The Failures of Violence Essay example

The Failures of Violence Essay example

Length: 1600 words (4.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Violence is inherently flawed. In the immortal words of Gandhi, "Victory attained by violence is tantamount to a defeat, for it is momentary." Therefore the most successful strategy for long-lasting peace and independence is nonviolence. This concept is crucial to understand the history of this time period. Violence and the lack of it, nonviolence plays a major role in the play of this chapter. Many question the practicality of nonviolence: “How can it work?” “Why can't armed and powerful opponents simply kill everyone that doesn't agree with them?” The answer couldn't be simpler: because the people will revolt. A few thousand oppressors wielding violence simply cannot control several million determined people. This lack of control is illustrated by four events throughout this chapter.

First, let's take a look at an example of nonviolence at work. In March 1917, nearly 200,000 textile workers in Petrograd, Russia led a citywide strike. Chants such as “Down with the autocracy!” and “Down with the war!” were heard as all the workers swarmed the streets. Soldiers, following orders from the czar, shot down the rioters, but later sided with them. This riot became known as the March Revolution, an example of nonviolent protest (civil disobedience). The March Revolution's holds significance because it was a nonviolent (on the protesters side, at least) way of expressing the belief that Russia should get out of the war.

Did the dissidents get what they wanted? Well, “the role of civil disobedience is to generate a response.” In this case, the response was just what the protesters wanted. The czar abdicated his throne. The March Revolution brought down the czar, and was a step towards giving the people what they want. This shows t...


... middle of paper ...


...

This relates to current events. The United States is currently engaged in the War on Terror. If this lesson from history is really taken to heart, and listened to, we would not send soldiers; instead, we would send diplomats and negotiators. Force only begets resentment, and we will never truly be able to get the Middle East under control. Fundamentally, the mechanism that the United States is using for control is flawed, and so—as long as these means are used—history says that the United States will never win.

To reiterate: violence has failed (as a method to create lasting amity) for totalitarian Joseph Stalin, and the Chinese Communist Party. However, nonviolence (as a method to secure long lasting peace and independence) has been enormously successful for the people of India (led by Gandhi) and the Russians in the March Revolution. Violence never works.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on School Shootings - Failures of Welfare Society

- Schools are no longer a safer environment for teenagers and children in today’s society. Every year, many young lives are taken away due to school shootings. School shootings are widespread issue that seek attention because of their dramatic and frighten nature. These shootings results teenagers who have been harassed or bullied into depression come back with the guns to get revenge. However, School shootings are becoming more and more of an everyday incident around the world. School shooting is an event that is committed by a student with gun violence at a school campus or other institutions....   [tags: Teen Violence, School Violence]

Powerful Essays
2041 words (5.8 pages)

Essay about The Issue of Xenophobia and How it Leads to Violence

- The shocking and outrageous xenophobia, which is an irrational fear or hatred of foreigners, has hit South Africa. I want to discuss this terrible behaviour with you today because I believe it is important that people should know about the issue of xenophobia and how it leads to violence and racism amongst the people within South Africa, as well as the effects it has on South Africa and its people as a whole. I also believe that if people are more aware of this situation, they can educate others and try finding a solution to decrease and possibly prevent the issue of xenophobia....   [tags: xenophobia, south africa, violence]

Powerful Essays
975 words (2.8 pages)

Teen Violence Essay

- Eating disorders. Anger problems. Suicide. When hearing these words, many things come to mind, but the most important thing to know about these words is that they are directly related to teen violence. The website “Family First Aid” tells us that teen suicide is the 3rd leading cause of death amongst adolescents in the United States and half of these yearly suicides are due to teen violence. Many people believe that slight cases of teen violence are just part of being a kid, when in fact they can have extremely awful and life changing effects on teenagers....   [tags: Violence ]

Powerful Essays
2134 words (6.1 pages)

Does Domestic Violence Affect A Child 's Future? Essay

- ... (2012) found that the women felt uneasy even when they weren’t at home in the midst of the abuse happening. There was always a “nagging worry lurking at the back of their minds” (p. 100) that left them wondering what they would find when they returned home. Another contestant reflected on the “loss of emotional support and guidance” from her mother when she needed it most. Mothers who are victims to emotional abuse may “experience a regularly overwhelmed state of mind and be emotionally unable to meet her child’s needs” (Alfolabi, 2014, p.112)....   [tags: Domestic violence, Child abuse]

Powerful Essays
1165 words (3.3 pages)

Woodrow Wilson 's Achievements And Failures Essay

- ... Due to the people wanting more credit flexibility in times of economic expansion and crisis, Wilson pushed for the Federal Reserve Act of 1913 which provided the framework for regulating the nation’s bank, credit, and money supply. The Clayton Antitrust Act prohibits price fixing and interlocking directorates, and made farmers like Wilson more as a President because it applied to them as well. The Federal Trade Commission Act created a board appointed by the President to investigate corrupt, unfair, or anticompetitive business practises....   [tags: Woodrow Wilson, World War I, Treaty of Versailles]

Powerful Essays
1243 words (3.6 pages)

The Rise of Fascism Due More to the Personality of Mussolini than the Failures of Liberal Italy

- The Rise of Fascism Due More to the Personality of Mussolini than the Failures of Liberal Italy In 1922, Mussolini became the prime minister of Italy. This meant the end of Liberal Italy, and the rise of Fascism. Mussolini managed to do this because of his incredible personality, one which helped him be an excellent politician. On the other hand, Liberal Italy failed to fulfill national expectancy, also helping in the rise of Mussolini. The question here is which of the two was more important to the rise of Fascism....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1061 words (3 pages)

Violence On Television Essay

- The issue of television violence and its influence on children’s behavior troubles me. Television violence seems to be becoming abundant and violence seems to be increasing. This may be a dangerous form of entertainment, especially when young children become involved. The majority of television programs viewed by children contain large amounts of violence and inappropriate material. Children’s vulnerability poses as the main problem due to desensitization. Psychologists’ studies report that children become immune to television violence and adopt the behavior as a way of problem solving....   [tags: essays research papers]

Powerful Essays
1021 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Successes and Failures of Sexual Offences Act 2003

- Successes and Failures of Sexual Offences Act 2003 The Sexual Offences Act 2003 was heralded as a response to shifting social attitudes, encompassing the broad libertarian approach towards sexual behaviour that has become increasingly dominant since the Act that preceded it whilst attempting to account for the myriad of more widespread sexual deviancies and abusive practices that were otherwise poorly regulated by existing statute. It was designed as a regularisation of the law on sexual offences giving a modern and consistent perspective upon the particular offences; one that would allow the courts to proceed on a fairer and less discriminatory basis, both in...   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
956 words (2.7 pages)

Can Government Intervention Be Effective In Correcting Market Failures Associated With Alcohol?

- Can government intervention be effective in correcting market failures associated with alcohol. I have chosen to perform a microeconomic analysis surrounding the effect of Alcohol consumption on society. ‘Can government intervention be effective in correcting market failures associated with alcohol’ is the question set. The model I will be exploring is ‘market failure’ ‘where the market mechanism fails to allocate resources efficiently’ (Smith et al, 2006, p.56) The Times ‘Alcohol-related treatment costs the NHS £1.7bn.’ The Telegraph Londoners are losing an astounding 1.68 million working days as a result of alcohol-related absence.’ ‘The Telegraph’ microcosmically displays how the issu...   [tags: Market Economy Taxing Alcohol]

Free Essays
1715 words (4.9 pages)

Essay on Gandhi`s Achivements and Failures

-  Gandhi was an influential figure in our society. He taught many people about equal rights, honouring thy neighbour, and peace and tranquillity. Although at times his actions were deemed improbable and insane nevertheless, they were effective. Life of Mohatama Gandhi; his goals he accomplish for freedom for South Africa; and how Mohatama finally obtained freedom for India. Gandhi, also known as Mahatma Gandhi, was born in the present state of Gujarat on October 2, 1869. He was educated in law at University College, London....   [tags: Mohandas Gandhi Essays]

Powerful Essays
971 words (2.8 pages)