This investigation analyzes what major factors led to the northern victory during the civil war? To assess the different factors and evaluate the impact each had on the victory of the northern army, the investigation focuses on both the army of the Potomac and the Confederate army during the civil war 1861-1865, the battles during the time, the economic situations of both armies, the political leadership of both the North and the South and the military leadership of the Northern and Southern armies.
The two sources chosen for evaluation are Starving the south: How the north won the civil war written by Andrew F. smith and Why the Confederacy Lost edited by Gabor S. Borrit and written by James M. McPherson. These sources are evaluated for their origin, purpose, value, and limitations
B. Summary of Evidence
The union’s naval blockade against the South led to a gradual decrease of the shipment of war material and necessary supplies to the South and affected the export of Cotton the South’s most acceptable collateral (Beringer 54). Historian E. Merton Coulter wrote, “without a doubt the blockade was one of the outstanding causes of the strangulation and ultimate collapse of the Confederacy (Beringer 55). “None of the confederate generals ever understood the facts of modern war, that war and statecraft were one piece…. the northern generals were able to employ new ways of war (Donald 41). When the war began there was 23 northern states fighting for the union and only 11 confederate states fighting for the confederacy. (Robertson jr. 7). The population of the North was 22,000,000 people and the South’s population was 9,105,000 people. The North also had more men fight in the army than the South did (Robertso...
... middle of paper ...
...shing, 1992. Web. 30
McPherson, James M. Why the Confederacy Lost. Ed. G. S. Boritt. New
York: Oxford UP, 1992. Print.
Potter, David M. "Jefferson Davis and the Political Factors in Confederate Defeat." Why
the North Won the Civil War. By David Herbert Donald and Richard Nelson.
Current. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State UP, 1960. 93-113. Print.
Robertson, James I. The Civil War. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Civil War Centennial
Ropes, John Codman, and W. R. Livermore. The Story of the Civil War: A Concise
Account of the War in the United States of America between 1861 and 1865.
New York: G.P. Putnam's Sons, 1894. Print.
Smith, Andrew F. Starving the South: How the North Won the Civil War.
New York: St. Martin's, 2011. Print.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The Civil War that took place in the United States from 1861 to 1865 could have easily swung either way at several points during the conflict. There is however several reasons that the North would emerge victorious from this bloody war that pit brother against brother. Some of the main contributing factors are superior industrial capabilities, more efficient logistical support, greater naval power, and a largely lopsided population in favor of the Union. Also one of the advantages the Union had was that of an experienced government, an advantage that very well might have been one of the greatest contributing factors to their success.... [tags: American History]
2114 words (6 pages)
- The person that has made the greatest impact on our country is Abraham Lincoln as he was a prominent leader who led his people to victory during the Civil War, he enacted on many measures to abolish slavery, and he delivered one of the most powerful, influential, and memorable speeches in American history. During the Civil War, Lincoln made many decisions that went against the laws. But by doing so, the people who fought by his side were ensured that they will emerge victorious. When it came to slavery in the United States, Lincoln was extremely against it.... [tags: American Civil War, Abraham Lincoln]
895 words (2.6 pages)
- Comparing the American Civil War with the Marvel Civil War In April of 1861, the American Civil War broke out. In June of 2006, the Marvel Civil War broke out. 145 years of separation still bind these two seemingly unrelated events. The nonfiction and fiction worlds may come across as totally different. One involves actual American heroes fighting over abolition versus slavery and federal versus states’ rights while the other involves fictional American superheroes fighting over freedom versus security, individual rights versus the need for regulation.... [tags: American Civil War, Confederate States of America]
1541 words (4.4 pages)
- From 1860 to 1865, the United States faced one of the most divisive events in its history, known as the American Civil War. The war pitted families, neighbors, and friends against one another, resulted in high rates of casualties, and ended slavery in America once and for all. Much debate about the war and precisely what it meant for America has occurred since the time. President Abraham Lincoln once referred to the Civil War as a “new birth of freedom” in the United States, however the war more closely resembled the last fight of the American Revolution.... [tags: American Civil War, United States]
752 words (2.1 pages)
- The Civil War: The Battle of Gettysburg & The Gettysburg Address The topic of relevance that has been selected for this research paper is The Gettysburg Address. The Civil War can be considered as an intense time period for the United States in that it created a sense of divide within the boundaries of the Nation. President Abraham Lincoln’s presentation of The Gettysburg Address proves to be an important speech throughout history, because of his forward thinking point of view. This paper will present the items leading up to The Gettysburg Address including the actual Battle of Gettysburg.... [tags: American Civil War, Abraham Lincoln]
1057 words (3 pages)
- The Right To Fight A fire was raging between both the northern and southern states in America, even before President Abraham Lincoln took office. The southern states had been threatening to secede from the Union because they objected to the black liberation views of the north. When President Abraham Lincoln won the presidential election in 1860 the confederate states carried out their threat, they refused to be governed by anyone who did not share their same views of white supremacy. Meanwhile, the black men in America stood up, and rushed over to President Lincolns call for volunteers, only to be rejected.... [tags: American Civil War, Abraham Lincoln]
1222 words (3.5 pages)
- Chapter 21: Big Question: The outcome of the civil war was influenced by men, materials, money, and motivation. Between the North and South, the North had the advantage of a larger population, which allowed for more men to be sent off to fight. The North was also more industrialized than the South, and due to its massive amounts of factories, was able to supply a large amount of needed materials to the Union troops compared to that of the rivals. Money wise, although the south was known for its wealthy landowners who owned hundreds of slaves, in reality, these people made up only a tiny percentage of the population.... [tags: American Civil War, Abraham Lincoln]
958 words (2.7 pages)
- The Civil War was at most one of the darkest hours in United States history. Bloodshed and loss quaked the land of our forefathers in a way we could not imagine. In the wake of the battles, the Union forces found new hope in their victories and came out on top in the victory of the war. In the hope to reconstruct the United States Abraham Lincoln proceeded with the new idea of reconstruction. The main idea was to give the freed slaves more rights and try to condone for the sins of the past and present.... [tags: American Civil War, Abraham Lincoln]
948 words (2.7 pages)
- Victory and Loss in the Russian Civil War History tells us the Bolsheviks (reds) did manage to eventually seize power over Russiain October 1920, however the question many historians ask is, 'did the reds win due to their careful planning, strength and unity, or was it purely down to the failures of their opposition, the whites?'. I will be looking at the possible answers to this question in this essay. The red army consisted of many different groups of people, old provisional government supporters, old tsarist soldiers, nationalists and separatists (who wanted independence) and basically anyone who hated the Bolsheviks and their ideas.... [tags: Papers]
687 words (2 pages)
- The 1850's were a turbulent time in American history. The North and South were seeing total different views on the issue of slavery. The North saw slavery as immoral and that it was unconstitutional. The south on the other hand saw slavery as their right. The South viewed African Americans as lower human beings which justified slavery. "The 1850's was a time of attempted compromise when compromise was no longer possible." This quote best describes this time period, because Americans were trying to compromise their views to prevent a large conflict, but there were many events which made a compromise impossible.... [tags: American History Civil War]
866 words (2.5 pages)