Essay on Goldstein And Pinker 's Theories On A Worldwide Decline Of Violence

Essay on Goldstein And Pinker 's Theories On A Worldwide Decline Of Violence

Length: 1041 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Goldstein and Pinker both use similar evidence and reasoning to explain their theories on a worldwide decline of violence. Goldstein even quotes Pinker in parts of his article. Their evidence does not just rest in modern history, but travels as far back as five thousand years ago. Both point to specific eras in history that in which certain types of violence was reduced. Goldstein tends to use the more recent examples, with his oldest just reaching 19th century Europe. Pinker basically covers from the beginning of written human history to current times.
Pinker espouses that there are six distinct periods of human history that can be used to prove that we, as humans, are becoming less violent. The first he calls the Pacification Process. He states that it started around 3000 B.C. and lasted for around a thousand years. With the movement of people to an agricultural way of life, rather than the previous hunter-gather style, came the creation of cities and governments. The violence that decreased in this period was that of raiding for land and resources by as much as five-fold.
Pinker’s next era or trend in the historical decrease of violence starts around the end of the Middle Ages and extends into the 20th century. Called the Civilizing Process, it lasted for five hundred years, this was when fiefdoms and other fragmented groups and territories started to condense into kingdoms. These kingdoms had a single central authority and allowed a larger level of trading and commerce. Pinker suggests that under this change from small, relatively self-contained feudal territories to large centralized Kingdoms that saw a drop in homicides between 900% to almost 5,000% percent.
The next era is the first commented on by both Pinker and Goldst...

... middle of paper ...

...y using self-control, empathy, a moral sense, and reason. There are also outside forces that help to contain aggression. Commerce, which is often associated with democracy, allows people to win without truly creating losers, as culture begin to respect women there become less of a violence based society, a central “monopoly [of] the legitimate use of force”, as people become more educated and have the ability to see the world on a larger scale, and to knowledge that violence is a problem to be solved and not just a means to an end.
Both Pinker and Goldstein agree that violence has been decreasing world-wide, although Pinker is looking at a much longer period of time. Both cite similar time frames when discussing this topic. While they do have differences of opinion they are in agreement that the world is slowly becoming less violent and my yet lead to a true peace.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Decline And Fall Of The Roman Empire Essay

- ... It seems the author assumes the audience reading it has an understanding of the time frame and history of Rome, and also that they already know some things about what is going on in Rome and around Rome at this time. The issue this article seems to be addressing is the theories blaming primarily a single reason as why Rome fell when there are many reasons why. The article appears to place the blame primarily on the economic and military problems of Rome, caused by the Emperors of Rome, and an increasingly stronger threat from the Celtic and Germanic tribes, and the Sassanid Persian Empire....   [tags: Roman Empire, Decline of the Roman Empire]

Better Essays
712 words (2 pages)

The Decline of Unions Essay

- Trade unions around the world are falling on hard times in the organized workplace. The phrase ‘union live and die at the workplace’ is becoming a reality sooner than later. The likely obituary of trade unions world-wide are declining membership, density collapse, weaken bargaining power, and the lost of prominence and place in polity. Analyses of trade unionism in the literature for some 20 years now have commonly referring to a crisis of trade unionism. Most authors puts it ‘unions under siege’, ‘stagnant and declining’, and ‘experiencing near death’....   [tags: Labor Union Decline]

Better Essays
2808 words (8 pages)

Essay on Surface Reading and the Decline in Understanding

- There are various types of methods that a person can implement when reading any work of literature. The methods range from scanning and skimming, which only examine the surface of the work, leaving out details, to analytical close reading that unearth the meaning of the miniscule details that are usually missed. With our society becoming more and more fast paced, it is being driven to rely solely on scanning and skimming (surface reading). This movement is furthermore compounded by the advances in technology—television, Kendal, internet, etc.—,which are able to supply the audience with almost an exact replica of the information that books provide in half the amount of time or less....   [tags: Decline of the Literate Culture]

Better Essays
758 words (2.2 pages)

A Specie's Vulnerability to Population Decline Essay

- Policy- and decision-makers claim information about the causes of population declines which driving species on the brink of extinction (). However, it is pointed out that the causes of vulnerability remain unclear to explain the variation to the risk of extinction (). According to Reynolds (2003), vulnerability is determinate by both the decline of species population and the reduction of their geographical range. These two forms of vulnerability are affected by both species’ mortality and habitat loss, which are the causes of intrinsic biological traits, extrinsic human induced effects and stochastic factors that likely determine the population trends ()....   [tags: animals, Population Decline, ]

Better Essays
558 words (1.6 pages)

Essay about Reasons Of The Decline Of Roman Empire

- Reasons of Roman Decline Roman Empire was one of the greatest and the largest ruling party. Roman Empire lasted for more than 500 years. After nearly half millennium of rule, the roman finally lost their grip on Europe in the 5th century (The History of the Decline and fall of the Roman Empire, Gibbon). There were a lot of factors and cause which led to the fall of Roman Empire. Not all the factors were that important or more accurately leading to roman fall, not all the Factor had an equal impact on roman fall....   [tags: Roman Empire, Decline of the Roman Empire]

Better Essays
1094 words (3.1 pages)

Analysis Of The Article ' Moral Instinct ' By Steven Pinker Essay

- Does everyone know what to do at a certain point, are all of our decisions benefiting us in the future, can our actions harm others. All of these thoughts are going on in our heads on a daily basis. Now that you are thinking about it ask yourself how many decision you make a day, and how many do actually consider the outcomes of later on. In the article, “Moral Instinct” written by Steven Pinker, touches upon the point of how these decisions are made based on certain factors in society or by self-judgment....   [tags: Burma, George Orwell, Shooting an Elephant]

Better Essays
1933 words (5.5 pages)

Analysis Of Steven Pinker 's ' The Mind As A Computing System Essay

- Speculations on the origin of the mind have ranged from ghosts to society. Each new theory brings about more speculation and disagreement than the last. Where the mind resides, where it came from and if the brain has any involvement with the concept are common questions that fuel theory paradigms. Those questions are also the foundation of the debate about the roll of experience versus the existence of innate capacities. Steven Pinker theorizes the mind as a computing system created by the brain to fill the gap between innate capacities and capacities missing using common sense and learned critical thinking skills....   [tags: Psychology, Critical thinking, Thought, Mind]

Better Essays
813 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on Reasons to Why Print Media is on The Decline

- Introduction The topic of interest in this literature review is on whether print media or digital media is better than their counterpart. Print media is a medium used to disseminate information or news on printed matter (“print media”). For example: newspapers, magazines, books. Digital media is digitised content that can be transmitted over the television or through computer networks like the Internet which constitutes text, graphics, audio and videos (“digital media”). Why is this topic of interest important....   [tags: digital media, print industry, decline]

Better Essays
1464 words (4.2 pages)

The Function Of Goldstein 's Book Essay

- Annotated Bibliography Gottlieb, Erika. "The Function Of Goldstein 's Book: Time As Theme And Structure In Dystopian Satire." Utopian Studies 2.3 (1991): 12-19. Literary Reference Center. Web. 19 Mar. 2016. In "The Function of Goldstein 's Book: Time as Theme and Structure in Dystopian Satire," Erika Gottlieb asserts that Goldstein 's book establishes Nineteen Eighty-Four by George Orwell as a dystopian satire. She juxtaposes Goldstein 's book with the propaganda version given to the children, the Children 's History Book....   [tags: Nineteen Eighty-Four, George Orwell, Telescreen]

Better Essays
1308 words (3.7 pages)

The Teacher Wars By Helen Goldstein Essay

- In “The Teacher Wars”, by Helen Goldstein, the book focuses on the historical implications of school policy and how it affects teachers. The author goes into depth with everything from the rise of female teachers to the rise of technology in today’s teachers. As Goldstein argues teachers have an incredible ability to be able to widen equality, yet can also narrow the achievement gap that is created from birth. Her showcase of the constant strife against teachers throughout the ages gives way to multiple ways politics and decisions affect the achievement gap....   [tags: Education, School, Teacher, Peer-to-peer]

Better Essays
1128 words (3.2 pages)