Gender Roles: Biology or Culture Essay

Gender Roles: Biology or Culture Essay

Length: 1301 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Brettell and Sargent open their book Gender in Cross Cultural Perspectives with a question: What is the role of biology in human behaviour (Brettell and Sargent, 2009, 1). Ward and Edelstein approach this question using cross-species analysis. They compare chimpanzee biology and behaviour to humans. There are four reasons that Ward uses comparisons to chimpanzees. First, because chimpanzees represent our closest genetic relative and second, the social activities and behaviours may be reflective of human ancestors. Third, cross-species analysis is the best way to overcome cultural biases (Ward and Edelstien , 2009, 101). Finally, there is extensive and scientifically recognized body of work on the relationship between biology and behaviour.
Several of the authors also use cross-species analysis and studies to compare humans to animal models of behaviour. When using biological models to explain human behaviour, there is the fear of the justification of sexism (Zuk, 2009, 7). Stereotypes often arise from the animal kingdom (Zuk, 2009, 7).This can pose a problem for accepting biology as an explanation for gender in modern humans. Zuk counters this belief, promoting an understanding of the biology of human sexual behaviour through an examination of animal models (Zuk, 2009, 8). Ehrenberg presents primate models to show the lack of difference biologically between males and females (Zuk, 2009, 17). Ward also uses primate models, specifically chimpanzees and baboons, to illustrate the similarities between humans and animals (Ward and Edelstien , 2009, 101).
Zuk does warn against attempting to use animal models as a single model for the origin of sex roles as the animal kingdom represents a wide variety of sexual behaviours including int...

... middle of paper ...

...roline B., and Carolyn F. Sargent, eds. 2009. Gender in Cross-cultural Perspective, 5th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall.
Ehrenberg, Margaret. 2009. ``The Role of Women In Human Evolution``. In Gender in Cross-cultural Perspective, 5th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall.

Martin, Emily. 1991. ``The egg and the sperm: how science has constructed a romance based on stereotypical male-female roles``.
Peach, Lucinda J. 2009. ``Gender and War: Are Women Tough Enough for Military Combat``. In Gender in Cross-cultural Perspective, 5th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall, pp. 21-32.
Zuk, Marlene. 2009. ``Animal Models and Gender``. In Gender in Cross-cultural Perspective, 5th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall.

Ward, Martha and Monica Edelstein. 2009. A World Full of Women, 5th ed. Boston: Pearson Education, Inc.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Gender Roles in Dakota Culture Essay

- I do not agree with scholars who argue that Dakota women were subordinate to Dakota men. Waterlily is “about a girl who lived a century ago, in a remote camp-circle of the Teton Dakotas [Lakotas].”(Deloria vi). Ella Cara Deloria, author of Waterlily, explains her writing, “it reads convincingly to any who understands Dakota life... and it's purely the woman's point of view, her problems, aspirations, ideals, etc.”. (Deloria vi). In general, when our [westernized] culture hears that women are inferior to men, we think of it as sexist and unfair, not as a culturally acceptable idea....   [tags: Gender Studies]

Strong Essays
923 words (2.6 pages)

Gender Stereotypes And Gender Roles Essay

- ... Often it is assumed that because we know the child’s sex we also know what they will be interested in. These outdated assumptions and roles face a major problem today due to people feeling free to express their true preferences. Transgender males and females have been very popular topics in recent news. More then ever we are seeing people feel enough social acceptance to express how they feel at the core of their being. Transgender individuals are challenging the rigid roles we have set in place by talking about how they feel like the opposite gender and how this is how they were born....   [tags: Gender, Gender role, Male, Female]

Strong Essays
909 words (2.6 pages)

Essay Gender Roles Of Men And Women

- Throughout history men are held to a higher standard than women. Men are viewed as the ones with political, corporate and economic power able to control the world we live in, but women on the other hand, are viewed as the opposite, the standard of women is seen as the ones who stayed home, take care and nurture the kids, provide food for the family and maintain the household. According to American anthropologist Conrad Kottak, gender roles are tasks and activities the culture assigns to men and women (2008)....   [tags: Gender, Gender role, Transgender, Man]

Strong Essays
1195 words (3.4 pages)

Gender Roles Of Male And Female Essay

- Our society is has been maintained throughout the human history by the roles and responsibilities of different members. Especially gender roles of male and female have contributed to the balance and development of society in different aspects. There are several ways to determine the roles of male and female, including biology, culture, evolution, and society. In general, gender role is considered to be a set of attitudes, behaviors, and self-presentation methods ascribed to members of a certain biological sex....   [tags: Gender, Gender role, Sexual dimorphism, Male]

Strong Essays
1135 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about Socialization and the Learning of Gender Roles

- The term socialization refers to the “lifelong social experience by which individuals develop their human potential and learn culture.” [Macionis et al. p 55] The concept of socialization is that our actions are driven/learned by culture. Socialization is also the foundation of personality, which we build by internalizing our surroundings. Through the lifelong process of socialization, society transmits culture from one generation to the next. A good example of socialization is the learning of gender roles....   [tags: gender, socialization, psychology,]

Strong Essays
887 words (2.5 pages)

Gender Role Behaviors: Biology and Society Share Responsibility Essay

- There are many different facets to the nature versus nurture argument that has been going on for decades. One of these, the influence of nature and nurture on gender roles and behaviors, is argued well by both Deborah Blum and Aaron Devor, both of whom believe that society plays a large role in determining gender. I, however, have a tendency to agree with Blum that biology and society both share responsibility for these behaviors. The real question is not whether gender expression is a result of nature or nurture, but how much of a role each of these plays....   [tags: Gender Role Behaviors and Attitudes]

Strong Essays
1524 words (4.4 pages)

The Roles of Mother and Father within Society Essay

- Essay Question 1: Western researchers and academics like to believe that there is a mostly consistent definition of the roles of mother and father within societies. This gives an easy set of touchstones for them to draw comparisons when they are studying different cultures’ ways of parenting, or when they are studying different social and cultural effects that they believe can be tied to alternative parenting roles. While it may be an accurate assumption that cultures have a mostly-consistent set of roles for mother and father, the degree of consistency of that role among individual parents has weakened over the past few decades....   [tags: gender roles, sociological analysis]

Strong Essays
2028 words (5.8 pages)

Gender Roles And Its Effect On Children Essay

- ... From the moment that you take your first breathe; your parents inundate you with discriminatory information because the gender roles have been passed down from generation to generation, and thus, parents relate to their pink daughters and blue sons differently. According to phycologist Crissy Duff, Duff points out “that from the moment children are born, they are bombarded with gender-related messages. Toys, clothes, and observations around the house-dad takes out the garbage, mom loads the dishwasher-all feed into what they think is expected of them” (Futterman1)....   [tags: Gender, Female, Gender role, Male]

Strong Essays
784 words (2.2 pages)

Essay about Gender Equity And Biological Determinism

- There has been discussion about gender role and gender equity for a long time. As we are striving for gender equity, the origin of gender role is also a good topic to research on. In this paper, I will first give definitions of the two explanations for gender role, social constructionism and biological determinism. I will talk about the comparison of this two and give out my preference. Second, I will mention more about gender equity, including the supposed different gender set, the possibility of gender equity and biological understanding of gender equity....   [tags: Gender role, Gender, Sociology, Transgender]

Strong Essays
763 words (2.2 pages)

Gender Roles Essay

- The term gender roles refers to the set of social and behavioral norms that are considered appropriate for individuals of a certain gender. These roles vary between cultures. Gender roles, unlike gender itself, are socially constructed. They may reflect the natural aspirations of the gender, or they may be manipulated, resulting in the oppression of a gender. Historically, gender roles have not always been consistent with those we have today. Though in many ancient societies men have been dominant to women, there are example where women have been considered equal to men, and where women have been dominant over men....   [tags: Gender Oppression]

Strong Essays
2007 words (5.7 pages)