Give a critical account of Freud’s understanding of religion. Essay

Give a critical account of Freud’s understanding of religion. Essay

Length: 965 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Give a critical account of Freud’s understanding of religion.
To answer the set question I will explore Freud’s Totem and Taboo looking at his theory of the primal horde and Oedipus complex and his theory on religion as an illusion. Also looking at Freud’s theory that religion is unhealthy psychologically. To conclude I will explore his relationship with Jung and the affect his criticism of Freud’s theory had on their professional collaboration.
Freud’s interpretation of the totem as representing the father of the tribe returns again to Freud’s problems with his own father. He approaches his Totem and Taboo theory from entirely a patriarchal stance ignoring the fact that his case ‘Little Hans’ fear was actually that his mother would disappear as she had often threatened this when the child misbehaved. (Storr, 1989, 108).
The belief that the origin of religion is benevolent to the father son relationship (Palmer, 1997, 30) returns us to his Oedipus complex. The primal horde that is dominated by a single father like male who takes all the women of the tribe and banishes his younger male rivals preventing incest and encouraging sexual ties outside the group. Again as in Freud’s Oedipus complex, the primary male is threatened by the younger males thus eliminating them from the group, this causes resentment within the younger males who then plot to murder the patriarch thus ending the primal horde. Freud states that as a result of guilt the younger males give reverence to the slaughtered father and as Freud sees it this is the very origin of religion. He also sees this as the origin of the taboo of incest.
Storr (1989, 108) argues that today there is no evidence from anthropology or from studies of subhuman primates that ...


... middle of paper ...


...othing more than repressed contents, these contents being constellated around the figure of the father. (Palmer, 1997, 164). It would seem that Freud went above and beyond to dispel religion as a healthy essential practice for the growth of society but rather saw it as a weakness. That many of Freud’s theories have stood the test of time is tantamount to his title as the ‘Father of Psychoanalysis’ although many have been tweaked or adjusted to suit today’s conditions. It would be unwise to completely ignore Freud’s views on religion but I think we can conclude that they are somewhat flawed.


Works Cited
Connolly, Peter (ed.) (1999) Approaches to the Study of Religion. London, Continuum.
Palmer, Michael (1997) Freud and Jung on Religion. 2nd edition, London, Routledge.
Storr, Anthony (1989) Freud; A Very Short Introduction. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Sigmund Freud 's Theory Of The Czech Republic Essay

- Biography Sigmund Freud was born on May 6, 1856, in Freiberg, Moravia, which is now a part of the Czech Republic. Freud was the first born of eight children, but he also had two step brothers from his Father’s previous marriage. His Father was married three times, the first two in which he was widowed. His third wife however was Freud’s mother, Amalia Nathanson. She was nineteen when she wedded his father who was thirty-nine at the time. Freud 's stepbrothers were the same age as his mother Amalia, and the older stepbrother 's son, which was Sigmund 's nephew, was his playmate growing up....   [tags: Sigmund Freud, Psychoanalysis, Carl Jung]

Strong Essays
1318 words (3.8 pages)

Freud and His Castration Complex Theory Essay

- The skill of questioning has a long history and is a part of every makeup of every human living on Earth. The result of any inquisition can show that the individual of any society is not fully the same as his co-inhabitor. People can have different definitions about what makes a happy life. Some will lean towards the financially materialistic end with money, toys, and electronics, among other things. Others will travel to another level and say examples that can include family, health, faith, and morality....   [tags: humankind, choices, obligations]

Strong Essays
952 words (2.7 pages)

Sigmund Freud and Everyday Use Essay

- Sigmund Freud and Everyday Use Sigmund Freud is best known for his development and use of psychoanalysis. The theory of psychoanalysis focuses on the concept of how our unconscious thoughts, feelings, and emotions play an active role in our daily lives. The id, ego, and superego are the three mental zones that encompass our psyche. Each zone has a specific function: The id functions on the pleasure principle; the ego on the protection of the individual; and the superego on protection of society....   [tags: Everyday Use essays]

Free Essays
851 words (2.4 pages)

A Critical Account of Freud’s Understanding of Religion Essay

- Sigmund Freud; Father of the psychoanalytic school of psychology, was not a friend to religious belief. Freud’s understanding of religion, to put it bluntly, was that of an illusion. That is to say, not necessarily false, but developed in response to the need to overcome the conflict between our sexual natures and the nature of civilisation. From this, we can attempt to critique said theory in order to see how “valid” it really is in the face of religion. For Freud’s position to be truly valid, we have to prove that the Oedipus complex is a fully universal sexual trauma, and that buried trauma can really manifest itself in the form of religion....   [tags: Psychology]

Strong Essays
923 words (2.6 pages)

Freud's Theory of Dreaming and Repression Essay

- The relationship between dreaming and repression is complex and requires thorough understanding of Freud’s theory thus it is better to get to know some of the terms and concepts Freud raises in study of dreams. As all the information is gathered, it is believed that the wish as fulfilled is shown only in a state of repression during sleep. It is universally known that dreams are full of meanings and emotions. In Freud’s theory, all dreams are wish fulfillments or at least attempts at wish fulfillment....   [tags: repression, dreaming, psychology, freud, ]

Strong Essays
1030 words (2.9 pages)

A Critical Analysis And Definition Of Sigmund Freud 's Beliefs On Religion

- This essay’s goal is to provide a critical analysis and definition of Sigmund Freud 's beliefs on religion. After thoroughly going through his theory on theology, I will then point out strengths and weaknesses in his beliefs and ultimately, make a decision on if I agree or disagree with his conclusions. In "Future of an Illusion”, religion is seen as imaginary. Although Abrahamic religions were a constant influence in his life. Freud, was an atheist and believed that religion is just a coping mechanism of civilization that can lead to harm....   [tags: Religion, Human, William James, Sigmund Freud]

Strong Essays
2560 words (7.3 pages)

Sigmund Freud 's Theory Of Psychoanalysis Essay

- Sigmund Freud is known for creating the concept of psychoanalysis, also known as psychoanalytic theory, which requires one to explore the unconscious mind. Over time, his theories have been revised as well as criticized in a variety of ways. Be that as it may, they have remained strong influences within the world of psychiatry, as well as in the worlds of film and literature. Many works generally exhibit Freudian influences, balancing the conscious life with the subconscious and dreamlike undertones....   [tags: Sigmund Freud, Psychosexual development]

Strong Essays
907 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Early Influences of Freud´s Theory

- Sigmund Freud was born March 6 1856 in Freiberg, Austria. Freud’s birth was somewhat of a controversy. The original announcement was that he was born May 6. The fact is that his mother Amalie was pregnant before she married Freud father Jakob. Freud was the eldest of eight children with Amaile Jokob’s third wife. His father did have two previous marriages. The first marriage he had two other children with Sally Kanner. Amalie had a great impact and influence on her son’s “Freud” theories. Amaile was much younger than Jokob....   [tags: Sigmund Freud, unconscious mind, personality]

Strong Essays
1896 words (5.4 pages)

Richard Wollheim's Analysis of Freud Essay examples

- Richard Wollheim author of ‘Freud’ was one of the most distinguished and productive philosophers of his generation. He made a significant contribution to the post war flourishing of British philosophy and as his career continued his work grew steadily more individual, rich and expressive (The Times 2003). For Wollheim psychoanalysis was crucial to his personal outlook and played a fundamental role in defining his outlook on art. This was reflected in his standing as an honorary member of the San Francisco Psychoanalytical Institute and honorary affiliate of the British Psychoanalytical Society....   [tags: Freud Essays]

Free Essays
1529 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on A Critical Examination of the Sexual Life of Man In Sigmund Freud

- A Critical Examination of the Sexual Life of Man In Sigmund Freud 1.0 INTRODUCTION It is a word that rings a bell, it penetrates all cultures and overwhelms all humanity. It means many things to many people; to some, it is sacred and should be treated with respect. To others, it is pleasurable and should be lured to without repression; expressed it is worded "human sexuality". Reiterating the central place which sexuality occupied in the life of man, Dietrich writers: Sex … as contrasted with other departments of bodily Experience is essentially deep....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
3822 words (10.9 pages)