The law is by all accounts is recognised as being indisputable fact, uncontestably some might say while morals can be argued either way. Just in the same way laws can be changed instantly but morals evolve and come to change over time. Finally Morals are enforced by social and domestic pressure such as that of religion. There are some instances when the law is heavily influenced by morals of the time and what society sees as correct and other laws where not a trace can be found.
When discussing the law and morals there is an age old argument of which came first? Was it laws that were influenced by morals, or morals that were transformed into laws? For theorists like Hart who believe that morality and laws are distinctly separate. We should have laws that govern are behaviour and we have morals which are what some think should not guide how we live our lives. Devlin on the other hand is a natural law theorists who believes that a law is not valid or should be respected unless it is verified by a higher being. If it doesn’t conform to what god deems is right then a law is not worth obeying in his eyes. The debate centres around the Wolfden Committee report 1957, which laid out the decriminalising of prostitution and homosexuality. Hart argues that we should not be constrained by the views of some on the premise, that if no one is being hurt in the process, then applying this to the issues in hand as long as no one is being forced to do something against their will. Then there should be no reason why not to legalise it. Whilst Devlin who was devoutly religious believed that these activates went against gods wishes and the...
... middle of paper ...
...be controlled by the law or they should have influence over what the law says is not always clear. Although undoubtedly religion has decreased and its hold on the views of society and what is moral have declined. Especially In regard to issues such as homosexuality and abortion. I think however it is important to respect everyone’s views and let everyone have a say on issues in hand including religious group. Just as those who like hart see the law and morality as being separate have a view. On issues such as euthanasia I think it is inevitable that eventually some assisted suicide will be made legal which In my view is a good thing, to me it seems morally wrong to keep someone who is experiencing such a bad quality of life alive and to me it’s beyond ridiculous that if they are of sound mind and wish to end their life to put themselves out of pain that we stop them.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- ... It aims to create laws that are predictable, that are able to be easily analysed and understandable by the general society. Morality is what the society regard as right and wrong which is highly subjective, some legal philosophers believe that there is a certain moral standard which human laws must contain. Chapter 2 in The Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 which is the Bill of Rights contains moral values which the country is based. Section 1 of the Constitution provides that South Africa is an independent sovereign, democratic state which was based on following values: ‘Human dignity, achievement of equality and advancement of human rights and freedom, Non racial... [tags: society, obey, positivism]
1265 words (3.6 pages)
- The hermeneutic perspective corroborates to the study, discussing the importance of assessing the norm by law professionals by producting and reproducting scientific and academic thoughts about the contribution of constitutionality controls to legal systems. In one small aspect, Gilmar Mendes teaches, that the work of interpreting the Constitution begins when it frustrates the direct communication with your text and it no longer responds to questions from your readers. It is the readiness that integrates to fix the meaning of the Constitution rules of law (MENDES, GILMAR.... [tags: Law, United States Constitution, Constitution]
1609 words (4.6 pages)
- BOOK I. RIGHT AND WRONG AS A CLUE TO THE MEANING OF THE UNIVERSE 1. Explain what Lewis means by the “Law of Nature” or the “Law of Human Nature.” Lewis means that the “Law of Nature” implies humans’ natural choices. He implies that many people today perceive the Law of Nature as gravity or other scientific option which is non-negotiable; however, Lewis states that the “Law of Nature” that he is speaking of implies a negotiable topic. One may choose to follow it or to not follow it. 2. When people are quarreling, to what are they appealing when they say, “How’d you like it if someone did the same thing to you?” (p.... [tags: Religion, Morality, Universe, Ethics]
2067 words (5.9 pages)
- “We can’t allow gays to marry. What would be next. Incest?” Opponents of gay marriage frequently cite a common philosophical fallacy known as the "slippery slope", to relate same-sex unions to incestuous relations. According to the Purdue University writing center, a slippery slope is defined as “a conclusion based on the premise that if A happens, then eventually through a series of small steps, through B, C,..., X, Y, Z will happen, too, basically equating A and Z” (“Logical Fallacies”). However, we often ignore the true moral implications of these “next level” immoralities we would slip into.... [tags: incestuous relations, family relationships]
1063 words (3 pages)
- “The trial of Socrates: A vehicle to analyse the Jurisprudential question as to why in a Modern Constitutional Democracy the Citizen has the duty to Obey the law” WHAT IS LAW Law in my view may be described as a set of rules that are manmade, through the formal legislative frameworks such as the parliament, with the intention of regulating aspects of life of those subject to it.( "Province of Jurisprudence Determined”) It generally governs the social behavior of its subjects and affords rights, but also imposes duties and responsibilities on them with the purpose of creating order and certainty.... [tags: morals, obedience, sanctions]
878 words (2.5 pages)
- Torture is a controversial topic in today’s society. What is torture. Torture can be defined as, ‘the act of inflicting excruciating pain, as punishment or revenge, as a means of getting a confession or information, or for sheer cruelty.’(Dershowitz, A) According to international law, it is illegal to use torture in any situation of any kind. Though torture undoubtedly continues throughout the world, the moral argument prohibiting torture should or could be justified. However, the question of torture has resurfaced in the context of the “Is There A Torturous Road to Justice” mainly focusing on the attacks of 911.... [tags: The Ethics of Torture]
1664 words (4.8 pages)
- The Rule of Law The rule of law maybe defined in brief as a doctrine that no individual, however powerful is above the law. In principle Rule of Law had a significant influence on attempts to restrain the arbitrary use of power by rulers and the growth of legally enforced Human Rights in many western countries. It is often used as a justification for separately legislative from judicial power, this can be clearly seen within the government structure of the UK.... [tags: Papers]
451 words (1.3 pages)
- Hawthorne depicts the social repression of the society in the 17th Century, which involved the use of psychic repression to ensure control over the subjects. The law prohibited things that were perfectly fictitious about people’s instincts and desire in order to persuade them into believing that they had intentions consistent with the restricted fiction. As a result, the law is able to achieve the intention to make the unconscious guilty. An example of psychic repression is the casual plot of Hester‘s disobedience and obedience between the transcendental law of erotic aspirations and the law of marriage with its own sanctification.... [tags: Morality, Sin, Meaning of life, The Scarlet Letter]
1145 words (3.3 pages)
- Robert Ferguson speaks of 'untold stories in the law' (84); Toni Morrison’s novel Beloved contains both the untold stories in the law, as well as untold stories in history. Morrison uses each character in Beloved ' Sethe, Baby Suggs, Denver, Beloved, Paul D., etc. ' as a representation of the complex ideas of the collective strife, the collective oppression, suppression and repression, that each slave in some way personally encountered - ideas that law was specifically written not to allow either expression or documentation.... [tags: Toni Morrison]
1357 words (3.9 pages)
- Research paper: Can we be good without G-d. In the discussion of morality and ethics, one controversial issue has been discovering if morality had actually came from a divine being or if it had just came to be. On the one hand, many non-theists and evolutionists argue that morality is a basis for human interaction and it is mandatory that we should have developed some sort of foundation of ethics to co-exist with our fellow beings. On the other hand, most Christians and people of religious back ground contests that this G-d had created us and there for he crated ethics, and morality.... [tags: Morality, Religion, God, Evolution]
1041 words (3 pages)