Gene and Finny in A Separate Piece

Gene and Finny in A Separate Piece

Length: 1332 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
In the novel A Separate Peace, the author John Knowles creates a unique relationship between the two main characters Gene Forrester and Phineas, also known as Finny. The boys have a love hate relationship, which becomes the base of the problems throughout the book. The setting of this novel, a preparatory school in New Hampshire known as Devon, creates a peaceful environment where World War will not corrupt the boys. The boys might be protected from the war, but they are not protected from each other. Throughout the book Finny manipulates Gene. These reoccurring manipulations cause Gene to follow in Finny's footsteps and begin to live through Finny. The lives of the two boys change dramatically when an accident occurs. Instead of Gene living through Finny, Finny begins to live through Gene.
In the beginning to the middle of the book Gene lives through Finny. ‘"Come on,' drawled Finny from below, ‘stop standing there showing off.'…‘Jump!'"(Knowles 9). Finny thought of an extremely adventurous idea. He decided that he wanted to jump out of a tree into the river below. Finny also wanted the other boys that were with him to jump out of the tree. After Finny jumped he attempted to persuade Gene to follow his lead and jump out of the tree. Gene, a very conservative individual, did not even dream of ever jumping out of the tree but Finny got his way. Gene climbed the tree and jumped into the river because Finny manipulated him to. ‘"Studying! You know, books. Work. Examinations'" (Knowles 49). Finny has come to tell Gene that one of the boys named Leper has finally decided to jump out of the tree into the river. Gene finally explodes and starts screaming at Finny. Gene tells Finny that he needs to study for the French final and that he cannot be wasting his time with a silly game. At this moment in time, Finny finally realized that Gene actually has to study in order to get good grades. Finny always thought that school for Gene came just as easily as sports did for him. When Finny realizes this he tells Gene that he has to study. ‘"Don't move from that desk. It's straight A's for you'"(Knowles 50). All of a sudden Gene became perplexed. He could not understand that Finny was actually telling him to stay home and study.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Gene and Finny in A Separate Piece." 05 Apr 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Separate Piece, By John Knowles Essay

- In John Knowles’ novel, A Separate Piece, the main Character, Gene Forrester, has to learn to become friends with his hazardous roommate, Phineas, at his school, Devon, in New Hampshire. The novel is affected by a number of changes, however the largest and most significant change is the change in seasons. In Thomas C. Foster’s novel, How to read literature like a Professor, chapter twenty explains the significance of the seasons. Foster states that, “Summer [symbolizes] adulthood and romance and fulfillment and passion,” while, “ winter [symbolizes] old age and resentment and death.” John Knowles’ book A Separate Peace, all aspects of Summer, Fall, and Winter are excellently represented as...   [tags: Season, Autumn, A Separate Peace, Winter]

Research Papers
910 words (2.6 pages)

Free College Essays - Envy in A Separate Peace

- Envy in A Separate Peace                     “People are often vain of their most criminal passions; but envy is one passion so mean and low that nobody will admit it” Francois de la Rochefoucauld(1613-1680), a French philosopher, once stated and that statement summarizes the undertone of A Separate Piece by John Knowles.  The story is set at a highly competitive boy’s school on the East Coast that sets the perfect stage to develop the storyline.  Gene’s insecurity, which led to jealousy of Finny, is the cause of the overall conflict....   [tags: A Separate Peace Essays]

Free Essays
391 words (1.1 pages)

Separate Peace Reflection Essay

- As a person grows and develops into an adult, there are people who help better them and people who hold them back. The book A Separate Peace by John Knowles follows Gene Forester along his journey to adulthood. With Gene is his best friend Phineas. As events push Gene to grow and mature, something holds him back, his friend Phineas. When Gene is not under Phineas’s influence, he is able to grow and become a stronger person. Phineas pulls Gene away from his responsibilities and chances for growth....   [tags: A Separate Peace, Guilt]

Research Papers
732 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about A separate piece

- A. Title and Author - A Separate Peace by John Knowles B. Story Setting - The story starts off at the Devon school, which is a prep school in New England at 1958. But the rest of the story takes place through a flashback of his days when he was a student at Devon during 1943. C. Main Characters - Gene Forrester - Gene is the narrator of the novel and appears at two different time periods: as a middle-aged man re-visiting Devon fifteen years after being a student there, and, for the majority of the novel, as a sixteen and seventeen-year-old student during World War II....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1775 words (5.1 pages)

Biography of John Knowles Essays

- John Knowles was born on 1962 in Fairmont, West Virginia and passed away on November 29, 2001. He was 15 years old when he became a student at Phillips Exeter Academy, a boarding school. After he graduated from there is 1945, he decided to join the war effort as part of the U.S. Army Air Force’s Aviation Cadet Program. John went to Europe and worked as a journalist until the mid 1950’s and then returned to the U.S in 1957. After returning, he took a job with the associate editor at Holiday magazine, Thornton Wilder....   [tags: American Novelist, A Separate Piece, Analysis]

Research Papers
1515 words (4.3 pages)

Essay about A seperate piece

- A seperate piece A Separate Peace by John Knowls Is a classic struggle of man vs. himself and man vs. society. Taking place as a flashback, the narrator Gene Forrester tells of his struggles as a prep school student in the years of his life between age 16, and 17 during the period of WWII. Although Gene Forester the narrator and Finny an athletic roommate are best friends, they have to contrasting struggles. Like the garden of Eden the first few chapters express the peacefulness of the summer at the Private school in New England and the land beneath the forbidden tree....   [tags: Essays Papers]

Free Essays
448 words (1.3 pages)

Essay on A Separate Peace Analysis

- Many people wish that there would be nothing to worry about. When problems do arise, these people do not associate themselves with them, but they try to find a separate peace. In the novel of the same title, Gene is one of those people, and he tries to ignore the outside war by finding an inner peace: Phineas. Finny becomes a magical fairy that sprinkles tranquility into Gene’s daily life. Even though Phineas becomes Gene’s separate peace, Finny ironically destroys Gene. The word “separate,” in the title, is depicted in Gene’s separation from the world, because he neglects most of his dilemmas in life....   [tags: Literary Review]

Research Papers
515 words (1.5 pages)

Essay on A Separate Peace

- A Separate Peace A Separate Peace is a coming of age novel in which Gene, the main character, revisits his high school and his traumatic teen years. When Gene was a teen-ager his best friend and roommate Phineas (Finny) was the star athlete of the school. Gene was only a mediocre athlete and is always jealous of Finny. They form a Super Suicide Society of the Summer Session which includes jumping from a tree into a river as its initiation. Eventually, Finny falls from the tree fracturing his leg....   [tags: essays papers]

Free Essays
659 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on Personal Experiences Reflected in John Knowle´s A Separate Peace

- Influences of John Knowles What is an author’s muse. A muse can be influences from historical events, life events, or ideals. A Separate Peace written by John Knowles is a book written from his experiences and current events. He took these experiences and transferred them to his novel. Today many people appreciate his novel and its influences. John Knowles’ boarding school at Exeter, his life and experiences during World War II, and the characters’ guilt influenced his great work, A Separate Peace....   [tags: World War II, Teenager, High school]

Research Papers
1282 words (3.7 pages)

Free Essays - Gene and Finny of A Separate Peace

- A Separate Peace Gene and Finny In A Separate Peace, the main characters are foils of one another. The plot is pushed along by the changing dynamics of their friendship. Their relationship begins to drift apart when their personalities clash. The changing dynamics of Gene and Finny's relationship and the revelations in Gene's personality are what move the plot along. At first, Gene fights against his memories. The story is opened with Gene returning to his old school, Devon. A struggle, or some sort of conflict, is clear by the way he practically forces himself to return to the staircase and the tree....   [tags: Separate Peace Essays]

Free Essays
525 words (1.5 pages)

Related Searches

This event confused Gene so much that he ended up going to watch Leper jump from the tree. ‘"Wait just a minute. I'm coming'"(Knowles 51). Once again Finny could manipulate Gene into going or doing what Finny wants him to do. "Going there risked exploitation, destroyed the studying I was going to do for an important test the next morning…it also involved the kind of long labored bicycle ride I hated. ‘All right' I said"(Knowles 37). Finny has just broken the school swimming record but makes Gene promise not to tell a soul. Finny decides that swimming in a pool is not good enough, that he wants to go to the beach. Even though Gene has an enormous trigonometry test to study for and he never disobeys the rules, Gene still goes because Finny manipulates him. Gene's going to the beach causes him to fail his test. This is the first failing grade he has ever received and it is all because Finny manipulates him to go to the beach even though he really does not want to. Gene's failing the test finally makes him consider that Finny keeps trying to ruin his grades so that he cannot be top of the class. This brings many feeling of hatred towards Finny into Gene.
Finny has manipulated Gene so much that Finny has become part of Gene. "In any case I was already late for my next appointment"(Knowles 67) Before Gene became such good friends with Finny, he would never consider being late for something or not even showing up but Finny has begun to rub off just a little bit on Gene. Gene has an appointment to go see Brinker, one of his classmates, but he decides not to show up. Then he has to go down to the Crew House to begin boating, but he shows up late. It would be understandable if Finny were with Gene that this could happen, but Gene is all by himself. No one could manipulate him. Gene decides by himself to be late and skip the meeting. This demonstrates how Gene is beginning to take on some of Finny's traits. "I was Phineas, Phineas to the life"(Knowles 54). One day, when getting dressed for dinner, Gene decides to wear Finny's clothes to dinner. Gene put on Finny's pants, shoes and a ridiculous pink shirt. When Gene looks into the mirror, he sees Finny staring back at him. The clothes are not the only thing that makes Gene feel like Finny, there is also the expression Gene has on his face. "I even had his humorous expression in my face, his sharp, optimistic awareness."(Knowles 54). When Gene sees Finny in himself he suddenly feels enlightened. He feels that nothing else could get in his way anymore and that every thing will be perfect. This demonstrates how Gene feels about Finny. Gene believes that Finny is perfect and that if he becomes Finny, nothing will be wrong about him, he too will become perfect. ‘" And could you tell me how and why you fell into the river?' ‘I slipped'"(Knowles 73). Gene just got into a fight with Quackenbush, the crew manager, and gets pushed into the river. When Gene comes sauntering back to his dorm, he comes across one of the teachers, Mr. Ludsbury. When Mr. Ludsbury asks Gene what happen, he says that he slipped. Normally Gene would never lie to a teacher. Finny is known for making up extravagant lies and being able to convince teachers to believe them. Even though Gene's lie is not unbelievable he still tells a lie. This becomes another example of Finny's daring personality shining through Gene's conservative personality.
After a horrible accident occurs, which involves Gene bouncing Finny off the tree and Finny breaking his leg, the tables turn. Instead of Gene living through Finny, Finny begins living through Gene. ‘"The two of them looked as black-as black as death standing up there with fire burning all around them'"(Knowles 166). Leper begun to describe what he saw on day when Finny fell from the tree. Leper cannot tell who was located where on the tree limb. He says that the boys looked black because the sun was shining so brightly. The boys merge together when they are up on the tree. The silhouettes of their bodies show that they become equal. As soon as Finny falls from the tree, Gene stops living through Finny, and Finny starts living through Gene. ‘"Listen pal if I can't play sports you're going to play them for me'"(Knowles 77). When Finny fell from the tree he broke his leg. This terrible accident prevented him from playing sport anymore. Since Finny could not do what he loved most, he decides that Gene is going to fulfill his needs to play sports. Finny starts training Gene to replace him. Finny begins to live through Gene when he makes Gene play sports. ‘"Did I ever tell you,' he began in a husky tone, ‘that I used to be aiming for the Olympics?'"(Knowles 109). Finny had been hoping to compete in the 1944 Olympics, although due to the war this dream is unlikely to occur. Gene becomes Finny's substitute when it came to sports.
Throughout the book a large transformation happens, although some things stay the same. In the beginning of the book, Gene lives through Finny, but by the end, Finny begins living through Gene. Finny still keeps on manipulating. John Knowles displays how people can change tremendously throughout one year. Sometimes change can lead to positive outcomes, but other times it can result in negative outcomes.
Return to