This article describes the flaws and weaknesses of the traditional aid model as implemented by the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), and proposes that all US foreign aid policy be implemented following the Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC) approach. In this critique, I will analyze the method used by the Heritage Foundation to analyze US foreign aid policy and determine whether or not it followed the policy analysis process as described by the literature.
Problem definition: This article clearly identifies and defines the problem. For the Heritage Foundation the problem lies on the USAID’s approach to foreign aid. They describe this approach as ineffective and costly because it is a top-down, fragmented, and does not require accountability system, which encourages dependency on aid. As a conservative think tank, a major concern is that USAID promotes a statist and entitlement mentality and has a poor record promoting economic growth. Another dimension of the problem is that Congress continues to increase USAID’s budget with funds that expire encouraging reckless spending. Finally, the Heritage Foundation sees this problem as a waste of taxpayers’ money.
As Bardach (2009) mentions, any problem definition should include quantitative measures in order to det...
... middle of paper ...
...rmine which countries will receive funding is measure enough of effectiveness. Nonetheless, the author fails to acknowledge the criticism that the MCC approach has received for the use of this objective indicators as measures of performance. On the other hand, efficiency is obtained through the promotion of transparency and accountability but the author fails again to determine how these concepts will be demonstrated and how the MCC approach will the gap.
Conclusion: This article doesn’t follow the policy analysis process developed by the literature, and therefore the outcome is disappointing. The fact that the think tank’s mission is to promote conservative policies should not mean that these types of policies go unrevised and unscrutinized just because they are conservative. A more thorough process is required, especially when the audience is policymakers.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Time is a plan, schedule, or arrangement when something should happen or be done. People think about time at every point in their life. Time not only affects people’s everyday life, but also the relationship between the President and Congress. This paper will begin by discussing the duties of the President and Congress in the United States. The paper will highlight the four ways in which the interaction of the President and Congress is shaped by time. The first reason why that the interaction of President and Congress is shaped by time is because of their time in office and their experience.... [tags: United States, United States Congress]
1331 words (3.8 pages)
- The impact of rotating shift work on police officers in terms of fatigue, increased stress, and other long term medical problems cannot be overstated. In 2011, an in-depth research project, “Sleep disorders, health, and safety in police officers” (JAMA, 2011), was conducted involving a group of North American police officers in regards to the sleep disorders and the health and safety of the officers participating. The study involved 4,957 officers that worked rotating shifts over a period of approximately two years.... [tags: sleep orders, shift work]
1234 words (3.5 pages)
- The Diversification of Congress; Beneficial, Pernicious or Benign. Although the 113th Congress is the most diverse in (Jennifer E. Manning)Gender 98 Women, Ethnicity, Religion 18 specific, Occupations 16 specific, age, sexual orientation 7 openly gay or bisexual and abilities. Yet, it is the most unproductive Congress of more than 60 years. This class, plagued with indications of Internalized oppression and self-destruction, has produced less than 50 laws and has no adherence to the budget timeline this session.... [tags: Congress, Republican Party, Governement]
1027 words (2.9 pages)
- I want to thank every one of you for the support, that you have gave not only on the campaign trail, but also during my two years in the United States Congress, this term. As you know election season is around the corner, and I am hoping to have your support again as we being to campaign for my re-election for the great 5th District of Minnesota. I am writing to inform you all my successes, failures, routines, and what I was responsible for during my time on Capitol Hill. As your representative, I feel that is greatly important to provide transparency to my constituents.... [tags: Democratic Party, United States Congress]
1767 words (5 pages)
- When our government was first created, it was decided that not all the power needed to rest with one division or person. All the power was to be divided into three separate Branches: Legislative, Executive, and Judicial. Each branch would have its own power and laws to follow. This created a system of checks and balances to insure that no corruption or overruling would take place. How each Branch works is deliberate in each action and ruling. The Legislative Branch is made up of congress members.... [tags: Separation of powers, United States Congress]
1728 words (4.9 pages)
- Should Congress Raise Minimum Wage. As our federal government debates the idea to raise the minimum wage, several interesting questions occur. Most important, should we raise the minimum wage. I believe it is a bad idea of raising the minimum wage from $7.25 per to approximately $10.25 in a short period of time, and I will explain why. The main reason raising the minimum wage radically would kill the economy is the pressure it would place on small businesses. Harrison, a reporter with The Washington Post, asks the question, “Are small businesses the back bone of our economy” (pars.... [tags: salary, employee, inflation]
674 words (1.9 pages)
- Background Many controversial topics have surfaced recently, but one that tends to fly under the radar is lobbying. Lobbying is defined as a group of persons who work or conduct a campaign to influence members of a legislature to vote according to a group’s special interests (“Lobby”). Although average citizens are not fully aware of the issue, it is quite contentious in politics. For those who are against it, they believe that restrictions should be placed on lobbying because it distorts democracy.... [tags: politics, democracy, legislation, Constitution]
1636 words (4.7 pages)
- Researching and reading about the many programs and initiatives of the agency was illuminating. Although familiar with several assistance programs, I knew little about how the organization is funded or “actually” operates. The United States Agency for International Development (US AID) was established in the 1960s by an executive order issued by President Kennedy (US AID, 2014). The agency combines development assistance with the promotion of foreign policy to advance US interests abroad (US AID, 2014).... [tags: international organizations, donors]
885 words (2.5 pages)
- ... While I tend to agree with is statement I tend to feel that this number is a little high. I feel there are several people in the US that are the working poor. I tend to agree more with these statements According CNN.com, research from economists David Neumark, Mark Schweitzer and William Wascher found a higher minimum wage results in a net increase in the proportion of families who are poor or near-poverty. The economists all stated the lose from the minimum wages increase out weight the winner.... [tags: economy, salary, business]
601 words (1.7 pages)
- Minorities in Congress In forming a government for the people, by the people, and of the people, our Founding Fathers developed the idea a bi-cameral legislature. This Congress, composed of the House of Representatives and Senate, thus became known as the people’s branch of government. American children are taught in schools that anyone can be elected to Congress, so long as they meet the qualifications of the Constitution. So long as you meet the age and residency requirements you are indeed qualified to be a candidate for Congress.... [tags: Congress Racism Politics Essays]
4214 words (12 pages)