Essay on Federalism Is The National Drinking Age Policy

Essay on Federalism Is The National Drinking Age Policy

Length: 1323 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Federalism definitely improves our American Democracy. It allows Local and State governments to be more important for its citizens and be more responsive to them. Federalism, at least in the United States, is the concept of both national and state governments having shared powers and authority of over matters - such as policies - that the other may not have. The state government has some autonomy, or authority, to pass those policies without needing the national government and vice versa. One simple example on how Federalism works is the national drinking age policy. The national government wanted to establish a minimum age for one to buy or consume alcohol. Since Congress could not simply pass a law making it so, they withheld federal highway funds from states who would not implement the proper drinking age. Congress’ mindset was: if younger people are drinking, your highways aren’t safe, therefore we withhold the funds needed to maintain your roads and highways. There are many aspects to Federalism. There is Dual/Layer Cake Federalism, where levels of government (local, state, national) do not interfere with each other, just like the cake. There is Cooperative/Marble Cake Federalism where the levels do interact with each other. Picket Fence Federalism is where the horizontal boards of a picket fence portray the different governments, while the vertical boards represent policies in which all governments have a part in. Coercive Federalism is when the national government essentially coerces the other levels to do or follow something using incentives. All forms of Federalism except Layer Cake are present in our system of government today.

Having a strong role for states can be a double edge sword. One advantage of a strong state...

... middle of paper ...

...e their change through the different Branches. The political outcomes of the Civil Rights Movement were specially tailored to the minority group without taking the majority into account. Dozens of other policies could have passed that could have easily been outdated 10 or 20 years from now because of how easy it is to demand what a group wants.

All in all, Madisonian values are the way to go for American Democracy. Participatory, or Majoritarian Democracy, places too much of an emphasis on majority interests when sometimes the minority interests are what’s best for the country. It does take quite a while and a bit of effort to work the Madisonian system, but it should all be worth it in the end. The time taken to pass certain laws and policies reflects the cooperation of the branches and levels of government and the compromise needed to better the nation as a whole.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Federalism : A Unique Features Of American Constitutionalism Essay

- Federalism: A Unique Feature of American Constitutionalism Three forms of government systems are implemented by countries to govern its people. Most of them are unitary governments, where most of the power resides in the central government. The second form is a confederation, where the government is weak and power is held in the hands of the individuals; the United States began as a confederation, but confederations are rare today. The third system that the United States implements is the federalist government, which is an organization of a nation where two or more levels of government have authority over the same land and people (Edwards III, Wattenburg, and Lineberry 68)....   [tags: United States Constitution]

Better Essays
1422 words (4.1 pages)

Government and Politics - The Benefits of Federalism Essay

- Government and Politics - The Benefits of Federalism In the early days of the United States, it was obvious to many that a system combining both federalism and representative democracy was needed. According to the textbook, “the people were too widely dispersed, and the country’s transportation and communication systems too primitive to be governed [solely] from a central location” (pg. 58). Although today both communication and transportation are highly advanced, America still maintains a federal system....   [tags: Exploratory Essays Research Papers]

Free Essays
885 words (2.5 pages)

Federalism Essay

- Federalism The term "federalism" describes the changing relationship between the national and state governments as they sort out their roles and responsibilities within the federal system. America has a decentralized government; there is no single source of power or center of government. Federalism goes well with pluralism, because of the multiple centers of power that exist in the government, and also the many divisions of power. There are several levels of government including the federal government, the 50 states, county and city governments and independent school districts....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
2586 words (7.4 pages)

The Federal Government And The Theories Of Federalism In The United States

- Federalism Name: Institution: Date: Federalism The federal-state relation has shifted more and more towards national supremacy for almost 200 years now. Certain enumerated powers are delegated to the federal government, while all other powers which are not prohibited by the constitution are reserved to the states. Over the past 20 years, some observers believe that the balance of power is tilting back towards the states. In recent years, the powers of the federal government were limited in favor of the states by the Supreme Court(Schleicher, 2017)....   [tags: United States Constitution]

Better Essays
945 words (2.7 pages)

Role Of The Federal Government During The United States Essay

- The role of the federal government in the United States has expanded drastically over the past century. In 1776, the federal government’s purpose, as outlined by the Declaration of Independence, was to protect individual’s unalienable rights and freedoms. According to the moral philosopher, Adam Smith, government in 1776 had three functions to provide: national defense, an administration of justice, and certain public goods (Lipford). The specific, clearly defined, and limiting functions Smith discusses are not the limits for the modern American government....   [tags: Federalism, United States]

Better Essays
806 words (2.3 pages)

Powers : States And National Government Essay

- Equalization of Powers: States & National Government The systems of the United States government is constantly at a subconscious war in which both sides of our government, the national and state governments, are battling over the obtainment of higher supremacy over the other. “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.” (U.S. Const. amend. 10). Ratified in December of 1791, the Tenth Amendment in the Bill of Rights states that the national government does not have the authority to control the state government’s verdicts that do not intervene with the U.S Constitution and vi...   [tags: United States Constitution, U.S. state]

Better Essays
849 words (2.4 pages)

Drinking Laws Essay

- I. Introduction and Description of Problem (APX 2 PAGES) 1) Statement of the Problem: (5 pts) Eighteen-year olds throughout the United States are considered legal adults in almost every way, with one notable exception: the privilege of having an alcoholic beverage. In every state, eighteen-year olds are legally permitted to drive, live as they choose, and work where they choose. Eighteen-year olds pay taxes as other adults do, are subject to all criminal and civil laws, and are punished, jailed and even executed for crimes they might commit against such laws....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
2562 words (7.3 pages)

Essay on The National Drinking Age Act Of 1984

- The National Drinking Age Act of 1984 was the law that basically told states they had to enact a minimum drinking age of 21 or they would lose up to 10 percent of their federal highway funding. Due to that fact the states quickly complied. This law does not prohibit drinking but outlaws the purchase and public possession by anyone under the age of 21. There are exceptions to this law such as possession and drinking for religious reasons, while in the company of parents, spouse, or guardians who are over the age of 21, medical uses, and during legal employment....   [tags: Drinking culture]

Better Essays
1459 words (4.2 pages)

Lowering The Legal Drinking Age Essay

- Lowering the Legal Drinking Age From 21 to 18 In the United States the legal drinking age, with a few exceptions, is 21; this should be changed from 21 to the age of 18. This would help high schoolers and college students who generally commit the act of underage drinking anyways to avoid long lasting legal repercussions. This would also remove the excitement that many underage drinkers feel since for many, it would now be legal. This would help to lessen temptation and encourage today’s youth to drink in a more safe and responsible environment since it would be considered a normal activity and would no longer need to be done in secrecy....   [tags: Drinking culture, Legal drinking age]

Better Essays
1158 words (3.3 pages)

National Drinking Age Essay

- Have you ever been discriminated against for your own good. Well I and millions of Americans adults that are under the age of 21 have been. There was a bill that was passed by congress called The National Drinking Age Act of 1984. This bullied any state that does not prohibit and single out adults under the age of 21 from buying or possessing alcoholic beverages. In spite of this, many people believe that it is justified because “child’s brain is very sensitive to alcohol” In other words, it is ok to discriminate against a particular group if it is for their own good, instead of it being that discriminating for any reason is wrong....   [tags: Twenty One, Drinking, Teenagers]

Better Essays
938 words (2.7 pages)