Conceptualizations of the public and the private have always been central to the politics of second-wave feminism. The slogan, "the personal is political," implied that private life was often the site, if not the cause, of women's oppression. In 1974, some of the authors of Woman, Culture and Society (Lamphere and Rosaldo 1974), one of the founding texts of academic feminism, asserted that the universal cause of women's oppression lay in their confinement to the domestic sphere. Since that time, anthropologists have modified and complicated their assertions about the private. 1 Many other scholars have turned to confronting the meaning of the public. Joan Landes's anthology represents an important stage in this development.
Landes divides the book into four parts. Part I, "The Public/Private Distinction in Feminist Theory," begins with the oldest essay in the book, Sherry Ortner's "Is Female to Male as Nature is to Culture?," published originally in Woman, Culture and Society (Lamphere and Rosaldo 1974). Mary Dietz's "Citizenship with a Feminist Face: The Problem of Maternal Thinking," a critique of Jean Bethke Elshtain, and Bonnie Honig's "Towards an Agonistic Feminism," a defense and "radicalization" of Hannah Arendt, also appear in this section.
Seyla Benhabib's "Models of Public Space" lays out two important themes: 1) the fact that the split between the public and the private always has been and, she avers, should always remain open to negotiation and 2) the need to take into account and to criticize the work of German philosopher, Jürgen Habermas. "All struggles against oppression in the modern world begin by re-defining what had previously been considered 'private,' non-public, ...
... middle of paper ...
...es has done a great service in bringing these previously published essays together. All are stimulating; many are truly excellent. Yet I wonder: Where is the private in this analysis? What are its distinctive functions, comforts, and benefits? Are some of the authors too sanguine about our ability to protect our private lives? What might be the dangers of legitimating an embodied and particular political presence (and multiple, raucous publics)? As I [End Page 181] conclude this review, President Clinton has been impeached for a private act made public, and the most public act of all, the bombing of another country, has raised little debate. These events should force us to confront anew our conceptualizations of the public and the private--as well as our presence and role in public life. The discussion, to which this volume makes a significant contribution, continues.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- ... They openly rallied against the essentialist idea that domesticity was natural to femininity and that presence in public spaces was designed for only men who, unlike women, were the “natural proprietors of religion, ritual, politics, and other realms of cultural thought” (Ortner 1996, 33). This push for female equality made Australia the second country in the world to provide women the right to vote (however, this is with the notable exception of indigenous women, which will be examined further on).... [tags: Feminism, Gender, Third-wave feminism]
1253 words (3.6 pages)
- Redefining Public and Private "Public and private are imbedded within a dense web of associational meanings and intimations and linked to other basic notions: nature and culture, male and female... The content, meaning, and range of public and private vary with the exigencies of each society's existence and turn on whether the virtues of political life or the values of private life are rich and vital or have been drained, singly or together, of their normative significance." The mantra of second wave feminism, "the personal is political," signifies the first attempt to break down the gendered division between the private sphere attributed to women and the public sphere of men.... [tags: Equality Gender Papers]
3855 words (11 pages)
- ... The second wave feminism come to the bow again in the late 1960’s.Feminism since this time has become a major influence to all women worldwide including third world countries. According to (Evans, 1995) there were extreme power differences between males and females mainly in regards to class. Women became seen as own by men through marriage being seen as their private property. Although feminism was widely influential to most, women still found themselves kept by male activists to a traditional role.... [tags: Feminism, Women's suffrage, Third-wave feminism]
2031 words (5.8 pages)
- The issue at the heart of the David Fincher film, Fight Club, is not that of man’s rebellion against a society of “men raised by women”. This is a film that outwardly exhibits itself as promoting the resurrection of the ‘ultra-male’, surreptitiously holding women accountable for the decay of manhood. However, the underlying truth of the film is not of resisting the force of destruction that is ‘woman’, or of resisting the corruption of manhood at her hand, but of penetrating the apathy needed to survive in an environment ruled by commercial desire, not need.... [tags: Feminism]
2133 words (6.1 pages)
- Feminism is the movement towards women’s equality. It fights for equal rights in the social, political, cultural and economical aspects for women. Feminism also fights for equal opportunity for women in employment and education. A feminist is someone who advocates their support for women’s rights but is not restricted to only women; anyone who supports women’s rights and equality are feminists, including men. Feminism is not only about the females, it fights for gender equality for all. Feminist movements, or Women’s movements, campaign for reforms in household issues with domestic violence, political issues with equal pay, employment and maternity leave, and reproduction rights.... [tags: Feminism, Women's rights, Women's suffrage, Law]
1681 words (4.8 pages)
- Why Men Should Teach Feminism We were asked to focus on three questions related to men and feminism: first, what leads us to teach feminism; second and third, can or should a man teach courses or topics on feminism. While my short answer to each question is “yes,” I have carefully examined my ideological history and experiences teaching women’s studies to be more certain of my response. Not all of the varied aims of women’s studies and feminist activism are directed toward the sensibilities and status of men, nor should they be, but men are still an important audience for feminist discourse and should play a more active role in teaching feminism.... [tags: Feminism Feminist Women Criticism]
2168 words (6.2 pages)
- ... However, most of the nurses did not acquire the proper medical skills that they needed after the war. Malka revealed that nurses’ work has been recognized as the work that “medicine rejects or fails to see.” Nurses were not valued as reliable health care professionals. In addition, hospitals had nurses that casted different and unusual roles. “Some expected their nursing staff to perform an almost unrealistic range of procedures” such as “setting up their patients on respirators or even mowing the hospital’s lawn.” Rather than providing the high quality care for their patients, nurses were ordered to do other responsibilities that did not involve nursing.... [tags: world war II, unrecognizable profession]
1629 words (4.7 pages)
- Liberal versus Marxist Feminism and Women in Corporate America Liberal feminists believe that oppression and inequality must be justified. In other words, any inequality between genders must be explained and justified, in order for it to be accepted by the liberal feminists. According to our textbook, the liberal feminism originated from the social contract theories. Such theories state that all forms of social domination or authority must be justified, according to the textbook. Liberal feminists hold a view that every member of the society should be equal.... [tags: Papers]
3094 words (8.8 pages)
- In contemporary society, hegemonic masculinity is defined by physical strength and boldness, heterosexuality, economic independence, authority over women and other men, and an interest in sexual relationships. While most men do not embody all of these qualities, society supports hegemonic masculinity within all its institutions, including the educational institute, the religious institute and other institutes which form the ideological state apparatus. Standards of masculinity vary from time to time, from culture to culture.... [tags: Manhood Hegemonic Masculinity]
829 words (2.4 pages)
- Feminist Perspective on Eighteenth Century Literature Feminism during the eighteenth century has come to be defined by the literature of the time. Women, who did not have as many outlets as they do today, expressed their political opinions through literature itself. Although feminist texts existed before the end of the century, women writers in the final decade were seen as more threatening to the dominant patriarchal system. Following the overthrow of the government in France, women in Britain believed that "a revolution in sentiments, manners, and moral opinions was possible in their own country" (5).... [tags: feminism]
1155 words (3.3 pages)