George Stinney 's Trial And Trial Essay

George Stinney 's Trial And Trial Essay

Length: 1007 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In 1944, 14-year old African American, George Stinney, was wrongfully convicted and executed. According to, a digital database containing the collective history of notorious murders, the event took place in Alcolu, South Carolina. Stinney remains the youngest person executed in United States history. Stinney was accused of first-degree murder. He was charged with the murder of 11-year old Betty June Binnicker and 8-year old Mary Emma Thames. Stinney was executed by the formal method of execution at the time, the electric chair. The trial concluded in one day. After Stinney was arrested he was not allowed to see his family until after the trial and conviction concluded. Stinney reportedly confessed to the crime according to the investigating deputy, even though a confession statement by George Stinney never existed. In 2013 Stinney’s descended family petitioned for a retrial. On December 17, 2014, George Stinney’s case was vacated on claims that the prosecution and their methodology was flawed and that his sixth amendment was denied, due to him not properly having a defense in court (
Stinney’s supposed confession was the determining factor during his trial. notes, During Stinney’s court confession; the reason why he killed Mary Emma and Betty Binnicker, was their refusal to accept his sexual advances (
General assignment reporter for the Washington Post and author of “It took 10 minutes to
convict 14-year-old George Stinney Jr. It took 70 years after his execution to exonerate him”, Lindsey Bever, states, “He was questioned in a small room, alone – without his parents, without an attorney” (Bever). It happens to be that George fell under the category of a minor, th...

... middle of paper ...

...It was physically not possible for a boy of his build to drag and burry the posthumous bodies of those two young girls for that long of a distance by himself.
Hastings reports that the judge vacated George Stinney’s case in 2014, because there was no due process (Hastings). To address the counter argument; suppose Stinney is guilty on all counts. He would still be wrongfully convicted, due to an improper jury, court proceedings, and a feckless defense attorney who did nothing for his client. Dahl reports that Amie Ruffner, George Stinney’s sister, states that her brother was a scapegoat and a part of something a lot bigger than them (Dahl). This would definitely explain the swiftness of the proceedings. From arrest, trial, conviction, and execution it took a mere 3 months. It looks to me that George Stinney Jr. needed to be dead and it had to happen soon.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The George Zimmerman Trial Essay

- A classic case of race. Trayvon Martin, a young black teen, walked down the street one afternoon with a bottle of tea and a pack of skittles, before encountering a man of a different ethnic background- George Zimmerman. That tragic day was the last one Mr. Martin would ever see and it brings about the question, “Is his death justified by law?” Some may argue Zimmerman acted out of self-defense. Still others say a boy lost his life due to acts of racism. Sounds similar to the case mentioned in Twelve Angry Men, does it not....   [tags: race biased, famous court cases]

Better Essays
1133 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Was the Rosenberg Trial a Fair Trial?

- Was the Rosenberg trial a fair trial. This has been a very controversial and debated question throughout the 20th century. Many people believe that the Rosenbergs where innocent but had an unfair trial. Others believe that the Rosenbergs had a fair trial and are guilty because of their involvement with espionage and the Soviet Union. Overall the Trial is still a very controversial because of their involvement with communism, their convictions of espionage, and their show of treason against he United States with the Soviets....   [tags: unfair trial, communism, russia]

Better Essays
1346 words (3.8 pages)

Our Current Trial By Jury System Essay example

- Our current trial by jury system was originally adopted from Anglo-Saxon English common law. Prior to juries, the United States had much more rudimentary methods that were in affect, such as bench trials. A bench trial consists of solely the judge determining the final verdict, versus a jury possessing that responsibility. Proceeding with a trial by jury assures that there will be a margin of error, simply due to the fact that the jurors are human, and are susceptible to human fallibility. Whether the jury is cognizant of it or not, emotions such as pre-determined bias and favoritism can impede or bring the case to a halt all together....   [tags: Jury, Jury trial, Bench trial, Common law]

Better Essays
781 words (2.2 pages)

The Trial of Lizzie Borden Essay

- It has been one hundred and twenty-two years since "Lizzie Borden took an axe..", in accordance to the folk rhyme, and Andrew and Abby Borden were brutally murdered in their home; but still today it remains one of America's most famous, or infamous, unsolved crimes. Although Lizzie was acquitted and no one was ever proved guilty of committing the crime; it is still the popular opinion that Lizzie was, in fact, the murderer. Not many people have in doubts in their mind about Lizzie's guilt, although there is no one alive today who could witness to what happened....   [tags: unsolved crime, axe, damage, trial]

Better Essays
1959 words (5.6 pages)

The Trial of Socrates Essays

- In the spring of 399 BCE, A man named Socrates was put on trial in front of his native Athenians. Facing the charges of not acknowledging the gods the city acknowledges, and introducing other new divinities. In addition, He is also charged with corrupting the youth of Athens. The affidavit introduced by Meletus demands the penalty of death. These are very serious charges and the demand of death should not be taken lightly. Yet Meletus is ignorant about what he claims and his accusations can easily be rebutted....   [tags: Meletus, Unjust Trial]

Better Essays
712 words (2 pages)

The Trial Of The Court Essay

- INTRODUCTION I visited Isleworth Crown Court on 8th April 2015. At First, there were two assistant who gave us the Court’s timetable and explained what cases would be trialled at different courts. Also, they explained where the jury, people in public gallery, defendant and claimant should sit. Before the Court starts Her Honour Judge gave a presentation in terms of her rule, how the Court proceed and how the cases are considered in the Court. She stated that any defendant has the right for fair trail and we presume that everyone is innocent unless proven guilty....   [tags: Jury, Judge, Trial, Criminal law]

Better Essays
1619 words (4.6 pages)

Justice On Trial in Kafka's The Trial Essay

- Justice On Trial in Kafka's The Trial There is no such thing as justice - in or out of court.        Clarence Darrow i Most often critically interpreted as a search for Divine justice, Kafka's The Trial, a fragmented and unfinished novel, appears to leave us with the same impression as the words above of Clarence Darrow.  In other words, there is no justice.  This assessment of Divine justice by Kafka works on two levels.  On one level, he is illustrating the helpless nature of the individual when in conflict against an established bureaucracy.  On another level, he is illustrating the existential dilemma of man in the face of a godless, indifferent, and often hostile universe.  A search...   [tags: Kafka Trial Essays]

Better Essays
3824 words (10.9 pages)

Kafka’s The Trial Essay

- Kafka’s The Trial delves into the life of Josef K., a bank worker who gets himself tied up in an unknown trial, against an indefinable and ultimately unaccountable legal system. While the piece is a work of fiction it parallels many of the legal problems in existence during the period in which Kafka was writing and to an extent gives a fictitious account of many real events going on. Many parallels can be seen in the trials of Alfred Dreyfus, Oscar Wilde, John Scopes and Nikolai Bukharin in various ways....   [tags: The Trial Essays]

Better Essays
1674 words (4.8 pages)

Essay about Kafka's The Trial

- Kafka's The Trial Comparing Franz Kafka with a more modern author, such as J.K. Rowling, is much like comparing Wilt Chamberlain to Kobe Bryant. It is extremely difficult to compare these two NBA stars when they played sixty years apart from one another. There are so many factors to consider including: the quality of coaching, competition, etc....   [tags: Kafka Trial]

Free Essays
1199 words (3.4 pages)

Kafka's The Trial Essay

- Kafka's The Trial Kafka's The Trial follows a man, K., as he is arrested and released for an unknown offense and attends a series of bizarre trials. He tries to comprehend and extricate himself from an outrageous course of events, which transpire suddenly in his life. K. is persecuted by this unimaginable court, which seems to hold a quasi-authoritative place in society. K.'s life seems to spiral out of control while he and the reader struggle to understand what is going on. Kafka uses this piece to criticize bureaucracy, even in a seemingly democratic society....   [tags: Kafka Trial Essays]

Free Essays
888 words (2.5 pages)