Film Critique: The Red Violin Essay

Film Critique: The Red Violin Essay

Length: 1132 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The movie The Red Violin is a drama written and directed by filmmaker Francois Girard, which follows the history of a mysterious and intriguing musical instrument over the span of 300 years. Francois Girard got the idea for the movie from events involving the legendary red Mendelssohn, a 1720 Antonio Stradivari violin which was purchased in 1990 by the grandfather of celebrated musician and heiress, Elizabeth Pitcairn (Fricke, 2010). The story is artfully and elegantly put together, and although the story is fictional the plot portrays what could be realistic characters, settings and life situations. There are some flaws in the movie however, but the entertaining qualities more than makes up for them.
There are several elements Francois Girard incorporated to make the movie a little suspenseful and more believable; he also uses some symbolic gestures. The movie is almost like a jigsaw puzzle in where you need one piece of the puzzle to get to the next until all the pieces form together to show an end result, giving the movie a little suspense. He achieves this during the scene of the auction of the Red Violin, the last place the violin ends up in Montreal; and while the auction is occurring, he flashbacks to the beginning from when the violin was created and tells the movement of the violin throughout history in chronological order. As he goes to each of the five countries the violin ends up during different time periods, he returns to the auction in between with a bidder representing that country and time period in some manner; whether someone who was directly involved with the violin, or indirectly. Each time he returns to the auction seen, he brings a new perception of the events taken place as if seen through ...


... middle of paper ...


... reviews from the itunes store give the movie a rating of five stars out of five. The movie probably deserves a rating of four to four and a half stars out of five because five out of five is perfect and although close, the movie is not perfect. A common comment made is how the violin causes despair to anyone who plays it. This comment holds no truth. Another common comment made is that the movie contributes something to a broad audience; this speculation could be true because it has many different elements that can appeal to different tastes.



Works Cited

Fricke, R. (2010). History of The “Red Mendelssohn” Stradivarius. Retrieved on
December 6th, 2011 from http://www.elizabethpitcairn.com/html/redviolin
2.asp
Girard, N. (Director/writer), & Fichman, N. (Producer). (1998). The Red Violin.
(Motion picture). Canada, Italy, & United Kingdom.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Priceless Sound of a Stradivarius Violin Essay

- Whenever there is talk of violins, the name Stradivarius always comes to mind. Questions have been asked over the centuries as to how the violins have their unique sound. Is it the varnish. Is it the water. Is it the shape. Or is it perhaps the provenance. Scientists have studied the violins and musicians have studied and debated the sound quality and the superiority of the instruments for centuries. Stradivarius violins are commonly hailed worldwide as the best violins in the world. The sound quality of Stradivarius violins is of unprecedented superiority when compared to other violins, and it is commonly believed that no one has been able to match it in the past three centuries since their...   [tags: music, violin, uniformed density, biography]

Strong Essays
1912 words (5.5 pages)

Film Critique of Dances with Wolves Essay

- Film Critique of “Dances with Wolves” This is a wonderful movie that is set in 1863 during the civil war. The main character is John Dunbar, a Lieutenant in the United States Army, who is played by Kevin Costner. The movie begins with Dunbar in the field hospital with a severely wounded leg that the Dr.’s are planning to amputate. Dunbar decides that he does not want to live minus a leg and leaves the field hospital, takes a horse and rides across the length of the enemy lines where he expects that he will meet his death....   [tags: Soldier, Sioux, Culture]

Strong Essays
1003 words (2.9 pages)

Physics of the Violin Essay

- "String instruments have been played for more than a thousand years. Performance on string instruments has reached a level today that cannot be improved upon, and the quality of instruments built nearly three centuries ago is maintained in the best instrument made today" (Allen, 1). "The violin is a wooden resonance box that amplifies the soundwaves from the vibrations of the strings stretched across it" (Mandy). The most material for the construct the violin is wood; maple used for the back, ribs, and neck) and spruce for the top....   [tags: physics music musical instrument violin]

Free Essays
526 words (1.5 pages)

Essay on Fantasy and Magical Realism in Violin

- Fantasy and Magical Realism in Violin     Violin is a novel by Anne Rice. The genre of the book is fantasy and the text allows for many comparisons to made between fantasy and magical realism.   I felt that there were a lot of fantastic elements in this book. An example of a fantastic element is when Tirana laid in bed with Karl after he died. She kept him in the house for about four days after his death because she didn't want the funeral parlor to burn him; she wanted to be with him forever (8)....   [tags: Violin Essays]

Strong Essays
1158 words (3.3 pages)

The History of the Violin Essay

- The invention of violin was recorded first in Europe during the Medieval ages. This instrument must have developed from the gambs family popular in the 15th century. The clear picture of violin as it is known today came into existence in the 16th century during the Renaissance period. The instrument like others developed steadily with time to a point when it was able to satisfy new ideas of sound. The same style that was used during the old musical periods is still in use today besides a few technical advancements (The History of the Violin....   [tags: music history, medieval ages]

Strong Essays
1177 words (3.4 pages)

The Failures of the Film Adaption of Carol's "Alice's Adventures in Wonderland"

- The inventive world of Wonderland and Alice’s journey in to her own imagination is more then merely a children s story. Looking deep at the symbols and structure of the story one can see that it becomes more complex and abstract as Alice gets deeper and deeper in her journey in Wonderland. Lewis Carol wrote the book in 1876 and Disney produced its own animated version of Alice in Wonderland no more then twenty years ago. The Disney production aimed at a younger audience, shows Wonderland as a very colorful and vibrant place, full of flowers, trees and a majestic garden of wonder and glory....   [tags: Film Analysis, Movie Critique]

Strong Essays
917 words (2.6 pages)

Film/Viewer Interaction in Apocalypse Now Essay

- “The horror... the horror...”- Colonel Kurtz are the last lines of Apocalypse Now, the Francis Ford Coppola directed war-film masterpiece, which truly explores horror. Typical war films, like Kubrick’s Full Metal Jacket or Boulle’s The Bridge on the River Kwai, follow the camaraderie of a protagonist and his unit and their struggles that build up to a violent and climactic confrontation where both sides sustain losses to illustrate the tragedy of war. Apocalypse Now is different; there are only two moments of brief violence that the main character participates in and he rarely talks with anyone else....   [tags: Film Critique]

Strong Essays
1530 words (4.4 pages)

Critique of Film And the Band Played On Essays

- Critique of Film And the Band Played On “And the Band Played On” was an HBO movie that illustrated the AIDS crisis in the 1980s and early 1990s. The movie touched on subjects concerning the reaction of the gay community, the heterosexual community, and the medical community. It showed not only the research in AIDS, but also the way that the US government dealt with it. The movie expressed the consequences the gay community suffered, the plight of the medical community in researching the disease, and the issue of government response to it....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
340 words (1 pages)

Film Critique On The Deer Hunter Essay

- Since 1968, there have been at least 25 films made that portray the events of the Vietnam War. Historians have to ask themselves when watching these films, "Did the fictional character represent historical figures accurately. Is this how a soldier would react in this situation?" The point of view of the director of the film can change with simple alterations in camera angles. For example, a view from the ground of a battle seen can show how the innocent people had the war in their own backyards....   [tags: Movies Film]

Strong Essays
1426 words (4.1 pages)

Violin Essay examples

- Violin Music and art, the feelings that go through a person while the music of Mozart and Beethoven are playing, are indescribable. Listening to music can take a person away to a different era. Music like Mozart or Beethoven can really take a person's imagination soaring in a whole new perspective. Composers throughout the novel, Violin were Beethoven, Mozart, and Tchaikovsky. Violin was a truly fabulous name for this story. It contains many fantastic elements as well as realistic elements; however, it should not be confused with magical realism....   [tags: Literature Music Composers Essays]

Strong Essays
1036 words (3 pages)