Karl the Nazi Soldier, who initiates our inquiry into forgiveness, represents multiple identities. He is at once a rational human being, a member and supporter of the Nazi military, a murderer, and actor and representative of the State. Because of the simultaneously occurrence and fluidity of these identities conflation is an easy mistake in constructing exactly who we are forgiving. To forgive Karl the individual is very different than forgiving the Nazis or the State as represented by Karl. Even Lawrence Lager in the Symposium writes “It seems to me that in refusing to extend forgiveness to the culprit, Wiesenthal unconsciously acknowledges the indissoluble bond fusing the criminal to his crime” (The Sunflower 178). The conflation of what Karl represents is a large part of what make Wiesenthal’s question so vexing because the rules of forgiveness alter depending on the actor. Karl the individual is due certain considerations simply because of his humanity while the Nazis and the State as represented by Karl are entangled in political considerations. Forever labeling Karl as a murderer forgoes his still present humanity. This is not to say that forgiving Karl the individual isn’t political, or that we shouldn’t acknowledge the enormity of his crime. This is to stress that the limits and criteria of forgiveness change whether it is person to person or person to political bodies.
This separation of individual from sta...
... middle of paper ...
...untry and the victims to move forward and be “free” as one symposium speakers says. To wallow with bitterness and despair is perhaps than acknowledging what happen, mourning what was loss, and beginning the process of rebuilding. Louise Mallinder in “Can Amnesties and International Justice be Reconciled?” posits the following hypothetical: “Amnesty for lower-level offenders could also mean that in their daily life, victims are frequently confronted by the individuals who caused their suffering which could cause further harm to the victims and even lead them to engage in vigilantism” (210).
Forgiveness is not physical and can only be manifested through the mediums of words, actions and shared understandings. These traits gives forgiveness a spiritual quality that illustrates how it can transcend physical atrocity; to render the unforgiveable forgivable.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- So forgive and forget, huh. It appears forgiveness is quite an important force in the tempest, bringing the story together beautifully. Forgiveness helps us learn about the characters in the play. Forgiveness is also what brings the play to a happy ending, but not without making one wonder whether forgiveness was really achieved. The role of forgiveness in the tempest is so significant because it is only through forgiveness that the characters truly succeed, but also because it raises the question of the extent of human forgiveness and helps the reader learn plenty about the different characters in the play.... [tags: The Tempest, Moons of Uranus, Forgiveness]
1124 words (3.2 pages)
- ... An perspective of gratitude in addition to forgiveness spills over right into all aspects of 1’s lifestyles and the next advantages may also be enjoyd: reduced pressure levels and strengthend talent to take care of tensionful state of affairss or predicament, enhanced sense of well-being and happiness, strengthening of courtings, develop intoation of anger into forgiveness, worry into courage. (Emmons & McCullough, 2003; Watkins, 2004). Appreciating and forgiving others promotes peace, joy and contentment in any given situation.... [tags: forgiveness, tolerance, optimism]
555 words (1.6 pages)
- order to move towards any form of authentic forgiveness for her husband. This means my client can be advised that acceptable grounds for forgiveness in this particular situation involving this domestic violence incident with her husband has to be compatible with her self-respect, respect for others as moral agents, and respect for moral rules (Murphy and Hampton, 1988). This translates into her husband will need to come forward on his own volition to authentically apologize to her for his wrongful act, demonstrate genuine sorrow, and convey real regret for what he did.... [tags: Forgiveness, Core issues in ethics]
1258 words (3.6 pages)
- “I hate you. I wish I were dead…” are the words of Amy Tan, which are included in her essay “The Most Hateful Words”. The hatred is directed to her mother, with whom, she had a turbulent relationship. The sixteen year old Tan talks about never being able to forgive her mother for all the injustices she had to endure. Tan and her mother didn’t have the greatest relationship, however at the age of 47, Tan saw herself forgiving her ill mother. Forgiveness should be learned and practiced by all, rancor is a heavy burden to carry and can turn a person into a miserable being.... [tags: forgiveness, amy tan, hate, forgive]
869 words (2.5 pages)
- Forgiveness is to stop feeling angry, to stop blaming someone for the way they made a person feel, and stop feeling victims of whatever wickedness was directed towards them. Is forgiveness necessary. Can everyone be forgiven despite the circumstances. If forgiveness depends on the situation, then is it necessary at all. Does forgiveness allow someone to continue their life in peace. Is forgiving someone who causes physical pain to someone, as a pose to forgiving someone who murdered a member of the family the same.... [tags: forgiveness, crimes, murderer]
1381 words (3.9 pages)
- Everyone has reconciled with forgiveness. Forgiveness can happen very quickly and easily or it can take years or even generations. It is subjective and goes beyond rationality. However, do people understand the entire process and the significance behind forgiveness. Forgiveness is a decision that is made through an intricate process. This includes multiple stages influenced by a variety of factors rather than a decision that is made based on only emotion. Likewise, forgiveness is not about identifying, but analyzing the situation where forgiveness needs to take place.... [tags: Psychology, Emotion, Forgiveness, Thought]
773 words (2.2 pages)
- After learning about Aristotle’s review of virtues, two of them stand out, justice and forgiveness. No one can touch justice or forgiveness, but you can see the outcomes when they are demonstrated. Justice and forgiveness are two different virtues that demand motion, with forgiveness it requires a deep feeling to let go, whereas with justice it requires an action a person takes. Forgiveness requires people to participate in a process of releasing bitterness, hate and anger toward someone or something.... [tags: justice, forgiveness, christians]
914 words (2.6 pages)
- Simon Wiesenthal’s question “What would [you] have done” if one had the opportunity to forgive a Nazi soldier forces humanity to understand and apply our moral repertoire. My moral repertoire I mean the set of moral beliefs that informs our understanding of forgiveness and the criteria by which we evaluate its Karl the Nazi Soldier, who initiates our inquiry into forgiveness, represents multiple identities. He is at once a rational human being, a member and supporter of the Nazi military, a murderer, and actor and representative of the State.... [tags: Informative, Nazy Soldier]
1343 words (3.8 pages)
- Forgiveness Christ Jesus some two thousand years ago came into this world to bring redemption for our sins. He did this through his death and resurrection, or what we refer to as the pascal mystery. We still encounter the saving presence of the Lord in the sacraments and in the Word. In each and every sacrament we come face to face with "the grace of God our Savior" (Titus 2:11). It is this redemption of sins aspect of the sacraments that I will be examine. In the past couple of century we have focused are attention primarily on the Sacrament of Penance as the means to obtain forgiveness of sins after Baptism.... [tags: essays research papers fc]
2944 words (8.4 pages)
- Forgiveness Jesus forgave many sinners throughout his ministry, but many people were upset at his actions e.g. when Jesus healed a paralysed man. In Palestine it was the general belief that sickness was caused by sin. When Jesus saw how much faith the man had he forgave all of his sins, and the man was able to pick up his mat and walk home. Jesus believed that he could heal physically and spiritually, but the Pharisees were extremely upset because they thought Jesus was blaspheming as only God could forgive sins.... [tags: Papers]
604 words (1.7 pages)