The Fall of Carrie and Hurstwood

The Fall of Carrie and Hurstwood

Length: 916 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
The Fall of Carrie and Hurstwood

Sister Carrie, written by Theodore Dreiser, is a tale of Carrie, who comes to Chicago to somehow make the money she has always dreamed of having. In pursuit of the material possessions and success she dreams of, she involves herself with two different characters, Drouet and Hurstwood. She eventually finds herself in New York, where she has a successful performing career. Even with all the success and material possessions she has attained do not bring her happiness. Due to naturalism and pre-existing conditions between Carrie and Hurstwood, human interactions in exchange for materialism lead to the downfall of the two characters.
Early in the text, it is evident that Carrie has an excessive greed for things such as clothing and money. Upon meeting Drouet, she immediately is blinded to the advantages he can bring her, such as expensive and beautiful clothing. Carrier soon realized all the city had to offer her, such as "wealth, fashion, ease – every adornment for women, and she longed for dress and beauty with a whole heart" (Dreiser, 21). Carrie is aroused by "something promising in all the material prospect" that Drouet had to offer (Dreiser, 5). While her background does subconsciously caution her momentarily, she ignores her misgivings in exchange for the happiness that Drouet's success might bring her. The same things that entice Carrie to Drouet also entice her to Hurstwood.
Perhaps it is safe to say that Carrie came to Chicago in pursuit of the American Dream because of "the drag of a lean and narrow life" (Dreiser, 11). The exchange of her life from dull Wisconsin to Chicago signifies her chase of a better and more fulfilling life. The realization that her life was still "the drag of a lean and narrow life" (Dreiser, 11) hampered Carrie's hope for the American Dream. Carrie was determined to not be "a common shop-girl" (Dreiser, 51). Once Drouet gives Carrie money, he dominates her life because she loves what he possesses. His possessions are Carrie's ultimate dream and goal in life.
Carrie allows other characters in the story to determine her fate and guide her actions. While Carrie is unaware of it, her relationship with Drouet sets up a pattern that drives her relationship with him and other men.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Fall of Carrie and Hurstwood." 12 Nov 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Protagonist in Sister Carrie by Theodore Dreiser Essay

- The picture of the protagonist that Theodore Dreiser’s novel, Sister Carrie, portrays is only a half-truth. By examining Sister Carrie’s character, she is readily deemed as passive, weak, and full of superficial desires and yet in this profoundly inert nature lies the seed for the greater expression of an artistic soul. However, this realization is only drawn out by Ames’s archetypically scholarly eyes (the intelligent but withdrawn engineer); bringing forth the powerful and intimate beauty that Carrie possesses, which without a photograph, the reader would forever remain blind to....   [tags: Theodore Dreiser]

Research Papers
1410 words (4 pages)

Essay on Sister Carrie

- Theodore Dreiser’s Sister Carrie is a simple tale of a young, pretty eighteen year old girl Caroline Meeber also know as Carrie. When Carrie got on the train from Columbia City to Chicago she had only few cheap items in her trunk and her sister’s address on a piece of paper. Being only eighteen she was still "full of the illusions of ignorance and youth"(Dreiser, 7). She was both afraid of the things to come and exited by the countless possibilities offered by one of the largest cities of the late 19th century – Chicago....   [tags: essays research papers]

Research Papers
786 words (2.2 pages)

Characterization in Sister Carrie Essay

- Characterization in Sister Carrie      The theme of unrequited love and unfulfilled ambitions, against a backdrop of a nation being transformed by industrialism and capitalism, provides the substance of Theodore Dreiser's Sister Carrie.  During the late 19th Century we encounter three main characters who demonstrate this underlying motif:  Carrie Meeber, Charles H. Drouet, and George W. Hurstwood.  Carrie will fulfill many of her desires for riches and success, but her insatiable appetite will leave her feeling dissatisfied at the end of the novel and all alone.  With respect to the two men who most covet her affections, Charles Drouet and George Hurstwood we have a study in contrasts.  A...   [tags: Sister Carrie Essays]

Research Papers
1537 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on Is Carrie White The Protagonist Or Is She Not?

- Is Carrie White the protagonist or is she not. According to X.J.Kennedy and Dana Gioia, a protagonist is “the central character in a literary work. The protagonist usually initiates the main action of the story, often in conflict with the antagonist” (Glossary of Literary Terms 2073). The purpose of this essay is to discover why she really is the protagonist. Now some might say she burned down a whole city and killed lots of people, but in Carrie`s defense if someone was bullied their entire life, and went through what Carrie did, who is to blame here....   [tags: Protagonist, Antagonist, Carrie White, Character]

Research Papers
947 words (2.7 pages)

Reversal of Male/Female Roles in Sister Carrie Essay

- Dreiser's Reversal of Male/Female Roles in Sister Carrie The novel Sister Carrie seems to be the platform from which Dreiser explores his unconventional views of the genders. In the world of Sister Carrie, it would seem that the role of women as trusting, caring creatures, and men as scheming victimizers is reversed; it is Carrie that uses the men around her to get what she wants, and it is those men who are victimized by her. Thus Dreiser uses this novel as a means of questioning the popular notions of gender and the role that it plays in modern society....   [tags: Sister Carrie Essays]

Free Essays
532 words (1.5 pages)

Free College Essays - Analysis of Sister Carrie by Theodore Dreiser

- An Analysis of Sister Carrie It was 1889; Carrie Meeber, an eighteen-year-old girl, was boarding a train from Columbia City to start a new life with her sister and her family in Chicago. Columbia City was a small town that did not have much to offer to anyone who wanted to make something of themselves. But in Chicago Carrie believed she would be able to find work and get good money. Chicago, in 1889, had the peculiar qualifications of growth, which made such adventuresome pilgrimages even on the part of young girls plausible1[1]....   [tags: Sister Carrie Essays]

Free Essays
1203 words (3.4 pages)

Huckleberry Finn, Daisy Miller and Sister Carrie as Heroes Essay

- The definition of a hero is not straight-edged. Heroes are, however, imagined to possess certain qualities. Courage, romanticism, charming beauty, and a willingness to defy society are four very prominent characteristics amongst heroes and contribute to today's notion of heroism. In order to decide if and to what extent any character lives up to the standards of heroism, one must search for these qualities. Huckleberry Finn, Daisy Miller, and Sister Carrie are three heroes from three different novels....   [tags: Huck Finn Miller Carrie Hero Heroes Essays]

Research Papers
2356 words (6.7 pages)

Carrie by Stephen King Essay

- The book uses fictional documents, such as book excerpts, news reports, and hearing transcripts, to frame the story of Carietta "Carrie" White, a 17-year-old girl from Chamberlain, Maine. Carrie's mother, Margaret, a fanatical Christian fundamentalist, has a vindictive and unstable personality, and over the years has ruled Carrie with an iron rod and repeated threats of damnation, as well as occasional physical abuse. Carrie does not fare much better at her school where her frumpy looks, lack of friends and lack of popularity with boys make her the butt of ridicule, embarrassment, and public humiliation by her fellow teenage peers....   [tags: Stephen King Carrie]

Research Papers
900 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Antigone And Dreiser 's Sister Carrie

- Women in Society Do women participate more in more often in today 's workforce rather than they did in earlier times. How do the dynamics of the participation, in respect to the times, compare or contrast. In Sophocles ' Antigone and Dreiser’s Sister Carrie, the women must both overcome gender barriers throughout their struggles. Throughout their lives they each displayed strong and pioneering actions. Even when they were looked down upon by men, they persevered. While the number of women who participate in the workforce has increased dramatically since the 1930’s, to what extent they are participating, and the aspects of their participation, still faces gender bias....   [tags: Gender, Gender role, Woman, Transgender]

Research Papers
864 words (2.5 pages)

An Inaccurate Review of The Fall of the House of Usher Essay

- An Inaccurate Review of The Fall of the House of Usher David A. Carpenter, in the form of an essay, addresses Edgar Allan Poe’s short story “The Fall of the House of Usher” by interpreting themes, meanings, style, and technique within the story. His essay review contains many quotes and direct references to both Poe and “The Fall of the House of Usher;” however, Carpenter’s analysis proves itself to be inaccurate. Carpenter repeatedly writes statements of which he claims are true, but then argues contrary points....   [tags: Fall House Usher Essays]

Research Papers
721 words (2.1 pages)

Related Searches

Carrie ignores all uncertainties in exchange for lavish dinners and clothes so that she may experience the American Dream she always dreamed of. To explain Carrie's thoughts, "the old definition: ‘Money, something everybody else has and I must get,' would have expressed her understanding of it thoroughly" (Dreiser, 59). The same characteristics that attract Carrie to Drouet, attract her to Hurstwood, and lead her to her fall.
Hurstwood's upper-class appearance impresses Carrie. Although Hurstwood is married, Carrie seems almost ignorant to the possibility of it due to the lifestyle he lives. The downfall of Hurstwood begins when Carrie realizes that he is married. In response, Carrie decides she wants nothing to do with him since he is married. Hustwood falls in integrity when he steals money. He steals the money to impress Carrie who is aroused by success. Hurstwood is successful in getting Carrie to leave Chicago and move to New York with him. Carrie's decision to do so signifies the downward spiral her life is in since the beginning of her pursuit for money.
Money and success soon fail in New York and Carrie feels dissatisfied as a result. Although Carrie herself now is successful in her career, Hurstwood's evolving failure shows that "her experience in Chicago proved that she had not tried the right way" Dreiser, 339). Carrie tried to become successful through the wrong means in life. Carrie's need for clothing and fancy "ornaments" was not longer being satisfied as it had before. Maybe Hurstwood fails in New York because he expects everything to fall into place and work out for him as it did in Chicago.
Once Carrie leaves Hurstwood, he becomes depressed of the fact that Carrie was going into "a realm which became more imposing as it receded from him" (Dreiser, 419). Carrie was becoming successful as Hurstwood was slowly becoming homeless. Despite the success found in Carrie's performing career, it does not bring her happiness. In the end Carrie considers her sense that there is more to life than what she has so far experienced.
Economic forces presented in the novel allow both Carrie and Hustwood to fall in given circumstances. In exchange for the goods Carrie has or wants, she has nothing to give. The money she earns from the factory proves to never be able to keep up with her desires. Once again, the economic forces took over her when Drouet gave her money. Carrie finds a way to capital on her desires. She feels that Hurstfood is a trade upward and can possibly offer better material conditions.
Perhaps the fall of both Carrie and Hurstwood is a cautionary tale of what happens when someone condenses all human interactions to the exchange for capital. In such as situation, such as Sister Carrie, all emotional and physical relationships are reduced to tradable possessions. As a result, a depressing picture of fallen society remains.
Return to