The Federal Defense Of Marriage Act ( Doma ) And California 's Proposition 8

The Federal Defense Of Marriage Act ( Doma ) And California 's Proposition 8

Length: 1253 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Supreme Court of the United States, around the time of March 27, 2013, listened to verbal arguments in cases that contest the constitutionality of the federal Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) and California’s Proposition 8 (Anderson, 2013). The issue at the time was whether the government would recognize same sex relationships as marriages and then require every citizen, house of worship and business to do the same. The underlying issue was, can policy pressure and force others to identify and confirm same-sex relationships as marriages.
Ryan T. Anderson does not question whether citizens of the same can love and join into a unified relationship. Mr. Anderson’s argument is based on his belief that marriage can only be between a man and a woman. Mr. Anderson speaks for the American public as a whole when he states that Americans respect marriage a crucial institution of civil society and the building block of all human civilization (Anderson, 2013). This premise of Mr. Anderson’s argument is inductive and weak. This is due to him relying on the group think fallacy to begin his argument. Another premise he uses that is inductive along with being weak is that marriage only exists to bring man and woman together as husband and wife to become father and mother (Anderson, 2013). This premise calls upon the appeal to tradition fallacy, which is just another form of the appeal to popularity fallacy. Unfortunately, the subject of same sex marriage often calls to those who oppose to use certain logical fallacies to provide value to their argument. Joel Clarke Gibbons also used heavy handed words when he describes the institution of marriage as a mystery of the human constitution, and we function in a paradigm of other men and women embed...


... middle of paper ...


...ited States. To do so would make a mockery of the very principles the country was founded upon.
We stand at a significant moment in the same-sex marriage movement. A clear eyed investigation of the same sex marriage movement’s successes and the challenges facing it going forward reveals that though as a society we have begun to shift towards tolerance there is still much ground to be covered (Wilson, 2014). This ground can only be covered when society sees all, whether they are homosexual or heterosexual, as an equal partner within society, but some opponents of same sex marriage dig in and resist the shifting times at all costs. Therefore, it is left to those who see all humans as being equal in the eyes of the law to ensure the very principles the forefathers of the United States be fulfilled and allow no one to be denied life, liberty or the pursuit of happiness.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) Essay

- The Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) is a controversial law in the past as it is now in the present. I chose to write about this law because the concept of gay marriage is being liberally accepted today compared to its heavy intolerance in the past. Today, countless couples are trying to marry yet must face obstacles such as DOMA that hinders their freedom to marry. I, myself, is an advocate for same-sex marriage and learning more about DOMA lets me see what these same-sex couples go through. In this paper, I will discuss the origins of the DOMA, what it encompasses, what the effects are today and in the future, how DOMA affects me, and how DOMA affects Guam....   [tags: freedom , law, homosexuality, LGBT, Guam, US]

Better Essays
895 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on The LGBT Community and the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA)

- As of 2015, the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) community continues to struggle for equal rights held by their straight counterparts. Socially, LGBT persons are subject to discrimination, hate crimes, and stigma, while legally, LGBT persons encounter obstacles that preclude them from basic rights afforded to every other subculture in America. One of the most divisive issues related to LGBT rights has been same-sex marriage, which has been creating conflict both politically and socially dating back to the 1970’s (Finnis, 1997)....   [tags: lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender]

Better Essays
2333 words (6.7 pages)

The Federal Defense Of Marriage Act ( Doma ) And California 's Proposition 8

- The Supreme Court of the United States, around the time of March 27, 2013, listened to verbal arguments in cases that contest the constitutionality of the federal Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) and California’s Proposition 8 (Anderson, 2013). The issue at the time was whether the government would recognize same sex relationships as marriages and then require every citizen, house of worship and business to do the same. The underlying issue was, can policy pressure and force others to identify and confirm same-sex relationships as marriages....   [tags: Same-sex marriage, Marriage, Homosexuality]

Better Essays
1253 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on The Supreme Court and the Defense of Marriage Act

- The legal definition of marriage is a relationship between one man and one women. Now, it seems like the government is trying to redefine what marriage is supposed to mean. There are many points of views on this issue. One could say this is about morality, letting homosexuals to feel happiness in marriage, religion, and the list goes on. This issue of same-sex marriage has been around for a long time, especially in this country. This country has been debating whether or not to legalize same-sex marriage....   [tags: DOMA]

Better Essays
1183 words (3.4 pages)

Defense of Marriage Act Essay

- Within the last month a highly anticipated law suit toward DOMA or the Defense of Marriage Act has come to a close. A federal judge has named portions of DOMA as unconstitutional. The verdict is a large win for those supporters of gay rights, as well as giant loss for those that oppose this type of union (Trotter). To clarify, if this verdict is upheld, federal government would have no say in whether or not to legalize gay marriage. Each individual states government would be held responsible to do so (Trotter)....   [tags: Marriage]

Better Essays
2253 words (6.4 pages)

Essay on The Defense Marriage Act

- The Defense Marriage Act is also known as DOMA. This act has been around for decades and continues to change over the years to shape individuals rights and needs. Individual’s perception of marriage equality is constantly evolving, and the number of government officials that recognize same-sex marriage is constantly changing (Rodriguez & Blumell, 2014). This act not only affects the LGBTQ community and their families, but also affects the whole nation. Many have different opinions on the topic and what should be in the Defense Marriage Act....   [tags: Same-sex marriage, Marriage]

Better Essays
1083 words (3.1 pages)

The Defense Of Marriage Act Essay

- Defense of Marriage Act H.R. 3396 or “Defense of Marriage Act” (DOMA) was passed in 1996. This federal legislation was passed by the one hundred fourth congress of the United States. DOMA defined marriage on a federal governmental level as a legal union between a man and a woman, as well as allowing states to decide on an individual basis whether or not to allow or recognize same-sex marriage as legal marriage (Defense of Marriage Act, 1996). The bill was signed into law on September 21, 1996, by President Bill Clinton (Civic Impulse, 2016)....   [tags: Same-sex marriage, Marriage, Bill Clinton]

Better Essays
1622 words (4.6 pages)

Defense of Marriage Act is Constitutional Essay

- Defense of Marriage Act is Constitutional Introduction The United States Supreme court ruled in Windsor V. United States on June 26, 2013 that the section 3 of the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) is unconstitutional. In this case, the Supreme Court ruled that all loving couples that are married and committed to each other deserve legal respect and treatment, which is equal. This ruling shall have an effect on the married same-sex couples, being treated as any other married couple by the federal government....   [tags: legal issues, same-sex]

Better Essays
1468 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about Defense of Marriage Act

- The LGBT communities have been and continue to struggle with equal rights with their straight counterparts. Many people will argue the notion that they support the LGBT community and feel they should have equal rights as heterosexual individuals; however how many of them will agree that LGBT communities should have the right to marry, adopt, etc. The minute the issue of marriage is brought up, many people will argue that marriage is a union between man and woman. Same sex marriage or marriage among the LGBT community is an issue dating back to the 1970’s....   [tags: Homosexuality ]

Better Essays
1800 words (5.1 pages)

Essay on Defense of Marriage Act

- Defense of Marriage Act Introduction Within our society and the western hemisphere, it is believed that only a man and a woman should be allowed to participate in the sacred ritual of marriage. These beliefs are instilled through the socialization of society and family. Our society illustrates marriage through the media. Our family illustrates marriage by first hand experience. In a traditional family, we perceive a man and a woman as our parents. Traditionally, people marry with the expectation that reproduction will occur, and one will grow old along side of children, and grandchildren....   [tags: science]

Better Essays
1948 words (5.6 pages)