Greatest Soccer Players of All-Time? Hardly.

919 Words2 Pages

As part of its centennial celebrations, the U.S. Soccer Federation conducted a poll to determine the best players who ever suited up for the red, white and blue. The result was a star-studded collection that is worthy of honor, but falls short of the stated goal. Brad Friedel was the top vote getter at the goalkeeping position, with a backline of Steve Cherundolo, Eddie Pope, Marcelo Balboa and Carlos Bocanegra. The midfield consists of Claudio Reyna, Tab Ramos, Landon Donovan and Clint Dempsey, while Brian McBride and Eric Wynalda were the voters' choices at the forward position. These are all great players who achieved much during their time on the national team. However, the list only covers the final quarter of the federation's century of existence. What of the first 75 years? Rather than celebrating the federation's centenary, it seems to show how shallow the roots really are. If Italy was selecting an All-Time Azzurri, would Facchetti or Maldini be so easily dismissed? Would Beckenbauer still be an automatic for Germany? Even though they played before the days of color television, would Di Stefano and Puskas get more respect from Real Madrid? Switching sports, in these days of LeBron and Kobe, is there still room for Magic, Bird or Wilt? How valid would an All-Time baseball team get if they ignored Ruth and Aaron? The results make it appear that the people in charge of soccer in this country, and especially those who have been given the responsibility to report on it have no depth of knowledge of the history of soccer in this country. That is understandable when the sport's Hall of Fame has been shuttered and shunted into an obscure warehouse in North Carolina. The federation is the guardian of its past, and it seems to h... ... middle of paper ... ...While it was hard to get the spotlight away from the likes of Beckenbauer, Chinaglia and Bogicevic - it was even harder to lead the U.S. to World Cup glory when there were only 24 tickets to the dance, rather than today's 32. Remember, CONCACAF was limited to only one berth until Spain 82, and just two until France 98. Would any of these modern U.S. stars seem as bright without seven straight World Cup appearances to hang their hats on? This is not to say that yesterday's forgotten heroes are necessarily better than today's stars. However, their performance in their respective eras deserves more respect for an honor that supposedly encompasses the entire history of the federation. If U.S. Soccer's goal with this poll was to honor its history, perhaps it should acknowledge and promote the fact that it has one, a deep one of which American soccer fans should be proud.

Open Document