Fifth Amendment Rights: Not Valid Outside the United States Essay

Fifth Amendment Rights: Not Valid Outside the United States Essay

Length: 1499 words (4.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Are you always entitled to the protections of the Constitution’s Fifth Amendment based solely on the fact that you are a citizen of or reside in the United States? The Fifth Amendment only applies to people, citizens or not, who are within the U.S. borders. If every person from the U.S. were entitled to the same constitutional rights outside the borders, as they are within, then the U.S. Government would not be able to use extraordinary rendition to interrogate persons of interest. Also, the U.S. Government would not be able to launch attack missions against their own citizens, whom are in a different country, if they were still protected by the Fifth Amendment. Lastly, people from the U.S. would not be held captive indefinitely, in another country for their alleged crimes, if they still had these protections.
Many people in the U.S. believe that a person is entitled to their constitutional rights no matter where they are. People think that simply because one is a citizen or resident of the U.S. one is automatically given these rights and they cannot be taken away for any reason. Others however, feel that a person should be held accountable for any crimes committed no matter where they go or what the punishment is. People constantly debate on the constitutionality of the actions the U.S. Government has taken against different individuals because of this difference in beliefs.
For example, the Government uses extraordinary rendition to get by with using interrogation methods that are not permitted under the U.S. law. According to The New York Times article titled “Rendition, Torture and Accountability” published on November 19, 2007(editorial), extraordinary rendition is “America’s notorious program of outsourcing int...


... middle of paper ...


...en to you by one country when you are being detained in another. The U.S. soldiers faced this same scenario during the Vietnam War, when they were held as POWs. These soldiers were held captive, subject to extreme living conditions, and tortured. They were not able to invoke their Fifth Amendment rights while they were being held captive. If these soldiers, who were protecting the United States, were not entitled to their Fifth Amendment rights, do you think that you will be entitled to yours in a foreign country?



Works Cited

New York Times article "Rendition, Torture and Accountability" published November 19, 2007

New York Times article "North Korea Prepares to Indict American" by Mark McDonald published April 17, 2011

Chicago Tribune article "A Terrorist's Due-U.S. Citizenship is not a Shield from Consequences of War" published on October 6, 2011

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Chinese Immigrants in the United States

-     More than three hundred thousand youths are destined to be unlawful settlers in the United States. Despite the outside citizenship and unlawful status of the guardian, the official extension of the United States government consequently perceives these kids as United States citizens upon conception. The same is valid for kids destined to vacationers and different outsiders who are available in the United States in a legitimate yet makeshift status. Since substantial-scale tourism and mass unlawful migration are late phenomena, it is indistinct for to what extent the United States government has taken after this practice of programmed "bequest citizenship" without respect to the span or l...   [tags: citizenship, illegal aliens]

Powerful Essays
1614 words (4.6 pages)

Current Fourth Amendment Jurisprudence Essay

- Introduction The Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution was drafted by the Framers to protect the right to be free from governmental intrusion. Without a warrant and probable cause, an officer may not enter a home and search it. The use of GPS technology, however, enables the government to collect the same information without ever leaving the office. Thus, GPS based surveillance presents the issue of what protection the Fourth Amendment offers. Current Fourth Amendment jurisprudence offers little protection from warrantless surveillance....   [tags: Fourth Amendment, Rights, United States]

Powerful Essays
1599 words (4.6 pages)

The Importance of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution

- The importance of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution is such that some have called it the amendment that “completed the Constitution.” When it was ratified on July 9th, 1868, the amendment became one of legislative cornerstones of the Reconstruction Era, a time in which the Radical Republicans, led by John A. Bingham and Thaddeus Stevens, promulgated a legislative program focused on providing racial equality before the law. Among the laws passed in the Reconstruction Era, the Fourteenth Amendment was one of the most controversial, with one Republican congressman, Representative A.J....   [tags: reconstruction era, 14th amendment]

Powerful Essays
2896 words (8.3 pages)

Essay about The First Amendment of the United States Constitution

- The United States Constitution was signed on September 17th, 1787. It did not include a bill of rights and it did not include their freedoms. And so, on September 25, 1789 Congress passed the first ten amendments, which were later ratified on December 15, 1791. The Bill of Rights was created by the Founding Fathers with the intent of restricting the powers of the new national government. The Bill of Rights, however, consists of 10 amendments. The first of the amendments was written because the people at America’s establishment wanted their basic freedoms guaranteed....   [tags: amendments, bill of rights, citizen freedom]

Powerful Essays
1064 words (3 pages)

United States Constitution: Amendment Process Essay

- The United States constitution has an amendment process that has been included in the Bill of Rights. The amendment allows Americans to make changes on the September 17, 1789 United States Constitution was ratified and made law. The amendment of the Bill of rights has made America to continue growing in prosperity through the years and to become one of the most powerful nations in the world. The United States constitution was created with an amendment in Article V. This amendment process allows the constitution to adapt to the changes in the American society....   [tags: bill of rights, bear firearms, amendments]

Powerful Essays
1026 words (2.9 pages)

The Codification of the Fourth Amendment Essay

- The most difficult problem that arises for the courts because of technology is the codification of the Fourth Amendment to apply to technological change and progress. The vast changes technology brings to surveillance, security, and data collection offer a challenge to courts in classifying these new technologies and monitoring their use within the limits of the Fourth Amendment. The Fourth Amendment states that people have the right to be “secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures.” An influential dissent written by Louis Brandeis contends that the amendment does not simply protect a person’s property but the “right to be let alone.”...   [tags: technologicals change, privacy, amendment]

Powerful Essays
1212 words (3.5 pages)

The US Constitution: The Difficulty of Adding an Amendment Essay

- The United States Constitution is considered to be more concise as well as much older than the constitutions of other nations worldwide. Although the United States Constitution is mature, there are such a limited number of amendments that have been added to the Constitution since it was created. Only twenty-seven amendments, including the Bill of Rights, have been added to the Constitution since its creation. This is not due to amendments not being suggested, because over eleven thousand amendments have been contemplated; however, this is because the process of adding an amendment to the Constitution is an extremely long and difficult process....   [tags: american history, amendment]

Powerful Essays
1000 words (2.9 pages)

Essay Fifth Amendment and Double Jeopardy

- Fifth Amendment and Double Jeopardy Double jeopardy is the prosecution of a person for an offense for which he or she has already been prosecuted. The double jeopardy clause, which is in the Fifth Amendment of the United States Constitution, was designed to protect an individual from being subject to trials and possible convictions more then once for an alleged offense. The idea was not to give the State too much over the individual, this way no individual will be subject to embarrassment, expense, and ordeal against being tried for an alleged offense more then once....   [tags: Law Legal 5th Amendment]

Powerful Essays
1616 words (4.6 pages)

The Second Amendment of the Constitution Essay

- The Second Amendment “A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed.” This timeless phrase, the Second Amendment of the United States’ Constitution, is an enduring example of the principles and ideals that our country was founded on. With this statement, the founders of this country explicitly and perpetually guaranteed the American individual the right to keep and bear arms. An incomparably crucial element of this country‘s origins, the Second Amendment and the rights it guarantees have proved vital to the growth and success of our nation....   [tags: 2nd Amendment Constitution The Right To Bear Arms]

Powerful Essays
503 words (1.4 pages)

4th Amendment Essay

- 4th Amendment In the late 1700's the 4th Amendment was written because of strong objections to the Writs of Assistance or general warrants. The Writs Assistance gave officials the right to enter any home and seize belongings without a reasonable cause. (Grolier Encyclopedia) The 4th amendment was ratified in the Bill of Rights on December 15, 1771. This amendment protects the people's right to privacy and security. (Encarta Online) The Fourth Amendment states, 'The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affi...   [tags: Government Constitution Amendments History Essays]

Powerful Essays
1098 words (3.1 pages)