they are still portrayed by provincial people as outsiders who do not belong in society. Over the years, this negative mentality has transformed into the way Asian Americans are viewed in media. Though there are many attempts of reversing the trend such as diversifying the cast members, stereotypical personalities such as “the human calculator” or “undesirable partner” are still utilized for writers to infuse racial slurs into comedy skits....   [tags: Asian American, White American, Stereotype]

Better Essays
1316 words (3.8 pages)

Asian Immigration And Asian Immigrants Essay

- Asian immigrants have faced many obstacles transitioning to life in America. One major obstacle Asian immigrants came face to face with was receiving an education. Asians are known to place high value on learning and education, but many things stood in their way and hindered them from even receiving an education. Between Asian immigrants and Americans lie a language barrier, which is often seen as a set back. An example of this is Lac Su since he had to serve as a translator for his parents, which in turn affected his school work....   [tags: Asian American, United States, Philippines]

Better Essays
937 words (2.7 pages)

Essay about Asian Americans : An Asian American

- As an Asian American, I have several points to discuss in terms of stereotypes. Through a variety of media, Asian Americans are portrayed by socially constructed stereotypes that are either positive or negative to our community. By explaining the definition of a stereotype and listing three specific ones identified, these points reflect our cultural values. These stereotypes include the concept of model minority, the insinuation that Asians are highly skilled at mathematics, and assumptions of our food ways....   [tags: Asian American, United States, White American]

Better Essays
1453 words (4.2 pages)

The Asian As Superior Myth Essays

- The author, Ronald Takaki, wishes to illustrate that the perceptions of Asian Americans as a "model minority" are not entirely accurate. Takaki writes that the facts and figures used to compare Asian-Americans to other, less successful minority groups are misleading. For example, the author writes that although Japanese Americans are seen as upwardly mobile, they have not yet achieved equality. The essay states that "while Japanese American men in California earned an average income comparable to Caucasian men in 1980, they did so only by acquiring more education and working more hours." In addition, the author found that while some Asian American groups do have higher...   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
619 words (1.8 pages)

Asian Business Essay examples

- 1. “To get rich and glorious” quote was said by Deng Xiao Ping, member of the communist party in China. They got richer, faster than any people ever had. The economy is now 10 times larger than it was then; it grew 300% just in the last 10 years. Incomes rose every year. People in China are becoming millionaires there than anywhere else on earth (Time Asia.) 2. Techno-nationalism is expressive and strict categories for understanding the impact of technology on society and vice versa. They reflect the fundamental assumptions made by analysts of the place of technology in the world, and denote ideologies, rather than technological policies or realities....   [tags: Asian Business]

Better Essays
1838 words (5.3 pages)

Asian Carp Essay examples

- The control and management of Asian carp in North America is an issue that numerous state and federal agencies have been trying work out ever since the first case of Asian carp being in the waterways of North America. Asian carp are a very difficult species of fish to manage and control because of their fast reproduction rate and that there are no predators in the North American waterways to reduce numbers. These fish are damaging native fish's food sources and habitat. More recently, Asian carp are threatening to invade the Great Lakes which would cause drastic economic and ecological problems....   [tags: social issues, asian carp]

Better Essays
1583 words (4.5 pages)