It is true that 300, though it has captured the concept of its graphic novel, and has additional scenes that we could say is for cinematic purpose and isn’t simply ‘a rehash ‘.To a certain degree it challenges the criticism made by “French Director Alain Resnais when he stated in the 1990, “Till today I haven’t seen a cinematographic adaptation of a comic, which seems to add something to the original work, they have always been rehashes” (Thomas 247; Pascal Lefevre, 2007, 1) To explain further the movie 300 represents at least 90% of the graphic novel, perhaps not in chronological manner of the graphic novel, for example in the graphic novel the upbringing and initiation of King Leonidas spreads throughout the five chapters unlike the movie the events is presented in the beginning to the audience. Despite the success of 300 there is the matter of a few downsides when it comes to adaptation, in this case a graphic novel, to cinema; I will discuss and make comparison of the scenes, both the film and novel, from where the Persian main messenger talks with King Leonidas to their deaths in Sparta.
In the article Incompatible visual ontologies ( Pascal Lefevre, 2007, 3-4) Pascal mentions four problematic aspects of adaptation, which are: 1. Deletion and Addition process, 2.) Characteristics of comic page layout and...
... middle of paper ...
...ng the reader a sound of that panel.
There will always be adaptation problems when it comes to comic books to novels because the challenges and expectations between the comic readers and film audience however Frank Miller’s 300 has to be one of the successful adaptation comic films.
Lefevre, Pascal. “Incompatible Visual Ontologies? – The Problematic Adaptation of Drawn Images. In Film and Comic Books, edited by Mark Jancovich, Matthew P McAllister and Ian Gordan, Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 2007, 1 – 13.
McCloud, Scott. “Time Frames”, Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art. New York : HarperCollins Publishers, 1993.
300 pictures. Martin Aquino. http://www.martinaquino.wordpress.com/ 01 March 2010.
The Best film of 2007. Rebecca Murray. http://www.moviesabout.com/300review/ 01 March 2010.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- ... For example, in the book Scarlett had three children, but in the movie she only had one child. The children are significant in that they give the reader an insight into Scarlett’s terrible parenting skills and make her character even more unlikeable. In the book, Ashley Wilkes has two sisters, Honey and India, but in the movie India is his only sister. Another character who was omitted from the movie is Will Benteen, who marries Scarlett’s sister, Suellen, and helped rebuild Tara. One very significant change in characters was the portrayal of Scarlett’s attacker as a white man in the movie instead of the black attacker in the book.... [tags: characters, atlanta, love story]
742 words (2.1 pages)
- Jaws was a mammoth success as a movie, but before it was a movie, it was a very successful novel that was on the best sellers list for 44 weeks. Jaws was written in 1974 by Peter Benchley. It is a story of a great white shark that preys upon a small resort community and the efforts of three men trying to kill it and stop its destructive attacks. After he learned about the exploits of shark fisherman Frank Mundus in 1964, Benchley's interest in shark attacks manifested into this novel. Doubleday publishing had commissioned Benchley to write the novel in 1971.... [tags: Jaws, Steven Spielberg]
1665 words (4.8 pages)
- The film The Green Mile was originally written by Stephen King and later directed by Frank Darabont. It is based on the guards and inmates of a penitentiary’s Death Row during the great depression. There is a certain monotony that comes with working on Death Row and Paul Edgecomb, played by Tom Hanks, has become numb to the fact that he is paid to take lives; that is until John Coffey gets sentenced to death and is sent to Paul’s “green mile”. John Coffey is a very large black man that was accused of rape and murder of two little girls, and in the 1930’s having charges like that brought upon you was grounds for the death penalty, especially for a black man in the south.... [tags: Green Mile, Frank Darabont, directors, ]
723 words (2.1 pages)
- ... The novel is over 1,000 pages and the film is 238 minutes, making it the longest movie at the time it was released, (1939). There are some very notable differences, however, between the book and the film. In both the movie and the book, Scarlett is married three times. Scarlett marries Charles Hamilton, a young man whom is leaving for the war. She immediately agrees to marry him in order to make Ashley Wilkes jealous. Scarlett is obsessed with Ashley and makes most of her life decisions throughout the film and movie only to position herself to be closer to him.... [tags: love story, scarlett, rhett butler]
997 words (2.8 pages)
- Between the book and the movie I prefer the movie. My reasoning for this is that the movie seemed much more interesting to me. It made much more sense. I also love who they chose to play the characters in the movie. Seemed much more interesting than the ones that were in the book. I must admit that the book was pretty good, though some of it I found rather boring. One thing I did not like about the movie is that they changed or added some details into the movie that the book did not have. The ending of the movie was much better then the ending in the book.... [tags: setting, book, movie, character]
564 words (1.6 pages)
- Into the Wild, a novel written by Jon Krakauer, as well as a film directed by Sean Penn, talks about Chris McCandless, a young individual who set out on a journey throughout the Western United States, isolating himself from society, and more importantly, his family. During his travels, he meets a lot of different people, that in a way, change his ways about how he sees the world. There are many characteristics to describe McCandless, such as “naïve”, “adventurous”, and “independent”. In the book, Krakauer described McCandless as “intelligent”, using parts in his book that show McCandless being “intelligent”.... [tags: Book vs Movie]
755 words (2.2 pages)
- In the movie Shawshank Redemption made in 1994 by Frank Darabont. Cast membranes are Tim Robbins as Andy and Morgan Freeman as Red his best friend. This movie can be describe as corruption, friendship, and hope. In the beginning, of the movie Andy is sent to prison for the murder of his wife and her affair. At the time no one knew Andy really did not kill his wife and her lover. When Andy made it to prison, he made a friend named Red another man that was in prison already for murder. During the years Red and Andy friendship grow.... [tags: The Shawshank Redemption, Frank Darabont]
743 words (2.1 pages)
- The Diary of Anne Frank Book Review On June 12, 1929, at 7:30 AM, a baby girl was born in Frankfort, Germany. No one realized that this infant, who was Jewish, was destined to become one of the worlds most famous victims of World War II. Her name was Anne Frank. Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl, by Anne Frank and B.M. Mooyaart, was actually the real diary of Anne Frank. Anne was a girl who lived with her family during the time while the Nazis took power over Germany. Because they were Jewish, Otto, Edith, Margot, and Anne Frank immigrated to Holland in 1933.... [tags: Diary Anne Frank Holocaust Essays Nazis]
1379 words (3.9 pages)
- The Big Sleep - The Movie and The Book One would think that it would be quite easy to adapt a novel to a screenplay; after all, what is there to do but turn the dialogue into lines and description into set design. However, common sense, aided by the horrifying number of absolutely awful adaptations, dictates that it simply is not that easy. When moviegoers have problems with a film adaptation of a book, their complaints tend to lie in the tendency of the creators of the film to change elements of the story: plot, character, and the like.... [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]
1320 words (3.8 pages)
- The poetry of Frank O'Hara is intimately connected to New York City. He explores the role of the individual subject in the city and the mechanics of the city itself; yet because he engages the urban landscape in an urbane manner many readers of Frank O'Hara view him as the prankish patron of the New York art scene who occasionally took pen to paper. Take this review by Herbert Leibowitz as an example: A fascinating amalgam of fan, connoisseur, and propagandist, he was considered by his friends, in an excess of enthusiasm, as the Apollinaire of his generation, an aesthetic courtier who had taste and impudence and prodigious energy .... [tags: Frank]
3014 words (8.6 pages)