Analysis Of James Lasdun's 'Cleanness'

1299 Words3 Pages

Dehao Liu
Jeff McMahon
English 1C
16 Oct. 2014
The Fallacies of Domination The father in “Cleanness”, a short by James Lasdun in his book It’s Beginning to Hurt, exhibits corruptive fatherly love. The father in this story is insecure. He depends on one of his few social relationships. That is why he adopts an excessively paternalistic and authoritarian approach when dealing with his son, including controlling the various aspects of his son’s daily live. This essay will therefore apply Erich Fromm’s notion of Authoritarian Personality to explain the controlling attribute of the father and how this results in the corruptive fatherly love that he exhibits towards his son that ultimately deters his son’s maturation process, psychologically, …show more content…

But, these concerns are not genuine. These concerns are his means to control his son. The fatherly love in “Cleanness” is corruptive because it prevents the maturation of the son to become an independent individual, and similarly the deceased mother, from asserting control over themselves. The father in “Cleanness” is over-protective and adopts a paternalistic approach that is actually detrimental to the psychological and emotional development of the son, although the father insists that he is only protecting his son through his excessive guidance. Such revelation is evident in the passage when Roland, the son, tries to intervene at the wedding, confides with the young woman with whom his father is marrying. Roland provides this revelation about his father’s controlling and excessively paternalistic character by drawing the relationship “between his father’s vigor and his mother’s steadily decline.” (Lasdun 620) For example, Roland’s father “harangued Roland’s former mother for not pursuing a career, for not seeing a psychiatrist when she became depressed, for drinking too much, for smoking after she was diagnosed with cancer.” (Lasdun …show more content…

Lasdun uses the metaphor of the healthy plant to illustrate the notion. “A healthy plant requires the steady disintegration of the organisms in the soil around it in order to thrive” (Lasdun 623) However, the constant control that the father exerts on Roland and his mom is preventing their natural maturation towards psychological independence. In other words, through this complicated action of the soul, the father’s excessive paternalistic concern for Roland and his diseased mother has resulted opposite effects of what was originally intended. It had kept both Roland and his diseased mother “in thrall to her own failure” (Lasdun 609) In addition, the father claims his perfectionist standards. However virtually everything is far from perfect. By imposing perfectionist standards on them, Roland and his deceased mother are being setup to only fail. In turn, the failure will have significant adverse psychological effects on Roland, because this will undermine his self-esteem and sense of self-efficacy. Over time if this situation does not change, Roland would depend on his father to make decisions for him which I mention as a physical isolation but mental dependence; that he cannot trust himself in making own decisions. However, none of this Roland’s father is aware of.

Open Document