Homer wants the overall portrayal of the Sirens to be intriguing and desirable because he wishes all to consider Odysseus as valiant. Homer describes the effect the Sirens have when Odysseus’ “'heart inside [him throbs] to listen longer,'” proving the Sirens to be seductive (20). The effect of his heart throbbing verifies that Odysseus longs to be with the Sirens, forcing an image of a man struggling against his will in order to be near a beautiful temptress. This suggests that the Sirens are irresistible and cunning because they know that they will be able to trick the men into falling for the Sirens. Odysseus longs to listen to the lovely music more to satisfy his desire to be with the Sirens. In order to both hear the song and stay alive, Odysseus’ men physically “bind [him] faster with rope on chafing rope” (24). The effect that the Sirens have on him is great, and the fact that the rope is irritating his skin shows the effort Odysseus is making to be with the Sirens. Nonetheless, throughout the scene Odysseus attempts to join the Sirens, without realizing the terrible consequences. Since the temptresses are so “ravishing,” it i...
... middle of paper ...
...n and cannot control how egotistical they are.
Homer believes the Sirens to be beautiful while Atwood portrays them as ugly through imagery, diction, and point of view in order to settle the argument of whether the men are smart or not and if the Sirens are irresistible or just repulsive. The significance of comparing these two pieces is that the reader can see the authors’ two very different interpretations of men and women’s role in their fate. The depiction of women has changed tremendously over time. In the past, woman were blamed for the downfall of men and being temptresses, but now hold high positions of power and are able to vote. Comparing these two pieces gives insight into how to resolve the never ending “Battle of the Sexes.” The answer is to compromise. Homer and Atwood’s portrayal of the Sirens prove that to each their own, interpretation that is.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Greek mythology is the myths and legends the ancient Greeks centred their lives around. The ancient Greeks used it to explain the events and components of the world around them. Their religion included gods and heroes, creation stories, and the origins of their civilisations and rituals. It is topic that had been studied and examined in great depth for thousands of years. This fascinating religion's messages and influences are reflected in today’s modern society, and many similarities can be found between Greek mythology and modern religions, such as Christianity.... [tags: Greek Mythology]
1022 words (2.9 pages)
- In Greek Mythology, perhaps one of the most rudimental yet one of the most important elements are the Greek Gods and Goddesses. The ancient Greeks created the stories about the lives and journeys of the Greek Gods, known as myths, simply as an endeavor to elucidate nature and all phenomena which were difficult to explain using modern science and logic. These myths about the Gods were spread around the world by explorers and storytellers, and later merged with Greek religion. To this day, numerous myths survived through many writings and through much art.... [tags: Greek Mythology]
1334 words (3.8 pages)
- Gods and goddesses in mythology are used in allusions and often referred to in our daily lives, but do we truly understand them. We may not understand how or why they look the way they do, how they behave, what they are capable of accomplishing, or how they interacted with humans. These super-beings of extremely high status were the heart and soul of prayers and explanations of natural phenomena. They had a variety of natures and were represented in a variety of ways, by different religions. To start, physical features and behaviours are crucial to the representations of gods and goddesses.... [tags: Greek Mythology]
739 words (2.1 pages)
- It is inferred that the parents should take care of their children and have their best interest at heart. This however, is not the case in Greek and Roman mythology. The killing of ones own children, or filicide, was not viewed as negative upon in their era. The contemporary times contrast with the ancient Greek and Roman’s because it was justified to use any means necessary to obtain a higher status. The Greeks and Romans valued keeping a high social reputation and having respect for those of great power.... [tags: Greek Mythology]
1616 words (4.6 pages)
- The dichotomy of social and individualistic tendencies is a source of conflict within all humans and throughout history. Psychologically healthy people have desires to be in the company of other people, while in other instances, they want to isolate themselves from the world and look inward. These two inclinations are kept in balance by leading a normal lifestyle without any extreme emotionally stimulation. However, when trauma is suffered in the psyche, this balance can be upset and people may find themselves looking only inward and shutting out the rest of the world completely.... [tags: Greek Mythology]
1600 words (4.6 pages)
- Women have given birth to new generations for centuries and have the common stereotype of being caring and gentle. But in the creation myth, women were given to man as a punishment. In the book of collected Greek tales, " Mythology Timeless Tales of Gods and Heroes", by Edith Hamilton, women take up important roles that shape each story. Although women are usually characterized as being helpful and motherly, Greek mythology, on the other hand, portrays them to cause distress, fear, and anxiety to numerous men.... [tags: mythology, greek myth, Trojan War]
600 words (1.7 pages)
- Joseph Drake asserted, “And they who for their country die shall fill an honored grave, for glory lights the soldier's tomb, and beauty weeps the brave” (Quote Garden). Is it respectable and honorable to allow a man who fought for the sovereignty of his father’s country to disintegrate on open land and feed the vultures. Leaving a man to rot, especially when he holds power above most, is both immoral and spiteful. Two royal brothers battle and die for the throne of Thebes and leave behind a city to be led by a wicked and conceited Creon.... [tags: Greek Mythology]
1494 words (4.3 pages)
- The lessons conveyed from Greek and Roman mythology are often cast aside as mere folklore and folly. However, numerous points displayed by the epic poets through the actions of their stories’ heroes are beneficial to the audience and can change one’s outlook on life. Heroes from Greek and Roman mythology that contain many similarities and differences between them include two brave souls. These men were Bellerophon, an audacious young adult who dared to bridle the winged horse Pegasus, and Aeneas, a Trojan War champion who bravely defended his city and later set the foundations for Rome after a treacherous journey through the Mediterranean.... [tags: Greek Mythology, Roman Mythology, Mythology, histo]
1045 words (3 pages)
- Long ago, people lacked knowledge on why certain things happened. Without scientific answers, like we have today, the Ancient Greeks created their own answers about the world and an individual’s place in it. These tales were known as myths. They described the feelings and values that bound the members of society. There are two types of myths -- creation myths and explanatory myths. A creation myth explained the start of many events such as the origin of the world and the creation of human beings.... [tags: Greek Mythology, Informative]
323 words (0.9 pages)
- Since the beginning of time the people of the world have their share of beliefs. Greek mythology is the arguably the most popular region of study. In Ancient Greece every citizen had a patron that would protect them and pantheism was commonplace. The Romans admired the Greeks in their art and culture and even took different aspects of their gods. Polytheism was widely accepted in all cultures so the seed of mythology bloomed. The time line of the creations of gods to the end of their reign is an important factor in Greek Mythology.... [tags: Mythology ]
1004 words (2.9 pages)