Essay Going through the Past

Essay Going through the Past

Length: 1706 words (4.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

History taking induces connections to the patient’s past problems to his or her reasoning for visiting the doctor today. During history taking, two different things are occurring: the doctor attempts to shape and validate the patient’s visit while the patient discusses his or her medical problem. As seen in the “Sore Shoulder” clip, history taking highlights the patient telling her doctor of her past medical issues with bursitis. Simultaneously, the doctor, in the clip, tries counteracting the patient’s prediction of having bursitis with an acute problem. I am going to discuss the pro and cons for history taking through the perspective from the doctor but I am arguing that history taking creates more problems rather than solves them. Further, I also am going to argue that history taking blurs communications between both the patient and doctor showing the patient also has his or her own agenda.
The role of the doctor, during history taking, is significant because he or she authenticates the patient’s visit. During any visit to the doctor, patients present a “doctorable” problem which is the impression the doctor will be able to treat and fix any medical issues (Halkowski 113). According to Elizabeth Boyd and John Heritage, history takings are used for the physician’s benefit because it aids establishment of an agenda for the patient’s response (Boyd and Heritage 154). History taking also gives a sense of meaning for the patient’s feelings of “fear and physical discomfort” for his or her health (Roter and Hall 5). In the “Sore Shoulder” clip, the doctor acknowledges the patient’s history during her problem presentation:
“Pat: … Thuh reason I’m here is because >a couple years ago< I had frozen shoulder in thee other arm
Doc: A[...


... middle of paper ...


... doctors.
The history taking process should that there is a struggle between the doctor-patient relationship. Throughout the history taking process in “Sore Shoulder”, doctor and patient alike ignore one another’s arguments and disagreements highlighting there is a lack of communication between the doctor and patient because they are both vouching for two completely opposite problems: chronic and acute. The idea that patients and doctors work together to find a diagnosis is ideal in which reality shows that it favors the doctors’ stance of the situation. To overcome such imbalance in doctor’s office, doctors should be neutral and let the patient speak of their experiences and patients should be open to other options and treatments. History taking ultimately test and display the relationship between doctor and patient showing that it is not always reciprocal.



Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Going to the Territory Essay

- Going to the Territory Ralph Ellison’s essay “Going to the Territory” is truly a definition of American culture.  Ellison’s essay is a description of his journey from Oklahoma to Brown University and along the way he uncovers truths about the way Americans selectively acknowledge their history and ignore important aspects of their culture and let them fester into an uncontrollable problem.  Ellison had a connection to Brown University before he even made it out of grammar school.  His principal was the first colored man to graduate from Brown and Ellison received an award in memorial to Dr....   [tags: Going to the Territory Essays]

Free Essays
474 words (1.4 pages)

Romanticism in Tim O'Brien's Going After Cacciato Essay

- Romanticism in Tim O'Brien's Going After Cacciato     Critics of Tim O'Brien's Going After Cacciato have examined its narrative technique (see Raymond) and its position in literature as metafiction (see Herzog).  Still other critics have commented on the motif of time (see McWilliams) and the theme and structure (see Vannatta).  On the last point, critics find the structure of the novel is fragmented to reveal the nature of the United States' involvement in Vietnam.  Unfortunately, this fragmentation makes the novel appear structurally weak.  Critics have found no unifying element to the parts to affirm the sense of wholeness readers feel after completing O'Brien's novel.  Nevert...   [tags: Going After Cacciato Essays]

Better Essays
1962 words (5.6 pages)

Blending Reality and Fantasy in Going After Cacciato Essay

- Blending Reality and Fantasy in Going After Cacciato by O'Brien As O'Brien's third novel, Going After Cacciato is one of his most acclaimed works. The book brings to the reader many chilling aspects of war while developing a connection between the reader and the narrator. After many years, Going After Cacciato still dominates over more recent war novels by providing a unique glimpse into the soldiers mind. O'Brien reflects upon his wartime experiences in Vietnam while successfully blending reality and fantasy in an original war story....   [tags: Going After Cacciato Essays O'Brien]

Better Essays
1261 words (3.6 pages)

California Is Going Through A Water Crisis Essay

- Have you’ve ever just been so thirsty, you just need to drink a tall cold glass of water. Americans take fresh water for granted, like we will never run out. Americans believe that they don’t need to conserve fresh water because that is unlimited, but that is untrue. Currently in California is going through a water crisis. Some of the main problems that led to the water crisis in California would be high temperatures in the winter, California’s agriculture, California’s Budget to fix the problem, and how it affected people’s everyday routine....   [tags: Water supply, Water resources, Water crisis]

Better Essays
1745 words (5 pages)

“The Going” Essay

- “The Going” by Thomas Hardy begins with the question ‘why’ a question which Hardy is asking as himself about the death of his wife. According to the footnotes this poem is written as eulogy to his first wife Emma, who died in 1912. Her death is sudden to him and he is questioning why he did not see it coming or if he missed any hints she could have given that would have pointed to her impending death. Her passing is described as happening quickly, calmly, and indifferent. Using the words ‘as if’ are key, because that is where he won’t admit that she would leave without telling him and he is protecting himself from having to outright call her indifferent....   [tags: Poetry Analysis]

Better Essays
1565 words (4.5 pages)

Going, Our Journey With The Narrator Travels Through Loss Essay

- In Amy Hempels’ Short Story “Going,” our journey with the narrator travels through loss, coping, memory, experience, and the duality of life. Throughout the story is the narrator’s struggle to cope with the passing of his mother, and how he transitions from a mixture of depression, denial, and anger, into a kind of acceptance and revelation. The narrator has lost his mother in a fire three states away, and proceeds on a reckless journey through the desert, when he crashes his car and finds himself hospitalized....   [tags: Time, Future, Present, Life]

Better Essays
1405 words (4 pages)

Essay about Pacific Oil Company Is Going Through Renegotiations

- Pacific Oil Company The Pacific Oil Company is going through renegotiations. The company grew immensely early in its conception. The Pacific Oil Company is a “producer of industrial petrochemicals” (Lewicki, Saunders, & Barry, 2010). In 1979 the Pacific Oil Company established a contract with the Reliant Corporation. Pacific Oil company was purchasing “vinyl chloride monomer” (VCM) from the Reliant Corporation. The initial contract was established in 1979, the contract was now set to expire in 1982....   [tags: Negotiation, Bargaining, Contract]

Better Essays
1060 words (3 pages)

Transition in Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been Essay

- Transition in Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been         Each of us experiences transitions in our lives. Some of these changes are small, like moving from one school semester to the next. Other times these changes are major, like the transition between youth and adulthood. In Joyce Carol Oates' "Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?", the author dramatizes a real life crime story to examine the decisive moment people face when at the crossroads between the illusions and innocence of youth and the uncertain future....   [tags: Where Are You Going Where Have You Been]

Better Essays
3642 words (10.4 pages)

Death in T.S. Eliot's The Wasteland and Maddy's No Past, No Present, No Future

- Death in T.S. Eliot's The Wasteland and Maddy's No Past, No Present, No Future Death is an inevitable fact that everyone experiences at some point in their lives. Whether it is losing a friend, family member, someone famous and well known, or finally themselves, everyone knows what it's like to deal with the topic of death. In The Wasteland T. S Eliot is describing death with a very different approach which makes death seem poetic yet very dreary and uninviting. On the other hand, in Yulisa Amadu Maddy's book No Past, No Present, No Future death is not poetic at all but very cold and melancholy....   [tags: Death Eliot Maddy Wasteland Future Past Essays]

Free Essays
1158 words (3.3 pages)

Life Lessons in Yulisa Amadu Maddy’s No Past, No Present, No Future Essay

- Life Lessons in Yulisa Amadu Maddy’s No Past, No Present, No Future An age-old cliché states that one really never appreciates what he or she has until it is gone. Does this mean that nobody has ever truly appreciated the gift of life while living. Such an assumption cannot easily be made because no one can truly know the experiences or feelings. One can only try to understand by relating it to personal experience. On the other hand, this cliché would seem to explain the changes that people undergo as a result of a close brush with death....   [tags: Death Maddy No Past Present Future Essays]

Free Essays
1020 words (2.9 pages)