Essay about The Flaws Of An Egalitarian Society

Essay about The Flaws Of An Egalitarian Society

Length: 1797 words (5.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Flaws of an Egalitarian Society

What if, in the society you lived in everyone is identically equal. Equal in every way from religion to laws, looks, strength, and intelligence. Well in the society of the short story “Harrison Bergeron” and short film 2081, that is the case. In the science-fiction short story “Harrison Bergeron” (1961), conducted by author Kurt Vonnegut, Jr., and the short film 2081 (2011), directed by Chandler Tuttle, the idea of a dystopian society of egalitarianism is a prevalent theme that can be examined in depth for both the similarities and differences. Throughout the short story and short film , “Harrison Bergeron” and 2081, there are two main similarities and two main differences linked between the two subjects. The differences being in the power and control of the government and the way George thinks. While the similarities are the government and the characters in the society.

The similarities pertaining to the conception of an Egalitarianism Government throughout both the short story and short film are evidently shown. In both of the exhibitions the government is portrayed as a overruling conglomerate that endeavors to create the “perfect society” by making everyone equal through Egalitarianism. The government controls what is equal in the society, how to make things equal, and the consequences for any retaliation. This portrays that the government is a negative organization and causes the egalitarian society to be a dystopian society. Everyone in the society is equal as quoted in the short story, “The year was 2081, and everybody was finally equal. They weren’t only equal before God and the law. They were equal every which way. Nobody was smarter than anybody else. Nobody was better looking than ...


... middle of paper ...


...very unique plot with two main similarities and two main differences. In both of the stories the government is seen as an overruling factor in the society. They have almost all control over the citizens. The next main similarity is that the characters are almost identical. George, Hazel, and Harrison are all described the same and act in the movie as was identified in the story. However there were two main differences, one being that George thinks of his son Harrison in the movie way more than in the short story. George seems to have an emotional attachment to Harrison that isn’t visible in the short story. The second difference is that the government in the short film comes across as a more overruling, powerful, and imitating conglomerate in the society. Now take a moment and ponder on this statement, what if in the society you live in everyone is identically equal.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The French Revolution Spread The Idea Of An Egalitarian Society

- The French Revolution spread the idea of an egalitarian society. This promise led many women to fight for the revolution with the hopes of gaining their freedom. When the monarchy had been replaced with a legislative government, the equality, liberty, and fraternity promised to women was never fully realized. Women were disempowered during the French Revolution and held more influence during the reign of the monarchy. The Ancien Régime was arguably a more equal society when it came to the roles of men and women....   [tags: Louis XVI of France, French Revolution]

Strong Essays
1342 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of The Article ' Society Flaws '

- “Societies Flaws” In the article written by Schaefer he points out the many flaws in society that most people do not think about and some are ones that are commonly known within society. The overall topic of the article was mainly social inequality which is when members of society are not treated the same because of the amount of money, power and the sex they are. This article was good to read and I believe that most college students should be reading things of this nature. Articles such as this one exposes the youth to the real world one they often do not know about or see....   [tags: Social class, Sociology, Education]

Strong Essays
708 words (2 pages)

One Cannot Legislate an Egalitarian Society Essay

- One Cannot Legislate an Egalitarian Society It is virtually impossible to direct language in a way that will lead us to a more egalitarian society. There are far too many obstacles to overcome. Beyond the ideas of racism or sexism there is also the running debate about religion and the nature of people to always want to win. I believe that we can reach a more tolerant society through teaching and good parenting, however, I do not believe that we could ever have a true egalitarian society....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Essays]

Free Essays
902 words (2.6 pages)

Flaws of Perception in Society: The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald

- Society nowadays can conform anyone, into whoever they want a person to be.Throughout The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Wife of Bath’s Tale by Geoffrey Chaucer, and Brave New World by Aldous Huxley, there is an interconnecting theme of the flaws of perception in society. This theme is shown with various characters throughout The Great Gatsby such as characters having their own perception as to who the main character, Jay Gatsby is, in The Wife of Bath’s Tale it is shown in the way of how the knight judges his wife based off of her physical age and beauty within, and in Brave New World, Bernard, one of the main characters, is in shock of what the reality of this “utopian” society e...   [tags: utopian society, american army, new world]

Strong Essays
1123 words (3.2 pages)

Guns, Germs and Steel by Jared Diamonds Essays

- In this book review I will be discussing chapters twelve, thirteen, and fourteen from the book “Guns, Germs and Steel” by Jared Diamonds. Chapter 12 “Blueprints and Borrowed Letters” talks about the evolution of writing, whereas chapter 13 “Necessity's Mother” talks about the evolution of technology, and chapter 14 “From Egalitarianism to Kleptocracy” talks about the evolution of government religion. Jared Diamond believed that societies developed due to environmental differences. He suggested that some societies and cultures had advantages due to their geography....   [tags: egalitarian society, cultures, logograms]

Strong Essays
929 words (2.7 pages)

John Locke and The Egalitarian Principle Essay

- Considered to be the ‘Father of classical liberalism,’ John Locke established the core values of classical liberalism, which included liberty, individualism, protection of natural rights, consent and constitutionalism. Classical liberalism that developed in the United States focused on a ‘minimal state’ in terms of government restriction while John Locke centralized his focus on the social and political means of the individual. Generally, egalitarianism is defined as “a belief in human equality in terms of social political and economic affairs.” Under this standard, John Locke cannot be labeled an egalitarian in all terms since he does not believe in equality of persons in all aspects....   [tags: classical liberalism, indivualism]

Strong Essays
792 words (2.3 pages)

The New World : An Egalitarian Period Essay examples

- According to Hicks (2014) an egalitarian period existed before Europeans. This period was when Aboriginal people established complex civilizations all across the land. These various civilizations had their own formed social structures that varied with different regional societies. Aboriginals thou varying across the regions had developed their own mechanisms for sharing wealth within the communities. They insured collective responsibilities for the weaker members and upheld these ideas by creating customs....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Colonialism, Culture]

Strong Essays
802 words (2.3 pages)

Can Traditional Marriages Survive Within An Egalitarian Workplace? Essay

- Can traditional marriages survive in an egalitarian workplace. In their article on the subject, Christine E. Stanik, Susan M. McHale, and Ann C. Crouter, all researchers at Pennsylvania State University, found that in some cases egalitarianism can be compartmentalized, and that the workplace does not have to affect the home (Stanik, McHale, and Crouter 797). In those certain cases, traditional marriage and marital love should be thriving as our society adapts to a new era. In an article published by Administrative Science Quarterly, Sreedhari Desai and his coworkers research shows that most strong traditional marriages will be affected negatively by a shift of egalitarianism at work (Desai...   [tags: Marriage, Human sexuality, Sexual intercourse]

Strong Essays
1466 words (4.2 pages)

Othello's Flaws Essay

- The modern world generally prefers characters that have flaws and qualities that are more humanlike. As said by Nicholas Cage, “I like flawed characters because somewhere in them I see more of the truth”. This statement holds much truth as flaws illustrate who the character really is and what their true intentions are. Therefore, characters with imperfections are more likely to have more of an appeal to the public. Many stories, such as Othello by the famous playwright William Shakespeare, have characters that may seem flawless on the outside, but when imperfections are portrayed, the truth is exposed. The character Othello, from the tragedy Othello, is portrayed as faultless in many ways in...   [tags: Shakespearean Literature]

Strong Essays
790 words (2.3 pages)

Flaws In Germinal Essay

- The Flaws in Germinal At first glance, one might say the capitalist system is righteous and it leads to more productivity, but upon discreet examination, the system has numerous flaws. As we discussed in class, one of the main flaws was the inability of the workers to advance themselves in society beyond the point of keeping food in their stomachs. One generation after another follow each other down below into the mines without cessation. First and foremost the company needs to insure that all members of the mine town have enough to eat, enough to wear, and a roof over their head....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
440 words (1.3 pages)