Essay on The Exposure of Valerie Plume as a CIA Operative

Essay on The Exposure of Valerie Plume as a CIA Operative

Length: 3183 words (9.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

On July 6, 2005, a federal judge ordered Judith Miller, journalist for the The New York Times, to jail. Miller was involved in the exposure of Valerie Plume as a CIA operative. In questioning, Miller invoked reporter’s privilege by refusing to disclose the identity of her sources, fueling fire to a heavily debated ethical issue in the field of journalism (Pinguelo, “A Reporter’s Confidential Source…Revealed?”). Successful journalism tells the truth to a public who has the right to know it. Journalists have the responsibility to tell us a story laden with facts and the more important responsibility of revealing the source of their information, right? Not necessarily. The right of journalists to keep their sources private has been a long-standing debate. The ethics in this debate are blurry. On one hand, it may be extremely important to the issue at hand that the source of information be known, as an argument could lose credibility otherwise. On the other hand, the source has the right as an American and an individual to remain anonymous. Isn’t it enough that he or she came forward with information at all? Judith Miller’s case garnered public attention and is just one example of many instances that raise the same, consistently debated question- how far can journalists go in protecting their sources and under what circumstances does withholding the identity of a source become unethical for either party involved? The answer to this question is obscure, but solvable. Journalists should have the right to protect to identity of a source unless the information they possess is for the greater good of the public or the situation at hand.
Sometimes journalists must withhold information to reveal information. Doctors, lawyers, and even pries...

... middle of paper ...

...t Media. Huffington Post, November 2012. Web. 19 November 2013.

“First Amendment.” Cornell University Law School. Legal Information Institute, n.d. Web. 18 November 2013.

Pinguelo, Fernando M. “A Reporter’s Confidential Source…Revealed?” National Academy of Television Arts and Sciences. July 2007. Web. 14 November 2013.

Reuters. “Katie Holmes Settles $50 Million defamation Lawsuit Against Star Magazine Over Drug Addict Story”. The Daily News, 28 April 2011. Web. 19 November 2013.

“The Reporter’s Privilege Compendium: An Introduction.” Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, n.d. Web. 15 November 2013.

Shepard, Alicia. “Deep Throat’s Legacy to Journalism”. NPR Books. 19 December 2008. Web. 14 November 2013.

Soghoian, Christopher. “When Secrets Aren’t Safe With Journalists”. The Opinion Pages. The New York Times, 26 October 2011. Web. 17 November 2013.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Art Exhibition Review: Valerie Andrianoff Essay

- The Gallery presented a set of bronze sculptures made by a French artist called Valerie Andrianoff. Val’s works of art can be perceived as a search for balance and stability as the heading of this exhibition has already suggested “The Balance of Life” (Byrs-Lasquier, n.d.). In the following, a few of her works will be selected to illustrate what kind of ideas she is trying to express and how I feel about these sculptures. Most of the human figures created by Val are small. We can rarely see their facial expression....   [tags: Valerie Andrianoff]

Term Papers
1089 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on The CIA Committed Illegal Acts

- 1. Intro A. Why the events were important B. The basic problems that came with these events C. Why they could have happened 2. Paragraph 1 A. Rockefeller Papers B. How it influenced the people about the accusations 3. Paragraph 2 A. CIA incidents B. What they were accused of C. The accusations 4. Paragraph 3 A. OPEC B. Describe the events that lead up to this C. Why OPEC decided to do this D. US response to the oil prices 5. Paragraph 4 A. How these tie together or how they don’t B. Influences on society C. Over all reactions 6. Conclusion A. Bring together all thoughts B. How some of this could have been solved C. Our thoughts about the government Democra...   [tags: CIA Above the Law]

Free Essays
1140 words (3.3 pages)

Valerie Martin’s Novel Property Essay

- Valerie Martin’s Novel Property is an engrossing story of the wife of a slave owner and a slave, whom a mistress of the slave owner, during the late 18th century in New Orleans. Martin guides you through both, Manon Guadet and her servant Sarah’s lives, as Ms. Gaudet unhappily lives married on a plantation and Sarah unhappily lives on the plantation. Ms. Gaudet’s misserableness is derived from the misfortune of being married to a man that she despises and does not love. Sarah, the slave, is solely unhappy due to the fact that she is a slave, and has unwillingly conceived to children by Ms....   [tags: Property Valerie Martin Literature Analysis]

Term Papers
1288 words (3.7 pages)

Analysis of Mary Reilly by Valerie Martin Essay

- Analysis of Mary Reilly by Valerie Martin The book Mary Reilly is the sequel to the famous The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde by Robert Louis Stevenson, is a stark, ingeniously woven, engaging novel. That tells the disturbing tale of the dual personality of Dr. Jekyll, a physician. A generous and philanthropic man, his is preoccupied with the problems of good and evil and with the possibility of separating them into two distinct personalities....   [tags: Mary Reilly Valerie Martin Literature Essays]

Term Papers
5228 words (14.9 pages)

Essay The 1954 CIA Coup in Guatemala

- The 1954 CIA Coup in Guatemala The 1954 coup that deposed the democratically elected government of Guatemala has long been acknowledged to have been the result of CIA covert action. Recently declassified documents have shown a new, and more sinister light, on the CIA's involvement in an action that gave birth to some of the most brutally dictatorial regimes in modern history. No one at this point will dispute the original involvement, but there are still those who maintain that this is all water over the dam of history and that the US has not had direct responsibility for the actions of a Guatemalan government since the 1954 coup....   [tags: CIA Guatemalan Government Economy Essays]

Free Essays
4707 words (13.4 pages)

Essay on The CIA and MKULTRA

- The CIA and MKULTRA For many Americans, the 1950s were a docile decade. In U.S. history books, the period is mostly portrayed as a mellow, orderly one, especially in light of the social upheavals that followed in the 1960s. But for the Central Intelligence Agency, the “I Like Ike” years were packed with adventure and action, much of it conducted outside of the public’s view. Few programs were sheltered with more secrecy than the Agency’s mind control experiments, identified together with the code-name MKULTRA....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
958 words (2.7 pages)

Essay about The CIA

- The CIA Thinking in the philosophical terms of "good" and "evil," nothing purely "good" can survive without the slightest taint of "evil," and vice-versa. The same standard exists for everything. Just as you cannot always succeed by being purely honest, a government cannot hold itself together without committing it's own personal rights and wrongs. The United States of America has protected its residents well in the past, and kept the appearance of a mild innocense; well, most of it, anyway....   [tags: Papers]

Term Papers
2844 words (8.1 pages)

The CIA Essay examples

- The CIA The CIA has committed many autocracies in the name of national security. Some of these include assassination attempts, assisting militia groups in overthrowing governments and other acts that are not all legal or morally accepted. These actions have some justification, which unlike many of their files remains classified, to keep a democratic rule over the world and gain as much as possible to maintain our power. The CIA has its roots with COI the then became OSS which was based on Britain’s SOE ....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
784 words (2.2 pages)

Valerie Essays

- Valerie glanced around the dimly lit ballroom. Two hundred candles are lit, all having a plain wax smell. The room in empty besides a large wooden table in the middle of the large room with twelve silver chairs surrounding it. Valerie's stiff, platinum blonde hair just falls over her shoulders. She's wearing a tight, black leather dress that uncomfortably hugs her skin. Suddenly a man with untidy, slick, black hair and crimson red eyes is standing in front of her. "They haven't changed yet," he said, staring straight into her brown eyes....   [tags: Dialogue Essays]

Term Papers
600 words (1.7 pages)

CIA Essay

- The Central Inteligence Agency The CIA is one of the U.S. foreign inteligency agencies, responsible for getting and analyzing information about foreign government, corporations, individuals, and reporting such information to the various branches of the U.S. government. The State Department's Bureau or inteligence and reserch and theDefense Department'sdefense inteligence agency comprise the other two. Its headquarters is inLangley, Virginia, across the Potomac River from D.C. The Agency, created in 1947 by President Harry S....   [tags: essays research papers]

Term Papers
2051 words (5.9 pages)