Growing Up as Described in The Choosing and In Mrs Tilscher’s Class

1159 Words3 Pages

‘The Choosing’ and ‘In Mrs Tilscher’s Class’ are both poems that revolve around the theme of growing up. Both Carol Ann Duffy and Liz Lochhead present growing up in a thoughtful manner, the speakers in these two poems seem to be neither upset nor ecstatic about growing up. The speakers were in the same position in that they appeared to not have any power over their own lives; the speaker in ‘The Choosing’ did not make the decision to be an academic, Mary didn’t have the choice to be a scholar, unlike her ‘best friend’, because when Mary grew up, she became a traditional woman, who was entirely dependant on her man. The speaker in Duffy’s poem ‘In Mrs Tilscher’s Class’ did not have a choice in whether she wanted to grow up or not therefore it was inevitable that she would grow up, as everything in nature either grows and develops or dies.

The girls in ‘The Choosing’ both begin in a very ordinary situation however, these friends unconsciously made their own decisions during school and oblivious to these choices made for them by their families, and they drifted apart and journeyed in opposite directions. Both of girls were as clever as each other, only Mary excelled in maths more than the main speaker, their paths cross ten years later, except their lives were completely different, and the question of “which is the better life?” is raised. When this poem was written, children would have accepted their parents making their decisions for them, although today, it would seem unfair and mean to have your parents dictating what you should and should not do.

‘In Mrs Tilscher’s Class’ is about a journey through primary school, the speaker of the poem sees school as a safe and secure environment for adventures and discovery. This poem has...

... middle of paper ...

... tell this because Mary’s father “contrasted strangely with the elegant greyhounds by his side”, greyhounds may look elegant, nevertheless, watching greyhound races were a pastime for people in the working classes in the era in which this poem was written. The theme of social class is weaved into the poem because even at the end, the speaker is wealthier than Mary since the speaker is winning prizes and is most likely a student at a university, which one has to pay for; however, Mary is reliant on her husband and is not earning money herself, “her arms around the full-shaped vase that is her body” meaning that she is pregnant, and the contrasting image of the speaker with her “arms full of books”, the repetition of “full of” foregrounds the importance of the contrasting lives in which both the girls lead, even though they were as equal and as ordinary as each other.

Open Document